make a claim about how well a real kind of design reduces a weather hazard.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. An umbrella helps in rain. Does it make the rain stop? What is the difference between stopping a hazard and making it less harmful?
What can a good design do about a storm?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Weather Team, you are not alone. People all over the world design for weather. We cannot stop a storm. We can reduce the harm it does. To reduce means to make smaller.
Three real kinds of solutions. A levee or flood barrier holds back high water. A wind-resistant roof is fastened tightly so wind cannot lift it. A lightning rod system gives lightning a safe path into the ground.
How to judge a solution. Make a claim. Give evidence. Check the criteria and constraints. Ask about benefits and risks too.
Worked example 1: Kai’s claim. “A flood barrier reduces flooding on the playground. Evidence: after it was built, the playground flooded 1 time in a year instead of 5. These are sample numbers.”
Worked example 2: Ruth’s check. Ruth asked if the barrier met the goals. It kept water out in most storms. It cost less than the limit. A risk remains: a very large storm could go over the top. So she wrote, “It reduces the hazard. It does not remove it.”
Read the case study and the career spotlight. Then check your thinking.
Connect this to our shelter.
Write a claim about how your shelter reduces a weather problem. Give one piece of evidence from your data.
What can your shelter NOT protect people from? Why is that important to tell people?
Riverbend School is a made-up school beside a small stream. After heavy rain, its playground floods. Children cannot use it for days. The school asks for help. It wants fewer flooded days, and it can spend only a small amount.
Team 1 suggests a low earth bank along the stream. It would hold back high water. It costs the most, and someone must check it often.
Team 2 suggests a garden in a low spot that soaks up rain. It costs less. It helps with rain that falls on the playground, but it cannot stop a stream that overflows.
The school tries both ideas on a small scale. In this sample story, the bank cuts flooded days from 10 to 3 a year. The garden cuts them from 10 to 7.
Think about it: Which solution would you pick? Use the numbers and the school’s limit on cost in your answer.
Designs reduce harm, and honest engineers explain their limits. Next, we review before the final test.
Exit ticket: how could an outdoor classroom's needs change in the future? Give one example.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 6, case study 6, checks 10, writing and exit 7 minutes.
Misconceptions: “engineers can stop storms”; “if a design is not perfect it failed.” Riverbend and its numbers are invented. Be sensitive to students who have lived through floods or storms.
Supports: offer the frame “I claim ___ because my data shows ___.” Stretch: propose using both Riverbend ideas together.
Answer guide: Riverbend answers may choose either solution if they weigh flooded days against cost. Shelter limits should include lightning: go indoors when thunder roars.
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, National Levee Database, What is a Levee? · U.S. government work, public domain
Land beside a river can flood. People sometimes build a levee to help. A levee is a barrier made by people. It lowers how often the land behind it floods.
Most levees in the United States are long banks of packed soil. They run along rivers, streams or coasts. Where there is no room for a wide bank, people may build a floodwall. It does the same job.
Levees are not all alike. Their height, width and materials depend on the place, its storms and when they were built.
A levee is built to hold back water up to a certain level. A very big storm may bring more. Water can flow over the top and wear the levee away. Water can also find a path through or under it.
That is why no levee is free of risk. Owners watch their levees for trouble. A levee lowers the danger, but people must still be ready for floods.
Source: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, National Levee Database, What is a Levee? (levees.sec.usace.army.mil)