explore how a rubbed balloon pushes and pulls without touching, and ask questions we can test about electric forces.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Your teacher rubs a balloon on a wool cloth, then holds it just above tiny bits of tissue paper. Watch closely. There is no magnet here.
What will the tissue bits do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A second invisible force. Magnets are not the only things that push and pull across a gap. Rub a balloon on wool, and it can pull on hair and paper. This is an electric force.
What rubbing does. Rubbing moves tiny charges from one thing to another. The balloon ends up with extra charge. We call this static electricity.
Push or pull. Opposite charges pull together. Matching charges push apart. So two rubbed balloons push away from each other.
Ask a testable question. Good questions name what we will change and what we will watch. Ask, “What happens to the tissue when the balloon moves closer?”
Worked example 1: a stronger question. June first asked, “Why is static weird?” She changed it: “Does rubbing the balloon longer make it lift more bits of tissue?” She can change the rubbing and count the bits.
Worked example 2: distance again. Here is sample data from Caleb’s team. With the balloon 10 cm above the tissue, 0 bits moved. At 5 cm, 3 bits moved. At 2 cm, 9 bits moved. Caleb says, “Closer means a stronger pull, just like magnets.”
Lab. Rub a balloon on wool for 10 seconds. Hold it 5 cm above the tissue bits. Then try closer and farther. Try two rubbed balloons on strings, too.
Compare the two forces.
Tell one way the rubbed balloon and a magnet are alike. Then tell one way they are different.
We have now seen two forces that work across a gap. Next we will use drawings to make sense of the forces we tested.
Exit ticket: would static electricity or a magnet work better for a cubby latch? Tell why.
Pacing (40 min): demo 4, reading 5, mini lecture 7, lab 15, independent work and exit ticket 9.
Materials per team: 2 latex-free balloons (inflated by an adult), wool or felt, tissue bits, string, ruler. Static works best in dry air; on humid days, rub longer or demonstrate.
Boundary: electric forces stay at the level of static electricity and objects students can handle. Do not teach electrons in detail.
Misconceptions: “The balloon became a magnet.” Test it with a paper clip. Be clear that lightning is dangerous and classroom static is not like being outside in a storm. The worked-example counts are sample data.
Supports: offer “What happens to ___ when ___?” Stretch: does the type of cloth matter?
Answer guide: alike: push or pull across a gap, stronger when closer. Different: a balloon must be rubbed and its charge fades; magnets pull steel without rubbing. A magnet suits a latch because it keeps working.
NOAA National Environmental Satellite, Data, and Information Service, It's Electric! · U.S. government work, public domain
NOAA is the U.S. agency that watches our weather and oceans. One of its student activities uses a plastic pipe and tiny pieces of aluminum foil. Students rub the pipe with felt or a paper towel. Then they wave it above the foil and write down what happens.
Rubbing builds up a charge on the surface of the pipe. A charge is a tiny bit of electricity that stays on an object. This build-up is called static electricity.
Objects can have a positive charge or a negative charge. NOAA explains that opposite charges are attracted to each other.
Static electricity is also part of a giant event in the sky. NOAA says lightning begins as static charges in a rain cloud. The charges build and build. At last they must escape. ZAP! That is a lightning strike.
Your balloon has far less charge than a storm cloud, so it is safe to explore in class.
Source: NOAA National Environmental Satellite, Data, and Information Service, It's Electric! (nesdis.noaa.gov)