give examples of cooperation between the Lenape and Penn’s colony and separate evidence from legend in the story of Penn’s treaty.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A famous painting shows William Penn making a treaty with the Lenape under a great elm tree. A painting can feel like proof. Is it? Write what you would need to know about a painting before you trust it as evidence. Then read.
According to the reading, when was Benjamin West's famous treaty painting made?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Early Pennsylvania had real cooperation. The Lenape and Penn’s colonists traded, met in councils and signed treaties and deeds, including the 1683 deeds signed by Penn and Tamanend. The Lenape helped shape early Pennsylvania as a nation with its own leaders, lands and laws.
Cooperation did not last forever. In lesson work last semester, you may have met the 1737 Walking Purchase, which many Lenape people called a fraud. Over time, Lenape people were pushed west. Lenape nations continue today, including the Delaware Nation and the Delaware Tribe of Indians, so our guide uses the present tense when we talk about them.
Fact, folklore and fiction. A fact is supported by evidence. Folklore is a story passed down that may hold some truth but cannot be fully proved. Fiction is made up. Historians label which is which and give their reasons.
Ask when a source was made. A painting made almost 90 years after an event is a secondary source about the meeting, even though it is a primary source about how people in 1771 remembered Penn. The person who paid for it, Penn’s son, may have wanted the family to look good.
Worked example 1: Grace sorts claims. Grace makes three boxes. Fact: “In June 1683, Penn and Tamanend signed land deeds.” Folklore: “They made a great treaty under an elm in 1682.” Not proved: “The wampum belt was given at that meeting.”
Worked example 2: Luis writes a fair label. Luis drafts: “Tradition says Penn and the Lenape leader Tamanend made a treaty of friendship at Shackamaxon. No record of that meeting survives, but a 1683 treaty with signed deeds shows they did make agreements.” His words “tradition says” tell families how sure we are.
Use the reading and the worked examples.
Draft a Pennsylvania Roots card.
Explain how the Lenape and Penn's colonists cooperated, and name one later conflict. Then explain one contribution the Lenape made to early Pennsylvania.
Sort three claims about Penn's treaty into fact, folklore or not proved. Give a reason for each.
Honest history tells families what we know and how sure we are.
Exit ticket: why might a famous painting become more famous than the evidence?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, drafting 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that the treaty legend is either totally true or a lie (historians think it may blend real treaties); that the Lenape vanished; that Penn’s good relations meant all colonists treated the Lenape fairly. Do not have students act out the treaty or wear costumes.
Supports: provide a three-box sort (fact, folklore, not proved). Show West’s painting only as a source to question. For the home task, remind students that family stories are welcome and need not be proved. The present-day Lenape nations named are well documented; invite students to visit the nations’ own websites with a teacher.
Answer guide: cooperation: trade, councils, treaties, the 1683 deeds. Conflict: the Walking Purchase, pressure on land. Contribution: Lenape homelands, knowledge of the land and rivers, and agreements that shaped the colony. Exit ticket: paintings are easy to see and remember, and a powerful family paid for this one.
Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia (Rutgers University), Treaty of Shackamaxon · Copyright Rutgers University; retold in our own words with a link to the source
A well-known tradition says that William Penn and the Lenni Lenape (also called the Lenape or Delaware) made a treaty of friendship in 1682. The meeting is said to have happened under a great elm at Shackamaxon, a Lenape place in today’s Fishtown neighborhood of Philadelphia. The site is now Penn Treaty Park. The Lenape leader linked to the story is Tamanend.
Historians look closely at the evidence. No original written record of that meeting survives. Penn’s busy schedule in late 1682 makes the date hard to fit. A wampum belt said to have been given at the treaty was donated in 1857. It supports the tradition but does not prove it.
Some things are well documented. In June 1683, a treaty produced land deeds signed by Penn, Tamanend and others. Its location is not stated, but it may have been Shackamaxon.
Benjamin West painted Penn’s Treaty with the Indians in 1771, long after the event, for Penn’s son Thomas Penn. Some critics say the tradition made the past look better than it was. Others think it blends many real treaties and land sales into one “Great Treaty.”
Source: Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia (Rutgers University), Treaty of Shackamaxon (philadelphiaencyclopedia.org)