prove with data and a safety check how well our final latch meets every criterion and constraint.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at your latch as if you were a kindergarten teacher. What is the first thing you would check?
What must be true of every magnet in our design?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today you prove it. You will run every test on your final latch. Your evidence will show what the latch can do.
Safety comes first. Do the Safety Check before any other test. If a magnet is uncovered or loose, stop and fix it. A latch cannot pass if it fails this check.
Then run the full plan. Do the Pull Test three times. Do the Bump Test, the Two-Finger Test and the Click-Back Test. Record every result.
Worked example 1: Ines scores her latch (sample data). Pull Scores: 12, 13, 12. Bumps: stayed shut. Two Fingers: yes. Click Back: 9 of 10. Safety Check: passed. Ines writes: “All criteria and constraints met.”
Worked example 2: Kofi tells the truth (sample data). Kofi’s latch scored 14, 15 and 14. It passed Safety and Two Fingers. But it opened on the fourth bump. He writes: “Most criteria met. The Bump Test is still a weak spot.” Honest results earn trust.
| Our Design Card | What it means |
|---|---|
| Criterion: Pull Score | The door opens with 6 to 20 washers pulling. This is our sweet spot. |
| Criterion: Bump | The door stays shut through 5 bumps. |
| Criterion: Two Fingers | It opens with one hand and two fingers. No pinching. No twisting. |
| Criterion: Click Back | It clicks shut after a light push at least 8 times out of 10. |
| Constraint: Materials | We use only our class kit and no more than 2 large magnets. |
| Constraint: Safe Magnets | Every magnet is covered and cannot come loose. |
| Constraint: Time | We finish in the class time we have. |
Run your Final Test. Answer these questions as checkpoints.
Complete your Final Results page.
Make a claim: how well does your latch solve the cubby problem? Support it with at least three test results.
Which criterion was hardest to meet? Which constraint limited your design the most?
Your evidence is ready. Next, you will share it with the people who need it.
Exit ticket: What is one thing a kindergarten teacher should know about your latch?
How confident are you that you can I can explain why magnet safety matters.
Pacing: Do Now 3, instruction 7, testing 20, independent 7, closure 3.
Materials: final prototypes, test setups, Final Results page.
Sensitive topic: keep the talk calm and practical. The source title is strong and the source includes serious injury details; do not read those aloud. Follow your school’s reporting steps for any suspected swallowing.
Misconceptions: large magnets are toys; a design must pass every test to be useful (partial success is real and useful data, though Safety must pass).
Supports: provide a checklist and claim frame. Stretch: suggest a stronger way to fix magnets in place.
Answer guide: claims match the data and name any missed criterion. Prototypes stay under classroom supervision and are not left with kindergartners.
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, CPSC Warns High-Powered Magnets and Children Make a Deadly Mix · U.S. government work, public domain
Magnets are useful, but some need great care. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, or CPSC, helps keep people safe from dangerous products. It has warned families about small, strong magnets.
Small magnets are easy to lose. Very young children may find loose ones on a table or floor. Older children have been hurt too. If someone swallows two or more of these magnets, the magnets can pull toward each other inside the body. That can cause very serious injuries.
The CPSC gives clear advice. Keep small magnets away from young children. Check toys and play areas for loose or missing magnets. If you think someone swallowed a magnet, tell an adult right away and get medical care.
This is why our class uses large magnets. It is why we count them every day. It is also why each magnet must be covered and fixed in place. Real engineers think about how a design could go wrong. Then they design to keep people safe.
Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, CPSC Warns High-Powered Magnets and Children Make a Deadly Mix (cpsc.gov)