test our final shelter and make a claim about how well it reduces wind and rain problems.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Read your Version 2 data. Which goal are you most sure about? Which one worries you?
What makes a claim about a design strong?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Weather Team, this is the final test. Run the same tests you used before. Your goal is to find out how well your shelter works, and to tell the truth about it.
Our design goals. In our design brief we wrote draft rules. Now we turn them into rules we can test on a model. Criteria are what the shelter must do. To show the seats stay dry, the learner paper under the roof stays dry. To show it stands up to wind, the shelter stays standing and moves 2 cm or less in fan wind. To show it keeps papers in place, the paper stays put. Six learner cards fit inside, with one open side so learners can see and reach the garden. Constraints are our limits. It fits on a 30 cm by 30 cm cardboard base. It is no taller than 30 cm. Our materials budget is 20 supply tokens or fewer. We build it in one class period.
Write a claim, evidence and reasoning. The claim says how well the shelter reduces the hazard. The evidence gives your numbers. The reasoning explains why the design caused those results.
Worked example 1: Elena’s claim. “Our shelter reduces rain problems. It had 0 wet spots from above and 1 from the side. The overhang sends water past the learner paper.” This is sample data.
Worked example 2: Isaac’s honest limit. “Our shelter stayed up on high fan but moved 3 cm. That misses our goal of 2 cm or less. It reduces the wind problem but does not fully solve it.” This is sample data.
Name the limit. Like a lightning rod, your shelter does some jobs and not others. It is not a safe place in a thunderstorm.
| Goal | Final result | Met? | Benefit for learners |
|---|---|---|---|
| Learner paper dry | |||
| Stays up, moves 2 cm or less | |||
| Six cards fit | |||
| Fits base and height | |||
| 20 tokens or fewer |
Run each final test twice and record the results.
Write your final engineering claim.
Write a claim about how well your shelter reduces wind and rain problems. Add at least two pieces of evidence and your reasoning.
Which criteria and constraints did your shelter meet? How would this benefit students and teachers? What limit should they know about?
Save your results. Next time you present your shelter to the people who would use it.
Exit ticket: which change helped your shelter the most?
Materials: final shelters, test stations from 2.19, data sheets from earlier tests.
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 5, mini lecture 5, testing 15, claim writing 10, exit 2 minutes.
Misconceptions: a claim must say the design is perfect; a missed goal means the project failed. Reward honest limits.
Supports: provide a claim, evidence and reasoning frame. Stretch: suggest how a full-size shelter might differ from the model.
Answer guide: a full claim states the degree of success, cites two measurements, explains how a feature caused the result, checks each goal and names a benefit and a limit such as “go indoors for thunder.”
National Weather Service, Lightning Rods · U.S. government work, public domain
Lightning can damage a building and start a fire. A lightning rod system helps protect a building from a direct strike.
Many people think a lightning rod keeps lightning away. It does not. The National Weather Service says these systems do not stop lightning from hitting a building. Instead, they give the lightning a safe path.
The system has parts that work together. The rod catches the strike. A metal cable called a conductor carries the electricity. A grounding network spreads the energy safely into the ground. All the parts must be connected well.
The rod is not a full answer by itself. Lightning can still send a surge, a sudden burst of electricity, through wires and pipes. So a complete system also needs surge protection.
This is how a careful engineer thinks. Say what the design does. Say what it does not do. Then people can use it safely.
Source: National Weather Service, Lightning Rods (weather.gov)