compare the Pennsylvania and U.S. preambles, explain what the Pennsylvania Constitution does, and name the three branches of Pennsylvania’s government and their leaders.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Both preambles begin with the same three words. Guess what they are. Then list one thing a state government does for you that the national government does not.
What three words do both preambles begin with?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Compare, then explain. When historians compare two documents, they look for what is the same, what is different, and why. Today you will write a claim, evidence and reasoning (CER) answer comparing the two preambles.
Same. Both begin with the people, which shows popular sovereignty. Both say the people “ordain and establish” the constitution. Both set up three branches.
Different. The U.S. Preamble lists six goals for the government. Pennsylvania’s Preamble gives thanks to God for liberty and asks for guidance, and then Pennsylvania puts its list of rights first, in Article I. The U.S. Constitution added its Bill of Rights later, at the end.
Pennsylvania’s three branches today. The legislative branch is the General Assembly, with a Senate of 50 members and a House of Representatives of 203 members, meeting in Harrisburg. The executive branch is led by the Governor, with the Lieutenant Governor. The judicial branch is led by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, whose seven justices are headed by a Chief Justice.
Worked example 1: a CER. Lily writes: Claim: both preambles show that power comes from the people. Evidence: both begin “We, the people.” Reasoning: starting with the people means the government gets its authority from them.
Worked example 2: a difference. Kwame writes: “The U.S. Preamble lists purposes. Pennsylvania’s Preamble expresses gratitude and then lists rights first. Pennsylvania puts rights at the front of its plan.”
Roles, not names. People who hold these offices change after elections. Our guide names the offices so it stays accurate, and families can look up who serves now.
Put both preambles side by side and fill a Venn diagram first.
Build a comparison card for our guide.
Make a two-column chart: U.S. government and Pennsylvania government. For each, write its lawmakers, its executive leader and its highest court.
Both governments are run by representatives the people choose. Next we ask: why not let the people vote on every law themselves?
Exit ticket: what is one thing the Pennsylvania Constitution does for people in our state?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 8, Venn and practice 12, CER 7.
Accuracy: the current Pennsylvania Constitution’s text is from the General Assembly site. Senate 50, House 203, Supreme Court seven justices are standard facts. Teach the religious language of the Preamble descriptively; do not ask students to agree or disagree with it.
Nonpartisan: name offices, not officeholders or parties. The try-at-home is a lookup only.
Likely misconceptions: that the Governor is part of Congress; that state and U.S. constitutions are the same document.
Answer guide: strong CERs quote both preambles accurately and explain a meaningful similarity (popular sovereignty) or difference (goals versus gratitude; rights first).
Pennsylvania General Assembly (palegis.us), Constitution of Pennsylvania, Preamble and Article I · Official text of the Pennsylvania Constitution, public law; summarized in our own words with a link
Pennsylvania’s Constitution today has a short Preamble. It begins “WE, the people of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.” It says the people are grateful to God for civil and religious liberty and ask for God’s guidance. Then it says they “ordain and establish this Constitution.” To ordain means to set up officially.
Right after the Preamble comes Article I, the Declaration of Rights. Its first section says all people are born equally free and independent. It names rights to enjoy and defend life and liberty, to own and protect property and reputation, and to pursue happiness.
The second section says that all power is inherent in the people. Inherent means it belongs to them by nature. Free governments are founded on the people’s authority, for their peace, safety and happiness. The people always have the right to change or reform their government.
Later articles set up the three branches of the state government: Article II, the Legislature; Article IV, the Executive; and Article V, the Judiciary.
Source: Pennsylvania General Assembly (palegis.us), Constitution of Pennsylvania, Preamble and Article I (palegis.us)