explain what the rule of law means and how the Boston Massacre trials protected rights and helped the whole community.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Two students argue on the playground. Before the principal decides, should both get to tell their side? Write yes or no and one reason.
After the shooting, many Bostonians hated the soldiers. Who agreed to be the soldiers' lawyer?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The rule of law. The rule of law means that everyone, including leaders, follows the same laws, and the laws are applied fairly. No one is punished just because a crowd is angry. Decisions come from evidence and fair rules.
Why it protects you. If unpopular people could be punished without a fair trial, anyone could be next. A fair trial with a lawyer, witnesses and a jury protects each person’s rights. It also helps the whole community trust its courts. That is part of the common good.
Worked example 1: spotting the rule of law. Grace reads that Adams defended the soldiers though he supported the colonists’ cause. She writes, “Adams showed the rule of law: even people the town hated got a lawyer and a fair trial.”
Worked example 2: evidence over feelings. Javier notices that witnesses disagreed about Preston. He writes, “Because the evidence did not prove Preston gave the order, the jury found him not guilty. The decision followed evidence, not the town’s anger.”
A complicated hero. Adams defended the law, and he also described the crowd with insulting words about race and background to win his case. Historians can admire one choice and question another. Our museum should show both.
Government’s job. People form governments partly to keep order and protect rights. Courts are one way government does that job.
Use the reading. Underline evidence for each answer.
Write a museum label for the trial.
Write a 60-word label titled “A Fair Trial for Enemies.” Explain the rule of law and use two facts from the reading.
Adams defended the law but also used insulting words about the crowd. How should our museum show both parts of his choices?
The courts stayed fair, but trouble over taxes came back. Next time: tea.
Exit ticket: finish the sentence: “The rule of law protects me because…”
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 8, practice 11, label 8.
No role-play: do not stage a mock trial of the soldiers with students as historical people. Analyze the records instead.
Accuracy: six of eight soldiers were acquitted; Hugh Montgomery and Matthew Kilroy were convicted of manslaughter and branded through an old law called benefit of clergy. The NPS Adams biography says all nine were acquitted of murder, which agrees.
Likely misconceptions: that a not-guilty verdict means nothing happened; that defending someone means agreeing with them.
Supports: a three-box organizer: what happened, what the law required, why it was fair. Stretch: connect to the Sixth Amendment’s list of rights.
Answer guide: fair trials protect everyone because anyone could be accused; trust in courts helps the community settle conflicts without mobs.
National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park, Boston Massacre Trial · U.S. government work, public domain
After March 5, 1770, Captain Thomas Preston and eight soldiers were arrested. Other Boston lawyers refused to defend them. John Adams agreed. He believed that a person facing death deserves a lawyer, even though the case could hurt his own reputation.
Officials delayed the trials so tempers could cool. Preston’s trial began on October 24, 1770, and lasted six days, the first trial in the colonies to last more than one day. Witnesses disagreed, even about what Preston wore. Several, including Newton Prince, a free Black man, said they heard no order to fire. The jury found Preston not guilty.
At the soldiers’ trial, more than forty witnesses spoke. Adams told the jury to decide on facts, not feelings. The jury found six soldiers not guilty. Two were found guilty of manslaughter, a less serious crime than murder, and were branded on the thumb.
The trials showed that colonial courts could give fair verdicts. Today, the Sixth Amendment protects the right to a lawyer and a fair, public trial.
“Facts are stubborn things.” — John Adams, at the soldiers’ trial, 1770, quoted by the National Park Service
Source: National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park, Boston Massacre Trial (nps.gov)