The Revolution Perspectives Museum
How can we build a museum that shows the Revolution through the eyes of Patriots, Loyalists, enslaved and free Black Americans, Native nations and women?
The mystery: In 1776 the Declaration of Independence said that all men are created equal, while about one in five people in the colonies was of African descent, and most of them were enslaved. How did people at the time argue about that?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
identify who made a historical source, when and why, and sort our Wonder Board questions by the kind of source that could answer them.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Think of a poster for a school fundraiser. The person who made it wants you to do something. What tricks might a poster use to make you care, such as colors, big words or pictures?
In 1770, silversmith Paul Revere made a famous picture of soldiers firing into a crowd in Boston. What do you think he wanted viewers to feel?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every source has a maker. A primary source is something made at the time we are studying, such as a letter, a law, a newspaper or a picture. Before we trust one, historians ask three questions: Who made it? When? Why?
Paul Revere’s picture. Revere titled his print “The Bloody Massacre.” He supported the colonists’ side. He made the picture within weeks of the shooting and sold copies. That tells us he wanted people to see the soldiers as cruel. It does not tell us every detail of what happened.
Propaganda is still evidence. A one-sided picture is useful. It is strong evidence of what its maker believed and wanted others to feel. It is weaker evidence of exactly who did what.
Worked example 1: sourcing a picture. Mateo writes, “Who: Paul Revere, a Boston silversmith on the colonists’ side. When: 1770, right after the shooting. Why: to make people angry at the soldiers. So I will check his picture against other sources.”
Worked example 2: sorting a question. Hana’s Wonder Board question is “Did Black soldiers fight in the Revolution?” She decides that army records, a soldier’s life story and pension papers could help. She tags her sticky note “records and life stories.”
Today’s workshop. We will sort our questions into kinds of sources: laws and official papers, letters and diaries, pictures and newspapers, maps, and records of people’s lives. Some questions will need more than one kind.
Use the reading and the sourcing questions. Agree as a team before you answer.
Fill in a Source Card for a source you use this unit.
For Paul Revere's picture, write: Who made it? When? Why? What does it show well? What might it leave out?
Sort three Wonder Board questions under these headings: laws and official papers; letters and diaries; pictures and newspapers; records of people's lives.
Our museum will label every source with its maker. Next time we go back to 1763, when one war ended and new trouble began.
Exit ticket: what is one question you will always ask about a source before you use it in our museum?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 8, practice 10, Wonder Board sort 9.
Materials: a projected image of Revere’s print (Library of Congress or other museum copies are public domain), sticky notes, Wonder Board headings.
Accuracy: keep the event’s name in quotation marks or say “the shooting on King Street” when discussing whether “massacre” is a fair word. Lessons 1.06 and 1.07 return to the event and the trials.
Likely misconceptions: that biased sources are lies; that pictures are like photographs. Revere engraved his image; it is not a camera view.
Supports: provide the Source Card with sentence starters. Stretch: list details in the print that might be exaggerated and how to check them.
Answer guide: Source Cards name Revere, 1770 and a persuasive purpose, and note that the picture shows the colonists’ view well but may leave out what the crowd did. Exit tickets name who, when or why.
National Park Service, Picturing a Revolution: Printmaking in the American Colonies · U.S. government work, public domain
In the colonies, the printing press was the only practical way to make many copies of a picture. Printers carved images into wood or engraved them, or cut lines, into copper plates. Silversmiths were often the first printmakers, because they already knew how to engrave metal.
To oppose the Stamp Act of 1765, a Pennsylvania newspaper made a fake stamp that mocked the official British one. Other papers copied it.
In March 1770, British soldiers fired into a crowd in Boston. Silversmith Paul Revere made the best-known picture of the event. He printed 200 copies, and the image was seen throughout the colonies and in London. He also made a picture of the coffins of the men who were killed.
In 1774, newspapers brought back Benjamin Franklin’s 1754 snake drawing, “Join or Die,” to call on the colonies to unite. The Park Service says these images worked as propaganda: messages made to win people to one side.
Source: National Park Service, Picturing a Revolution: Printmaking in the American Colonies (nps.gov)