explain the conflict over the whiskey tax in western Pennsylvania, compare peaceful and violent responses and describe what happens when laws are broken.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In the 1790s, a new tax angered many farmers right here in western Pennsylvania, including what is now Allegheny County. If you thought a law was unfair, what are two ways you could try to change it? Write them, then read what people actually did.
According to the reading, why did the whiskey tax hit western farmers so hard?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Conflict happened in early Pennsylvania, not just cooperation. Some conflicts were over land. The Whiskey Rebellion was a conflict over a law. It took place in the counties around Pittsburgh, close to where we live.
Two sides had reasons. Many farmers said the tax was unfair to the West, where cash was scarce and courts were far away. A 1791 local meeting called the law “dangerous to liberty.” The national government said the law had been passed by Congress and had to be obeyed, or the new government would not work.
Peaceful or violent? Some people tried to change the law through meetings, petitions and elections. Others threatened and attacked tax collectors. Both groups disliked the law. Only one group used methods that respected other people’s rights and safety.
Breaking laws has consequences. The National Archives explains that Washington led an army of about 10,000 troops west, and the rebels never fought it. Around 20 people were arrested and tried for treason. Only one man, Daniel Hamilton, was convicted, and Washington later pardoned, or forgave, him. Violence also hurt the community: people were injured, one man died, and neighbors lived in fear.
Worked example 1: Jada compares responses. Jada writes: “Peaceful: Gallatin’s group met and asked to repeal the law. Violent: rebels attacked Neville’s house. The peaceful group kept working inside the law, and Gallatin was later elected to Congress.”
Worked example 2: Owen traces consequences. Owen makes a chain: “Law broken with violence, then militia called out, then arrests and treason trials, then one conviction and a pardon.” He adds a second chain for the community: “Fear, injuries, a death, and a region marked as rebels.”
Use the reading and the mini lecture.
Draft a Pennsylvania Roots card.
Write a 100-word card for families: what caused the Whiskey Rebellion, two ways people responded, and one consequence. Show both sides fairly.
Describe what happens to people and to a community when laws are broken, using one example from the Whiskey Rebellion and one from everyday life, such as damage to a park.
Disagreeing with a law is allowed. How people disagree makes all the difference.
Exit ticket: if you disagreed with a rule in our town, what is one peaceful step you could take?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, drafting 9, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that all western farmers were violent (many were not); that the rebellion was a large battle (the rebels never fought the army); that disagreeing with a law is itself wrong. Present the tax debate fairly and do not connect it to present-day tax arguments.
Supports: provide a two-column peaceful-or-violent sort and a cause-and-consequence chain. Stretch: explain why Washington sent commissioners to talk before sending the army. Consequence facts come from the National Archives page on the indictment of Daniel Hamilton (archives.gov/philadelphia/highlights/daniel-hamilton), which also lists Allegheny, Greene, Fayette, Washington and Westmoreland counties.
Answer guide: cause: the 1791 tax on distilled spirits hurt farmers who relied on whiskey sales and had little cash. Responses: peaceful meetings to repeal; violence against collectors. Consequences: militia and army, about 20 tried for treason, one convicted then pardoned, fear and injury in the community. Gallatin answers should mention calm leadership and public service.
National Park Service, Gallatin: A Voice of Moderation During the Whiskey Rebellion · U.S. government work, public domain
In the spring of 1791, the new national government passed a tax on distilled spirits such as whiskey. Western Pennsylvania farmers turned their grain into whiskey because whiskey was nearly the only product they could sell. Many poor families had little cash to pay. Farmers accused of breaking the law had to go to court in Philadelphia, about 300 miles away.
People responded in two ways. One group worked peacefully to repeal, or cancel, the law through legal means. Albert Gallatin, a local leader, joined that group. Another group used violence. In the fall of 1791, a tax collector was tarred and feathered. In 1794, rebels attacked the house of John Neville, the regional tax collector, and one attacker was killed.
The government acted. Congress let local courts hear some cases. President George Washington called out the militia and sent commissioners to talk with the rebels. At a meeting in Brownsville in August 1794, Gallatin spoke first and urged people to obey the law. A little over half the delegates voted to submit. Later, Gallatin served in Congress for many years.
Source: National Park Service, Gallatin: A Voice of Moderation During the Whiskey Rebellion (nps.gov)