compare the reasons people became Patriots, Loyalists or neutrals and write a claim supported by evidence.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Imagine it is 1776. Write one reason a farmer, a minister or a shopkeeper might want to stay loyal to the king. Then write one reason they might want independence.
John Adams estimated how colonists split. Which guess matches his estimate?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three choices, real reasons. Historians try to understand why people chose what they did, without making one side all good or all bad. Patriots argued that Parliament had taken their rights. Loyalists argued that the king’s government protected order, property and their way of life. Many people simply hoped to stay out of the fight.
Claim, evidence, reasoning. A claim answers a question. Evidence is a detail from a source. Reasoning explains how the evidence supports the claim. Today you write a CER about why people chose sides.
Worked example 1: a CER. Amelia writes, “Claim: Some people became Loyalists to protect what they had. Evidence: the Park Service says some wanted to protect their property and many were ministers, lawyers, doctors and teachers. Reasoning: people whose jobs or land depended on the king’s government had a lot to lose in a revolution.”
Worked example 2: comparing two sources. Tomas compares this reading with the Stamp Act reading from 1.05. He writes, “The Stamp Act page shows Patriot anger about taxes and rights. This page shows Loyalists’ reasons. Together they explain why neighbors disagreed.”
Pennsylvania was divided. An officer called Pennsylvania “enemies’ country” because so many people there were Loyalists. Many Pennsylvania Quakers also refused to fight on either side because of their beliefs.
For our museum. The Loyalists gallery must explain their reasons fairly, using evidence, not only what Patriots said about them.
Use the reading and your notes from 1.04 and 1.05.
Build a Point of View Chart.
Make a three-column chart: Patriot, Loyalist, Neutral. Give each column two reasons and name the source for each.
Which reason for loyalty would most surprise our visitors? Write a 40-word label explaining it fairly.
Neighbors chose different sides. Next time we look closely at the choices of enslaved and free Black Americans.
Exit ticket: why should a museum explain the Loyalists' reasons fairly?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 8, practice 10, CER and chart 10.
Accuracy: the one-third split is Adams’s estimate as reported by NPS; modern historians debate it, so call it an estimate. The Quaker sentence in the mini lesson is established history: the Quaker peace testimony led many to refuse to fight. Do not teach that Loyalists were traitors or cowards; treat their reasons as real.
Likely misconceptions: that colonists were united; that being neutral was easy (neutrals were often pressured by both sides).
Supports: a CER frame with sentence starters. Stretch: explain why the Revolution can be called a civil war.
Answer guide: Patriot reasons: rights, taxes without consent, self-government. Loyalist reasons: property, jobs tied to the Crown, expected rewards, hopes of freedom for some enslaved people. Reasoning links each reason to what a person stood to gain or lose.
National Park Service, Teachers: Loyalists in American Revolution · U.S. government work, public domain
John Adams wrote that about one-third of Americans supported independence. These were the Patriots. About one-third supported the king. These were the Loyalists, also called Tories. The last third supported neither side. This was Adams’s estimate, not a count.
It is hard to know how many Loyalists there were, because many kept their loyalty secret. Their numbers varied by place. There were many in New York. There were so many in Pennsylvania that one officer called it “enemies’ country.” South Carolina and Georgia also had many.
People stayed loyal for many reasons. Some expected rewards after the war. Some wanted to protect their property. Many were ministers, lawyers, doctors and teachers. Some Loyalists were servants or enslaved people who believed the way to freedom was not through American independence.
The British promised freedom to some enslaved people. Sadly, many of them were later sold into slavery in the West Indies. Because colonists fought colonists, the Park Service explains the Revolution as a kind of civil war.
Source: National Park Service, Teachers: Loyalists in American Revolution (nps.gov)