change one part of our shelter, test it again and compare the two versions with data.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A team changes the roof, the posts and the base all at once. The shelter works better. Can they tell which change helped?
What is the best plan for a retest?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Weather Team, it is time to improve. Pick the failure point that matters most. Change that part. Then test it the same way as before.
Think about where water goes. The reading says water keeps moving. Water that runs off your roof must land somewhere. If it lands on the learner area, you still have a problem. An overhang or a gutter can send it away.
Keep the test the same. Use the same number of squirts, the same height, the same fan distance and the same time. Then you can compare Version 1 and Version 2 fairly.
Worked example 1: Priya’s overhang. Version 1 had 6 wet spots in side rain. Priya added a 3 cm overhang. Version 2 had 1 wet spot. The change helped. It also cost 2 more tokens, for a total of 19. She is still within the limit. This is sample data.
Worked example 2: Caleb’s anchors. Version 1 slid 9 cm on high fan. Caleb pressed clay and 4 pennies onto the base. Version 2 slid 2 cm. But the cost rose from 18 to 22 tokens. That breaks a constraint. He swapped a costly roof for wax paper and got back to 20. This is sample data.
| Goal | Version 1 data | Version 2 data | Better, same or worse? | Goal met? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rain from above | ||||
| Side rain | ||||
| Fan high: cm moved | ||||
| Token cost |
Make your change, retest and fill in the table.
Explain your improvement.
What did you change? What evidence told you to change it?
Did the change work? Explain using numbers from both versions.
Your shelter is stronger because you listened to the data. Next we meet people who design for real weather.
Exit ticket: what would you change next if you had more time?
Materials: Version 1 shelters and data, building supplies, tokens, test stations from 2.19.
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, mini lecture 5, revise 10, retest 10, writing and exit 6 minutes.
Misconceptions: “a change that felt good must have worked”; “a bigger number is always better” (fewer wet spots and fewer centimeters moved are better here).
Supports: provide a subtraction number line and a filled sample row. Stretch: graph Version 1 and Version 2 as side-by-side bars.
Answer guide: strong answers name one change, cite before and after numbers and check that constraints still hold.
U.S. Geological Survey, Runoff: Surface and Overland Water Runoff · U.S. government work, public domain
Rain does not stay where it lands. Gravity pulls it along. Some of it soaks into the ground. Much of it flows downhill over the land. Water flowing over the land is called runoff. Runoff helps fill rivers and lakes.
Many things change how much runoff there is. A hard rain makes more than a light rain. A long rain can too. The kind of soil matters. Plants matter. So does the slope of the land.
In a forest, much of the rain soaks into the soil. It moves slowly and reaches streams later. This can lower flooding.
Pavement works differently. It stops water from soaking in. More water reaches streams, and it gets there faster. That can make floods bigger and more common. People build curbs, ditches and storm sewers to carry this water away.
So, a good plan for rain asks two questions. Where will the water land? Where will it go next?
Source: U.S. Geological Survey, Runoff: Surface and Overland Water Runoff (usgs.gov)