explain what William Penn meant about government and the people, and describe the difference between limited and unlimited government.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A clock has many parts, but it only keeps time when someone winds it and keeps it in good shape. How might a government be like a clock? Write one guess, then read about William Penn’s plan for Pennsylvania.
In Penn's 1682 plan, who chose the members of the Provincial Council?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Penn’s clock idea is about people. A government’s laws and offices are like a clock’s gears. They do not move by themselves. People give them motion by voting, serving, obeying laws and speaking up. If people stop caring, even a good plan can break down.
Old words, today’s meaning. Penn wrote “men,” as writers often did then. Our state standards today say “Governments, like clocks, go from the motion people give them.” In Penn’s colony, only some men, called freemen, could vote. Women and enslaved people could not. The idea was bigger than the voting rules of its time.
Limited and unlimited government. In a limited government, the leaders must follow the law too, and written rules limit what they may do. In an unlimited government, one ruler or a small group can do whatever they want. Penn said a government is free “where the laws rule.” Our Constitution limits government by dividing power among three branches and listing rights the government may not take away.
Penn’s plan was a kind of republic. Freemen chose representatives for the Council and the General Assembly. Those representatives made the laws. That is different from a direct democracy, where every voter votes on every law.
Worked example 1: Sofia explains the quotation. Sofia writes: “Penn means a government works only if people keep it running. For example, a library board needs neighbors to serve on it and to come to its meetings.” She ties an old idea to a local, everyday example.
Worked example 2: Andre sorts governments. Andre writes: “Limited: the president must follow the Constitution, and courts can check the other branches. Unlimited: a king who makes any law he likes and cannot be questioned.” He uses Penn’s phrase “where the laws rule” as his test.
Keep the reading and the challenge quotation open.
Draft a Pennsylvania Roots card.
In 80 words or fewer, explain Penn's clock idea to families and give an everyday example.
Compare a limited government and an unlimited government. Use Penn's phrase “where the laws rule” and one feature of the U.S. Constitution in your answer.
Penn’s clock still needs people to wind it, and that includes us.
Exit ticket: what is one way a 5th grader can give motion to our school's “government”?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, drafting 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that Penn’s colony let everyone vote; that limited government means weak or small in size (it means bound by law); that a clock metaphor is about time.
Supports: bring a wind-up or battery clock and remove the battery to show that it stops. Read the challenge quotation aloud and paraphrase it together. The Avalon transcription is shared by Yale Law School; the 1682 words are public domain. Stretch: compare Penn’s amendment rule with Article V of the U.S. Constitution.
Answer guide: strong explanations say that government depends on the people who run it and take part in it. Limited: leaders bound by laws, separation of powers, the Bill of Rights. Unlimited: a ruler or small group with no legal limits. Examples of motion: voting, serving on a jury or board, attending a public meeting, following laws.
The Avalon Project, Yale Law School, Frame of Government of Pennsylvania · The 1682 text is in the public domain; transcription by The Avalon Project, Yale Law School
In 1682 William Penn wrote a plan for his new colony called the Frame of Government of Pennsylvania. A frame of government is a plan that says how a government will be set up and run.
In the preface, or opening, Penn compared governments to clocks. A clock moves only because someone gives it motion. In the same way, he said, governments are made and moved by people, and people can also ruin them. He wrote that governments depend on people more than people depend on governments. Even a good plan will be spoiled if the people running it are bad.
Penn also wrote that any government is free to the people under it when the laws rule. Anything more than that, he said, is tyranny, which means cruel or unfair rule.
His plan set up a Provincial Council of 72 members chosen by the freemen, with one-third elected each year. A General Assembly of representatives, also chosen by the freemen, would review and pass laws. The plan could be changed only with the agreement of the Governor and six of every seven parts of the freemen in the Council and Assembly.
“Wherefore governments rather depend upon men, than men upon governments.” (William Penn, preface to the Frame of Government, 1682)
Source: The Avalon Project, Yale Law School, Frame of Government of Pennsylvania (avalon.law.yale.edu)