plan fair tests that show whether a latch meets each criterion and where it fails.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Two teams test latches. One team pulls gently. The other team yanks hard. Can they compare their results? Why or why not?
What makes a test fair?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why do we test? A test tells us what works and what fails. A spot where a design breaks down is called a failure point. Finding one is good news, because now we know what to fix.
The Pull Test. Set a shoebox cubby at the table edge. Tie a string to the door’s pull tab. Let it hang over the edge to a paper cup. Add washers one at a time. Count the washers when the door pops open. That number is the Pull Score.
Balanced and unbalanced. While the door stays shut, all the forces on it are balanced. Add enough washers, and the cup’s pull beats the magnet’s pull. Now the forces are unbalanced. The door moves.
Keep it fair. Use the same string, cup and washers. Start with the door fully shut. Add washers gently. Do three trials. Change only one thing when you compare.
Worked example 1: Zoe plans the Bump Test. Zoe writes: “Criterion: stays shut through 5 bumps. Method: tap the side of the box 5 times with a flat hand, the same way each time. Data: did the door stay shut?”
Worked example 2: Omar plans the Click-Back Test. Omar writes: “Criterion: clicks shut 8 out of 10 times. Method: open the door the same distance, then let go with a light push. Data: count the clicks.”
| Test | What we keep the same | What we record |
|---|---|---|
| Pull Test | String, cup, washers, door start | Washers at opening, 3 trials |
| Bump Test | Number and strength of taps | Stayed shut: yes or no |
| Two-Finger Test | One hand, two fingers | Opened: yes or no; pinching or twisting needed? |
| Click-Back Test | Same opening distance, 10 tries | Number of clicks |
| Safety Check | Gentle tug on each cover | Magnet stayed covered and fixed: yes or no |
Practice the Pull Test setup with a sample box. Your teacher will show the steps first.
Set up your team’s test plan page.
Choose one test. Write what you will change, what you will keep the same and what data you will record.
How will this test help you find a failure point in your latch?
Your plan is ready. Next, you will build your first prototype.
Exit ticket: Why do we do three trials instead of one?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how a test helps us improve a design.
Pacing: Do Now 5, instruction 10, demonstration and guided practice 15, independent 5, closure 5.
Materials: one demonstration shoebox cubby with a cardboard door taped along one edge, string, paper cup, steel washers, covered classroom magnets.
Tune the sweet spot: washers and magnets vary. Try one latch before class. If 6 to 20 does not fit your supplies, set a new range and update the Design Card.
Misconceptions: changing many things gives a faster answer; washers measure weight only (here they show how big the pull is, compared with other pulls). Keep force talk qualitative: bigger pull, smaller pull.
Supports: provide a fill-in test plan. Stretch: ask what could accidentally make the test unfair.
Answer guide: changed thing: the design or the washers added. Same: cup, string, door start, method. Data: the count or yes/no result. Three trials help us catch an odd result.
NASA, NASA Restarts Rigorous Vibration Testing on the James Webb Space Telescope · U.S. government work, public domain
A rocket launch shakes and roars. A space telescope must survive that wild ride. So NASA engineers tested the James Webb Space Telescope on the ground first. Webb travels folded up, which makes testing extra important.
Engineers put the telescope on a shaker table. This machine shakes things in a careful, planned way. Sensors measured how the telescope moved. A sensor is a tool that notices and records a change.
On December 3, 2016, the test stopped by itself. The sensor numbers were higher than the team had predicted. Engineers studied the data. They found tiny movements in the parts that hold one folded mirror wing in place.
The team changed the test plan so the problem would not happen again. Then they went back to testing. They shook the telescope in one direction and planned to test the other two directions as well.
A test that finds a surprise is not wasted. It teaches engineers exactly what to look at next.
Source: NASA, NASA Restarts Rigorous Vibration Testing on the James Webb Space Telescope (nasa.gov)