explain how the Six Nations tried to stay neutral and why the Confederacy split, using evidence of what changed and what continued.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Two neighbors you trade with start a fight. Both want your help. Write what you would want to do, and what might happen if you refuse both.
When the Revolution began, what did Oneida leaders first tell the governor of New York?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Nations, not bystanders. The Six Nations of the Haudenosaunee were the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca and Tuscarora. They were sovereign: they governed themselves and made treaties as nations. In the Revolution they weighed their own interests, just as the colonists did.
The land question. From 1763 on, the biggest issue for many Native nations was settlers moving onto their lands. Many leaders judged that Britain, which had at least tried to draw lines, was the lesser danger. That is one reason most Six Nations supported Britain.
Worked example 1: change. Maya writes, “Change: before the war the Six Nations acted as one confederacy. During the war they split, and some nations fought each other.” She uses before and during to show change over time.
Worked example 2: continuity. Caleb writes, “Continuity: from the 1763 Proclamation to the 1768 treaty to the war, settlers kept pushing onto Native lands. That pressure stayed the same.” Continuity means something that lasted.
Near us. Lenape and Shawnee communities lived in the Ohio Country, the region that includes the Pittsburgh area. The 1768 treaty was signed for them, sometimes without their consent.
They are still here. The Haudenosaunee nations continue today, with their own governments. Our Native Nations gallery will speak of them in the present tense.
Use the reading and your timeline from 1.03.
Make a Change and Continuity chart for the Native Nations gallery.
Make a two-column chart from 1763 to 1784: Changed and Stayed the Same. Give at least two items in each column with a date and a source.
Write a 40-word label: why did different Haudenosaunee nations choose different sides?
Native nations chose carefully and paid a heavy price. Next time we hear from a woman who asked Congress to remember people left out.
Exit ticket: name one thing that changed for the Six Nations because of the war and one thing that continued.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 8, practice 10, chart 9.
Accuracy: the NPS page spells it “Delewares”; the nation calls itself Lenape. The Oneida also sent 50 men to Valley Forge in the winter of 1777-78, and an Oneida woman known as Polly Cooper cooked for Washington, according to the NPS page “The Oneida in the American Revolution.” Joseph and Molly Brant supported Britain. Do not describe ceremonies or sacred objects.
Likely misconceptions: that all Native nations chose one side; that they were pawns rather than nations with their own goals; that they no longer exist.
Supports: a map of Haudenosaunee homelands. Stretch: explain why signing for other nations without their consent caused conflict.
Answer guide: changed: the Confederacy split, villages were destroyed, lands were lost in 1784. Continued: settler pressure on Native lands and the nations’ efforts to protect their homelands. The quotation shows they saw the war as a quarrel between Old England and New that was not theirs.
National Park Service, Fort Stanwix National Monument, The Six Nations Confederacy During the American Revolution · U.S. government work, public domain
The Six Nations governed themselves through women’s leadership and a men’s council. Their lands sat at the headwaters of great rivers, including the Ohio, Delaware and Susquehanna, which made them a powerful confederacy.
After the French and Indian War, colonists kept pushing onto Native lands. In 1768, British and Six Nations leaders signed a boundary treaty at Fort Stanwix. The Six Nations also signed for the Shawnee, the Lenape and others, with and without their consent. Settlers kept coming anyway.
When the Revolution began, the Six Nations saw it as a quarrel among the English and did not want to be drawn in. Oneida leaders said they loved both Old England and New. But pressure grew, and the Confederacy split. Most nations supported Britain, believing they had a better chance of keeping their lands. The Oneida and Tuscarora gave major support to the Americans as scouts and guides.
The 1783 peace treaty made no provisions for the Six Nations. The war left villages destroyed on both sides, and in 1784 the nations that had sided with Britain gave up large areas of land.
“We are unwilling to join either side of such a contest, for we love you both, Old England and New.” — Oneida leaders to the governor of New York, quoted by the National Park Service
Source: National Park Service, Fort Stanwix National Monument, The Six Nations Confederacy During the American Revolution (nps.gov)