list what our shelter must do and describe the limits on our design.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Imagine our outdoor classroom has a strong roof. Dark clouds roll in, and you hear thunder far away.
What should the class do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every design has rules. Criteria are the things a design must do to be successful. Constraints are the limits we must work within, such as materials, money and time.
Solve today’s need. Our teachers need a place for garden classes now. We will not design for a far-away place or for every kind of storm. We will focus on everyday wind and rain.
| Our draft criteria (what it must do) | Our draft constraints (our limits) |
|---|---|
| Keep the seating area dry in rain | Model fits on one sheet of cardboard |
| Stay standing in strong wind | Use only the classroom materials provided |
| Keep papers from blowing away | Stay within the materials budget your teacher sets |
| Let students see and reach the garden | Finish in the time we are given |
Worked example 1: sorting. Isla read, “We can use only the classroom materials provided.” That is a limit, so it is a constraint. She read, “It must keep the seats dry.” That says what success looks like, so it is a criterion.
Worked example 2: making a criterion testable. Ben wrote, “It should be good in the rain.” That is hard to check. He changed it to: “A paper towel under the roof stays dry during our test rain.” Now we can test it.
An important rule. Our design will not include lightning protection. Our plan is simple: when thunder roars, go indoors.
Sort these with your team.
Start your design rules.
Write three criteria and two constraints for our shelter. Make at least one criterion testable.
Now we know what success means and what our limits are. Next time, we join our data and our rules in a design brief.
Exit ticket: why does our outdoor classroom need a safety plan as well as a shelter?
Pacing: log update 3, warm-up 4, reading 8, mini lecture 8, sort 9, independent 5, exit ticket 3.
Materials: criteria and constraint sort cards, chart for class rules. Set the actual materials budget before part 2.
Misconceptions: treating any roof as lightning-safe is the most important one to correct. Align the lesson with your school’s severe-weather procedure. Students also confuse criteria and constraints: ask, “Is this a goal or a limit?”
Supports: color-coded sort cards. Stretch: rank criteria from most to least important.
Answer guide: a shelter handles wind and rain, but people must leave for a safe building when thunder is heard.
NOAA JetStream, Lightning Safety · U.S. government work, public domain
A roof can keep you dry. That does not mean it keeps you safe from lightning.
If you can hear thunder, that is your warning. You are close enough for lightning to strike. Go to a safe place right away.
The safest place is inside a large, closed building with plumbing and electric wiring. Plumbing means water pipes, like those for sinks. If no building is near, a closed metal vehicle, such as a car or school bus, is a good choice.
Some places only look safe. Picnic shelters, sheds, porches, carports and baseball dugouts are not safe during lightning. Many have open sides.
Stay inside until 30 minutes after the last thunder. Remember this rule: when thunder roars, go indoors.
So our outdoor classroom needs two things: a shelter for wind and rain, and a plan to walk quickly to the school when thunder is heard.
Source: NOAA JetStream, Lightning Safety (noaa.gov)