write the criteria and constraints for a magnetic latch that meets the needs of kindergarten children.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Imagine you are buying a backpack. Write one thing it must do. Then write one limit, like how much money you can spend.
Which one is a limit on the backpack?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two kinds of statements. Criteria tell what a design must do to be successful. Constraints are limits on the design, like time, money, materials and safety rules.
Focus on the need right now. Ms. Okafor does not need a latch for every door in the school. She needs one for a cubby door that small children use today. Keeping the problem clear helps us do it well.
Our criteria. The door stays shut when bumped. A kindergarten child can open it with one hand. It needs no pinching or twisting. It works again and again.
Our constraints. Magnets must be sealed inside so no child can reach them. No sharp edges. We may use only classroom materials. We have a set amount of building time, and each team has a small supply budget.
Worked example 1: sorting. Nia reads, “We have two class periods to build.” She says, “That is a limit, so it is a constraint.” Then she reads, “The door stays shut when bumped.” She says, “That is what it must do, so it is a criterion.”
Worked example 2: making it testable. Ben wrote, “The latch should be good.” He changed it to, “The door stays shut through 5 bumps.” Now the class can test it.
Sort and sharpen with your team. These decisions become your Design Brief.
Write your team’s Design Brief.
Write the problem in one sentence. List at least 3 criteria and at least 3 constraints. Put a star by the one you think matters most, and tell why.
We know the problem, the science and the limits. In the next part of the unit, you will start building and testing your latch.
Exit ticket: why is it important to know the criteria and constraints before you start building?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 6, mini lecture 8, sorting 10, Design Brief and exit ticket 12.
Materials: sorting cards, Design Brief sheet, sample cubby door. Set your real build time and supply budget before class.
Reading care: this reading is about a serious topic. Read it calmly and focus on what keeps children safe. Do not bring small or high-powered magnets to class. Check on any student who seems worried.
Misconceptions: students may confuse criteria and constraints. Ask: does it say what the latch must do, or what limits us? Safety can appear as both; accept a good reason.
Supports: provide sentence strips to sort. Stretch: write a test for each criterion.
Answer guide: criteria: stays shut when bumped, one-hand opening, no pinch or twist, repeats. Constraints: sealed magnets, no sharp edges, time, materials, budget. Knowing these first keeps the design focused on real needs.
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, CPSC Warns High-Powered Magnets and Children Make a Deadly Mix · U.S. government work, public domain
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission works to keep products safe for families. It has warned people about very small, very strong magnets. Some of these magnets are sold in sets as desk toys for adults.
Why the warning? Young children may put small things in their mouths. If a child swallows two or more of these magnets, they can pull toward each other inside the body. That can cause serious injuries, and a doctor must help right away.
The agency gives clear advice to grown-ups. Keep small magnets away from young children. Check toys and play areas often for loose or missing magnets. Get medical care right away if a child may have swallowed one.
There is also a safety rule for toys. Since 2008, toys for children under 14 cannot have loose magnets of a size that could be swallowed.
This matters for us. Kindergarten children will use our latch. They must never be able to reach a loose magnet.
Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, CPSC Warns High-Powered Magnets and Children Make a Deadly Mix (cpsc.gov)