revise our panels so they compare points of view fairly, starting with the Loyalists, and explain how the rule of law protects rights.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Many stories of the Revolution call Patriots heroes and Loyalists villains. Is that fair to the people who lived then? Write one reason a colonist might have stayed loyal to the king.
About what share of colonists do you think stayed loyal to Britain?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision means “seeing again.” Today every team looks at its panel with fresh eyes. We start with one question: does this gallery show more than one point of view, using real evidence?
Two sources, two views. The Declaration gives the Patriot view: the king abused his power, so the colonies had the right to break away. Loyalists saw it differently. Many believed that breaking the law and rebelling against the lawful government was wrong and dangerous. Comparing these sources does not mean choosing a winner. It means explaining why each side believed what it did.
The rule of law protects everyone, or no one. During the war, some Patriot crowds threatened Loyalists, took their property or drove them from their homes without a fair trial. When people are punished without laws and courts, anyone’s rights can be taken. The rule of law protects each person’s rights and helps the whole community live in peace, even people we disagree with. The Treaty of Paris asked the states to return property taken from Loyalists.
Worked example 1: Priya revises for fairness. Priya’s first label says, “Loyalists were traitors who loved the king.” That is an opinion. She revises: “Loyalists stayed loyal to Britain. Some wanted to protect their property. Some enslaved people hoped Britain would bring them freedom.” Now her label uses evidence and more than one reason.
Worked example 2: Ethan compares sources. Ethan writes: “The Declaration says the king was a tyrant. A Loyalist minister would say the king was the lawful ruler. They disagree because one wanted new rules and the other wanted to keep the old ones.” He names both views and the reason they differ.
Revision checklist. Use our museum criteria.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every claim traces to a named source. |
| Fair | We show at least two points of view, use the specific names of people and nations, and show enslaved people as people who resisted. |
| Clear | A neighbor can read it without help. |
| Complete | It tells who, where, when, and the causes and results. |
| Constraints | One panel per team. Main label of 100 words or fewer. At least one primary source per panel. Legends are labeled as legends. No costumes or role-play. |
Use the reading, the Declaration and your own panel.
Make your revisions.
Compare how the Declaration and the Loyalist reading show different points of view about the king. Use one detail from each.
Use one detail from today's reading as evidence for this claim: “Loyalists were not all the same.”
Explain how the rule of law protects one person's rights and also helps the whole community.
A fair museum lets visitors understand people they might disagree with.
Exit ticket: what is the biggest revision your team made today, and which criterion did it meet?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, revision work 12, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that all colonists were Patriots; that Loyalists were all wealthy or British-born; that fairness means agreeing. The one-third estimate is commonly attributed to John Adams and is reported on the NPS page; present it as a rough estimate. Mistreatment of Loyalists and the treaty’s property articles are established history (see Articles 5 and 6 on the National Archives Treaty of Paris page).
Supports: provide a two-column comparison frame (Patriot view / Loyalist view / why they differ). This is a flex revision lesson; let teams spend extra time on the criterion they scored lowest in the 1.22 critique.
Answer guide: comparisons should name the Declaration’s charge that the king abused power and a Loyalist belief that the king was the lawful ruler. Evidence for “not all the same”: different reasons (property, rewards, jobs, hopes for freedom) or different places. Rule-of-law answers: laws and courts protect a person from unfair punishment, and they keep the peace for everyone.
National Park Service, Teaching with Historic Places, Loyalists in the American Revolution (student activities) · U.S. government work, public domain
Loyalists were colonists who stayed loyal to Britain and its king. Patriots sometimes called them Tories. No one knows exactly how many there were, because many people kept their loyalty secret. John Adams once estimated that about one third of the people supported the king, one third supported independence and one third took neither side.
Loyalists lived in every colony. There were many in New York and Pennsylvania, and even more in South Carolina and Georgia.
People became Loyalists for different reasons. Some hoped for rewards after the war. Some wanted to protect their property. Many were ministers, lawyers, doctors and teachers whose work was tied to Britain or the Church of England. Some servants and enslaved people believed that American independence would not bring them freedom.
Loyalists fought in battles too, such as Moore’s Creek Bridge and Kings Mountain in the Carolinas. The source also notes a hard truth: many enslaved people who were promised freedom by the British were instead sold into slavery in the West Indies.
Source: National Park Service, Teaching with Historic Places, Loyalists in the American Revolution (student activities) (nps.gov)