The Little-Hands Magnetic Latch
How can we design a magnetic latch that keeps a kindergarten cubby closed but is easy for small hands to open?
The mystery: A paper clip can hang in the air under a magnet without touching it. What is holding it up?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
describe the floating paper clip, ask questions about it, and explain the cubby problem our kindergarten teacher needs us to solve.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Look at the front table. A paper clip is tied to a thread. The thread is taped to the table. The paper clip is up in the air, and nothing seems to touch it. Look closely. Do not touch it yet.
What do you think is holding the paper clip up?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A strange sight. A paper clip is floating on a thread. The thread goes down to the table. A magnet is above the clip. There is a small gap between them. When the magnet moves away, the clip falls.
Forces. A force is a push or a pull. You push a door. You pull a wagon. Most pushes and pulls happen when things touch. This one seems to work across a gap. That is our big puzzle.
A message from Ms. Okafor. Ms. Okafor teaches kindergarten at a school like ours. Her room has new cubbies with little doors. The doors swing open when children walk by. Coats and bags fall out. The hook latches are too hard for small fingers. She asks: can you make something better?
Our mission. We will design a magnetic latch. It must keep a cubby door closed. It must also be easy for small hands to open. To do that, we need to learn how pushes, pulls and magnets work.
Worked example 1: who, what, why. Engineers start by telling about the problem. Amara wrote: “Kindergarten children need cubby doors that stay shut, because their things fall out.” Her sentence tells who, what and why.
Worked example 2: a good question. Diego first asked, “Are magnets cool?” Then he changed it: “What happens to the paper clip if the magnet moves farther away?” The new question can be tested. We can try it and watch.
Our teams. You will work in teams of four. The Materials Manager gets and returns supplies. The Recorder writes data. The Tester runs the test. The Reporter checks safety and shares ideas. Jobs change each lesson.
Work with your team. Talk about each one before you answer.
On your own, add to our class Wonder Board.
Write one question about the floating paper clip. Start with “What happens if” or “Why does.” Put it on a sticky note.
Draw the floating paper clip. Label the magnet, the clip, the thread and the gap.
Today we saw a force work across a gap, and we met our client. Next time we will sort our questions and sharpen the problem.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence. Ms. Okafor's class needs ___ because ___.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now and demo 8, mini lecture 10, reading 5, guided practice 10, Wonder Board and exit ticket 7.
Materials: strong bar magnet held by a ruler on stacked books, steel paper clip, thread, tape, sticky notes, chart paper. Adjust the height before class so the clip floats with a clear gap. You may read Ms. Okafor’s request as a letter, or ask a real kindergarten teacher to send one.
Misconceptions: “The thread holds it up.” The thread actually pulls down; it keeps the clip from jumping up to the magnet. Do not resolve this yet. Students build the explanation by 1.12.
Supports: offer question starters and let students draw first. Stretch: ask what they could change to test an idea.
Answer guide: hook answer: small fingers, a tight grip, or two steps at once. Exit ticket: names the children or teacher, a door that stays closed and opens easily, and a reason such as things falling out.
NASA, An IMAGE Satellite Guide to Exploring the Earth's Magnetic Field · NASA educational publication; NASA content is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
NASA wrote a guide to help students explore magnets. One activity may look familiar. Tape one end of a string to a desk. Tie the other end to a paper clip. Then hang a magnet from a ruler that rests on books. Move the magnet to just the right height. The clip stands up in the air and does not touch the magnet.
What does this show? It shows that a magnetic force can be invisible. Invisible means you cannot see it. You can only see what it does.
The guide says a magnet is a metal that can attract, or pull on, certain other metals. A magnet has two areas called poles. The magnet’s effects are strongest at its poles.
The guide also gives students an idea to try. Slide paper or cloth between the clip and the magnet. Does the clip still stand up? Students can test different materials and write down what they find.
Source: NASA, An IMAGE Satellite Guide to Exploring the Earth's Magnetic Field (science.nasa.gov)