The Bill of Rights in Our Lives Guide
How can we make a guide that shows families how the Constitution and Bill of Rights protect people today, and how rights grew over time?
The mystery: The government under the Articles of Confederation could not even pay its soldiers. Why did leaders who met in Philadelphia in 1787 end up writing a whole new plan?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
use details from a reading to explain how the Articles of Confederation worked and why many leaders thought it was too weak.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Imagine a school club that can make plans but cannot collect dues. It can only ask members to pay, and many never do. What happens when the club needs to buy supplies?
Our first national government had a problem like that club. What do you think it could not do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome, civic researchers. In this unit you will make a guide called The Bill of Rights in Our Lives. Families in our community will read it to learn how the Constitution and Bill of Rights protect people today. To explain the Constitution well, we first need to know why it was written.
Our puzzle. The Declaration of Independence said governments exist to protect people’s rights, and that their power comes from the people. After the war was won, the new nation had a government that could not even pay its soldiers. Why did the leaders who met in Philadelphia in 1787 end up writing a whole new plan?
Why so weak? Americans had just fought a war against a king and a Parliament that taxed them without their consent. Many feared any strong central government. So the Articles kept most power in the states. That choice protected the states, but it left Congress without money or a way to make states cooperate.
Worked example 1: a detail becomes evidence. Keisha wants to show that Congress had trouble paying for things. She finds this detail: Congress could only ask states for money, and states did not have to pay. She writes, “Because states could ignore requests, Congress could not count on money to pay soldiers or debts.” She named the detail, then explained what it shows.
Worked example 2: a strength, too. Mateo notices that the Articles did some things well. Congress made treaties and ran post offices, and the states stayed united through the war. He writes, “The Articles held the states together, but they made it hard to act.” Good researchers show both sides.
Our promise to families. Everything in our guide will come from evidence. We will name our sources and explain hard words in plain language.
Keep the reading open and work with your team. Point to the sentence that gives you each answer.
Start your own page for the class Wonder Board.
Make a T-chart: what Congress could do, and what it could not do, under the Articles. Put at least three details on each side.
Write one question you wonder about how the new nation was governed. Put it on a sticky note for the Wonder Board.
We met our puzzle: a government that could not pay its bills. Next time we see what happened when farmers in Massachusetts ran out of patience.
Exit ticket: why might a government that cannot collect taxes have trouble protecting people and serving the common good?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, Wonder Board 5.
Likely misconceptions: that the Articles were a total failure (they carried the nation through the end of the war and the 1783 peace); that there was a president under the Articles (there was no separate executive branch); that the Constitution was written in 1776.
Supports: provide the T-chart template and the frame “The reading says ___, which shows ___.” Stretch: why would people who had just fought a war over taxes design a Congress that could not tax?
Answer guide: strong responses name a weakness from the reading (no taxing power, no control of trade, nine-state rule, every-state amendments) and connect it to an effect, such as unpaid debts or slow decisions. Exit tickets should link money to services or protection.
National Archives, Milestone Documents: Articles of Confederation (1777) · U.S. government work, public domain
During the Revolution, the Second Continental Congress asked a committee to plan how the states would join together. John Dickinson of Delaware wrote most of the plan. His draft used the name “the United States of America.” Congress adopted the Articles of Confederation on November 15, 1777. They took effect on March 1, 1781, when Maryland became the last state to approve them.
The Articles made a confederation, a loose union of 13 states. The document called it a “league of friendship.” Each state kept every power not clearly given to Congress, and each state had one vote, no matter how many people lived there.
Congress could decide on war and peace, make treaties, coin money and run post offices. But it could not tax. It could only ask the states for money, and states did not have to pay. Congress also could not control trade. Big decisions needed nine states to agree, and changing the Articles needed every state. The treasury ran low, and paper money lost its value.
In 1787, leaders met in Philadelphia to fix the Articles. By mid-June they decided to design a whole new government.
Source: National Archives, Milestone Documents: Articles of Confederation (1777) (archives.gov)