explain what the Preamble says, what popular sovereignty means, and how Gouverneur Morris of Pennsylvania shaped the Preamble’s words.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Read the opening words: “We the People of the United States.” An early draft began by naming every state instead. Why might “We the People” be a better start?
Which delegate do you think wrote the final Preamble?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Popular sovereignty. Sovereignty means the highest power. Popular sovereignty means that the highest power belongs to the people. The words “We the People” say that the Constitution’s authority comes from the people, not from a king or only from the states.
The six goals in plain words. Form a more perfect Union: work better together than under the Articles. Establish justice: fair laws and courts. Insure domestic tranquility: peace at home. Provide for the common defense: protect the nation. Promote the general welfare: the well-being of all. Secure the blessings of liberty: protect freedom now and for future generations.
Pennsylvania’s fingerprints. The essay says scholars generally credit Morris with the Preamble, and that its language echoes his home state’s constitution. A Pennsylvanian helped choose the most famous words in American government.
Worked example 1: linking a goal to history. Haruto connects “insure domestic Tranquility” to Shays’ Rebellion: “After armed unrest in Massachusetts, the framers wanted a government that could keep peace at home.”
Worked example 2: who were ‘the People’? Amina asks whether everyone counted. She writes, “The Preamble says We the People, but in 1787 women could not vote in most places and enslaved people had no rights. Over time, Americans worked to make ‘the People’ include more people.”
For our guide. Families may know the opening words by heart. Our guide can explain what each goal means and show how the words came to be.
Use the reading and a copy of the Preamble.
Write a plain-language Preamble for our guide.
Rewrite each of the six goals in your own words, with one example of what it looks like in daily life.
Investigation is done. Next we make sense of our evidence, starting by comparing the U.S. Preamble with Pennsylvania’s.
Exit ticket: what does “We the People” tell us about where government's power comes from?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, rewrite 5.
Accuracy: the essay says authorship is “generally acknowledged” as Morris’s; keep the hedge. Note the Constitution Annotated is a Library of Congress publication. New Jersey and a few places allowed some women to vote early on, so say “most places.”
Likely misconceptions: that the Preamble gives the government powers (it states purposes); that “We the People” included everyone in 1787.
Supports: a six-box organizer with picture cues. Stretch: compare the two drafts and explain what changed in meaning.
Answer guide: strong rewrites keep the meaning of each goal and give realistic local examples, such as courts, police, parks or libraries.
Library of Congress, Constitution Annotated (constitution.congress.gov), Pre.2 Historical Background on the Preamble · U.S. government work, public domain
A preamble is an introduction that explains a document’s purpose. Many state constitutions of the time had one. Pennsylvania’s 1776 constitution said government was created to protect the community and let people enjoy their natural rights.
For the first two months of the Convention, no one proposed a preamble for the Constitution. In late July 1787, Edmund Randolph of Virginia, working on the Committee of Detail, suggested one. He wanted it short and focused on why a new government was needed.
The first draft, released on August 6, began “We the People of the States of” and then listed all thirteen states. After September 8, the Committee of Style, with Gouverneur Morris of Pennsylvania doing most of the writing, changed the opening to “We, the People of the United States.” One reason: no one knew yet which states would approve the Constitution.
Morris’s version listed six goals: a more perfect Union, justice, domestic peace, the common defense, the general welfare and the blessings of liberty. The record shows no objection from the delegates.
Source: Library of Congress, Constitution Annotated (constitution.congress.gov), Pre.2 Historical Background on the Preamble (constitution.congress.gov)