describe what kindergarten users need and turn those needs into criteria and constraints.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think about when you were five. What was hard for your hands to do? Tell a partner about a zipper, a button or a lid.
Which door handle would be easiest for a five-year-old?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers design for real people. The people who use a design are called its users. Our users are kindergarten children. Their hands are smaller than yours, and they are still building finger skills.
Needs become criteria. A need tells what a person wants to do. A criterion turns that need into something we can check. “Easy to open” is a need. “Opens with one hand and two fingers” is a criterion we can test.
Limits become constraints. We have a class kit, a set amount of time and a safety rule. Magnets must be covered and fixed in place, because young children must never get hold of a loose magnet.
Needs can change. Open shelves once worked fine for this class. Now the class wants doors to keep things neat. New wants can create new problems to solve.
Worked example 1: Mei writes a criterion. The teacher says, “Children get frustrated when doors stick.” Mei writes the need: open without a hard tug. Her criterion: the door opens with 20 washers or fewer pulling.
Worked example 2: Jamal finds a constraint. The teacher says, “Nothing small can come off.” Jamal writes: every magnet must be covered and cannot come loose. That is a limit every design must obey.
Try the Two-Finger Test on a folder, a zipper pouch and a box lid. Use one hand and only two fingers. Then answer.
Build your own user page in your notebook.
List two things our kindergarten users can do and one thing that may be hard for them. Use the reading.
Write one new criterion and one new constraint for our latch. Explain why each one matters.
You know your users now. Next, you will imagine latches made for them.
Exit ticket: Finish this sentence. A kindergartner needs a latch that ___ because ___.
How confident are you that you can I can describe the criteria and constraints for our latch.
Pacing: Do Now 5, instruction 10, Two-Finger Test and guided practice 15, independent 5, closure 5.
Materials: folders, zipper pouches, box lids, Design Card. If possible, ask a kindergarten teacher for two or three real comments.
Be respectful: milestones describe most children, and every child grows differently. Do not use them to label anyone.
Misconceptions: a need and a criterion are the same thing; a constraint is something the design does (it is a limit).
Supports: sort sentence strips into Criteria and Constraints. Stretch: rewrite a vague need so it can be measured.
Answer guide: accept abilities from the reading (some buttons, counting to 10, following rules). Criteria should be checkable. Constraints should name a limit such as materials, time or magnet safety.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Milestones by 5 Years · U.S. government work, public domain
Children grow and learn new skills step by step. A skill that most children can do by a certain age is called a milestone. The CDC, a United States health agency, lists milestones for families.
By age 5, most children can button some buttons. Look closely at that word: some. A five-year-old may do some buttons but still need help with others. Most can also hop on one foot.
Five-year-olds are growing in their thinking, too. Most can count to 10. Most can pay attention for about 5 to 10 minutes during an activity. They can follow rules and take turns in games. They can do simple chores, like clearing a table.
What does this mean for designers? Our users can learn a simple step. They can count and follow a rule. But a latch that needs tiny, careful finger moves may be too hard. A latch should work quickly, too, because five-year-olds pay attention for only a short time.
Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Milestones by 5 Years (cdc.gov)