explain the Great Compromise and how it shaped the two houses of Congress, using a vote record from July 16, 1787.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Our school is choosing a student council. One class has 30 students and another has 10. Should each class get the same number of representatives, or more for the bigger class?
How do you think the framers settled this kind of fight?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The fight. Large states such as Virginia and Pennsylvania wanted seats in Congress based on population. Small states such as Delaware and New Jersey feared they would be outvoted forever, and wanted each state to have an equal vote, as under the Articles.
The idea. The Park Service notes that Roger Sherman of Connecticut had proposed the key idea weeks earlier: one house by population, the other equal by state. That is why it is also called the Connecticut Compromise. Today we call the houses the House of Representatives and the Senate.
A republic of representatives. Either way, citizens would not vote on every law themselves. They would choose representatives to decide for them. A government like this is called a republic. We will compare it with direct democracy later in the unit.
Worked example 1: reading the vote. Rosa counts: five yes, four no, one divided. She notices Pennsylvania voted no. She writes, “Pennsylvania was a large state and wanted both houses based on population, so the compromise gave it less than it hoped.”
Worked example 2: what a compromise is. Eli explains: “In a compromise, each side gives up part of what it wants. Large states got the House. Small states got the Senate. Neither got everything.”
Still true today. Pennsylvania has many seats in the House because of its large population, and two senators, the same as every state.
Use the vote record in the reading. Work in pairs.
Make a diagram for our guide.
Draw two boxes labeled House and Senate. In each, write how seats are given and which states liked that plan.
Write one sentence explaining Rutledge's idea in your own words.
The delegates had settled one fight, but another was linked to it: who would be counted in the census. Next we study that question honestly.
Exit ticket: why is the Great Compromise sometimes called the Connecticut Compromise?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, diagram 5.
Accuracy: the NPS page lists the vote as five yes, four no, Massachusetts divided; North Carolina’s Spaight voted no within a yes delegation. New Hampshire’s delegates had not arrived and New York’s had left. The NPS page has a typo (“sixty-fire”) for sixty-five. Sherman’s proposal is from the NPS June 11 page.
Likely misconceptions: that the Senate was elected by the people from the start (state legislatures chose senators until the 17th Amendment); that every state has the same number of House members.
Supports: a colored map of the thirteen states for marking votes. Stretch: why might North Carolina’s surprise vote have mattered so much?
Answer guide: strong responses note small states gained equality in the Senate and large states gained power in the House, citing the vote.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park: The Constitutional Convention: A Day by Day Account · U.S. government work, public domain
On July 16, 1787, the delegates in the Assembly Room voted on what the Park Service calls the most important compromise of the Convention.
The plan had several parts. In the first house of Congress, states with more people would have more representatives. That house would start with 65 members, because no count of the people had been made yet. A census, or count of the people, would be held every ten years, and seats would be adjusted. Bills about money would start in the first house. In the second house, every state would have an equal vote.
The vote was very close. Five states voted yes: Connecticut, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland and North Carolina. Four voted no: Pennsylvania, Virginia, South Carolina and Georgia. Massachusetts was divided.
Some large-state delegates were unhappy. But several said an imperfect compromise was better than letting the Convention fail. John Rutledge of South Carolina put it this way: even if they could not do what they thought best, they ought to do something.
“Although we could not do what we thought best in itself, we ought to do something.” —John Rutledge (SC)
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park: The Constitutional Convention: A Day by Day Account (nps.gov)