follow our test plan and record data about how well Version 1 works.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look outside. What is the wind doing to trees, flags or leaves? How could you tell the wind’s strength with no tools?
Where do you think your shelter is most likely to fail today?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Weather Team, today the storm arrives. Our storm is a model. A spray bottle stands in for rain. A small fan stands in for wind. Follow your plan and write down what truly happens.
Three test stations. Station 1 is rain from above: 20 squirts from 30 cm. Station 2 is side rain: 10 squirts from each of two sides, to act like rain blown by wind. Station 3 is wind: the teacher runs the fan for 30 seconds on low and 30 seconds on high.
Water and fans stay apart. The fan table is far from the spray tables. Dry your hands before you go to the wind station.
Worked example 1: Lucia’s rain data. Lucia counted 0 wet spots from above and 6 wet spots from side rain. Her roof works from above. Her open side lets side rain in. This is sample data.
Worked example 2: Sam’s wind data. Sam’s shelter stayed up on low and moved 1 cm. On high it slid 9 cm and one post bent. He wrote exactly what happened. He did not write “it was bad.” This is sample data.
Data beats guessing. Numbers and careful words show where your shelter works and where it needs help.
| Test | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Met the goal? | What we noticed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rain from above: wet spots | ||||
| Side rain: wet spots | ||||
| Fan low: cm moved | ||||
| Fan high: cm moved | ||||
| Still standing? |
Rotate through all three stations. Record as you go.
Study your data.
Use your data to tell how well Version 1 met each criterion.
What part of your shelter caused the biggest problem? How do you know?
Keep your data safe. Next time another team will look at your shelter and help you see what you missed.
Exit ticket: what surprised you most in the storm test?
Materials: spray bottles, paper towel squares, trays, rulers, masking tape, one small fan on a separate dry table, a tape safety line, towels.
Setup: run the fan yourself and keep it at 1 meter from the shelter. Replace the towel square for each trial. Rotate teams every 7 minutes.
Misconceptions: a fan is not a real storm, so results compare designs and do not predict how a full-size shelter would do. Students may think a shelter that moves but stands has passed; check it against the goal.
Supports: number the steps on station cards. Stretch: graph wet spots for each test.
Answer guide: responses cite specific numbers and connect a failure to a part, such as “the open side let in 6 wet spots.”
National Weather Service, Beaufort Wind Scale · U.S. government work, public domain
How can you tell how strong the wind is if you have no tools? You can look around. The Beaufort Wind Scale matches what you see to a number called a force. The scale goes from force 0 to force 12.
At force 0, the air is calm. Smoke rises straight up. At force 2, wind blows at about 4 to 7 miles per hour. You feel it on your face, and leaves rustle.
At force 4, wind blows at about 13 to 18 miles per hour. Dust and loose paper lift up. Small branches move. At force 6, wind blows at about 25 to 31 miles per hour. Large branches move, and umbrellas are hard to use.
At force 8, wind blows at about 39 to 46 miles per hour. Twigs break off trees. At force 10, wind blows at about 55 to 63 miles per hour. Trees can come up by the roots, and buildings can be badly damaged.
Careful watching can give useful data.
Source: National Weather Service, Beaufort Wind Scale (weather.gov)