explain how checks and balances and federalism keep any one group from having too much power, and how that structure protects people’s rights and property.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Finish this sentence: “If everyone always did the right thing, we would not need…” Share your ending with a partner.
Federalist No. 51 says: “If men were angels, no government would be …” What word comes next?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Federalism. Dividing power between the national government and the states is called federalism. The national government handles things like coining money, making treaties and the armed forces. States handle things like public schools, driver’s licenses and most local laws. Some powers, like taxing, are shared.
Two layers. Inside each level, power is divided again into branches. Pennsylvania has its own General Assembly, Governor and courts, just as the nation has Congress, a President and federal courts.
Protecting rights and property. When no single group holds all power, it is harder for anyone to take away people’s rights or property unfairly. Courts settle disputes, laws protect property, and leaders must follow the Constitution. That structure also serves the common good.
Worked example 1: a CER. Zoe writes: Claim: the Constitution protects rights by dividing power twice. Evidence: Federalist No. 51 says power is split between nation and states and then among branches. Reasoning: if one part overreaches, another part can push back.
Worked example 2: national or state? Malik sorts examples. Issuing coins: national. Running East Allegheny’s schools: state and local. Collecting taxes: both. He notes that a family may deal with both levels in one day.
A fair disagreement. Americans have argued since 1787 about how much power belongs to the nation and how much to the states. Our guide presents the structure and lets families think it through.
Sort powers, then build your CER.
Make a power map for our guide.
Draw three circles: national, state, both. Place at least six powers in the right circles.
Not everyone was convinced the structure was enough. Next we hear from Pennsylvanians who wanted a bill of rights.
Exit ticket: explain “If men were angels, no government would be necessary” in your own words.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, sort 8, CER 9.
Accuracy: the LoC guide lists “Hamilton or Madison” for No. 51; most historians credit Madison, but keep the guide’s wording. Examples of national, state and shared powers are standard civics.
Nonpartisan: present the nation-state balance as a long-running debate with reasonable views on both sides.
Likely misconceptions: that states are just branches of the national government; that checks and balances mean branches never cooperate.
Answer guide: strong CERs quote or paraphrase the double security and connect it to a concrete protection, such as a court hearing a property dispute.
Library of Congress, Research Guides: Federalist Papers: Primary Documents in American History, Full Text of The Federalist Papers, Nos. 51-60 · Public domain historical text; Library of Congress guide
Federalist No. 51 appeared in the New York Packet on February 8, 1788. The Library of Congress lists its author as Alexander Hamilton or James Madison.
The essay explains why the Constitution divides power. People who hold power may try to take more. So the essay says each branch should have the means and the desire to resist the others. In its famous words, “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.” Ambition is a strong wish for power or success.
The essay also says that if people were angels, no government would be needed. Because they are not, a government must be able to control the people, and it must also be made to control itself.
Finally, the essay describes a “double security” for the rights of the people. First, power is split between the national government and the state governments. Then each of those governments is split into separate branches. The levels can check each other, and each branch can guard its own work. That gives the people’s rights two layers of protection.
“Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.” —Federalist No. 51
Source: Library of Congress, Research Guides: Federalist Papers: Primary Documents in American History, Full Text of The Federalist Papers, Nos. 51-60 (guides.loc.gov)