The Little-Hands Magnetic Latch
How can we design a magnetic latch that keeps a kindergarten cubby closed but is easy for small hands to open?
The mystery: A paper clip can hang in the air under a magnet without touching it. What is holding it up?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
describe a problem a new tool could solve, explain how needs change over time, and sort our questions into ones we can test.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Try this slowly. Open your pencil box or a classroom drawer with one hand. Now pretend your fingers are very small and not very strong. Use only a closed fist. What gets harder?
Which door handle would be easiest to open with a closed fist?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Start with the people. Engineers do not start with a cool gadget. They start with people and what those people need. Ms. Okafor’s students are five years old. Their hands are small. Their fingers are still getting stronger.
Is this a problem a tool can solve? Yes. A new or better latch is a tool that can help. Some problems need a new object. Others need a new way of doing something.
Needs change over time. Many older buildings have round door knobs. Over time, people saw that knobs were hard for many hands. Now many public doors have levers. Ms. Okafor’s needs changed too. Her old cubbies had no doors. The new ones do, so now she needs a latch.
Worked example 1: then and now. Hana wrote: “Before, the cubbies were open, so no latch was needed. Now they have doors that swing, so the class needs a latch.” She told what changed and what is needed now.
Testable questions. Some questions we can answer by trying something in our room. “Does a magnet pull through cardboard?” is testable. “Who made the first compass?” needs a book.
Worked example 2: sorting a question. Malik read, “How far away can a magnet pull a paper clip?” He said, “We have a magnet, a clip and a ruler. We can test it.” He put it in the Test It pile.
Our Wonder Board is full. Let’s sort it and sharpen our problem.
Write like an engineer.
Write the problem in your own words. Tell who needs help, what they need, and how a new tool could help.
Tell one way the children's needs changed when the cubbies got doors.
We know who we are helping, and we have questions to test. Next we will start with the basics: what do pushes and pulls do?
Exit ticket: why did Ms. Okafor's class start needing a latch?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 5, reading 6, mini lecture 8, sorting practice 14, independent writing and exit ticket 7.
Materials: Wonder Board notes, four sorting labels, pencil boxes or drawers.
Misconceptions: students may think every question can be tested. Others may think a design is only about looks. Bring them back to who will use it. Treat disability respectfully: designs that remove barriers help many people.
Supports: give the frame “___ need ___ because ___.” Stretch: ask what a five-year-old can do that a pinch latch ignores.
Answer guide: a strong problem statement names the kindergarten children, a door that stays closed but opens easily, and a latch as the tool. A changed need: doors now swing, so children must open and close them.
U.S. Access Board, Chapter 4: Entrances, Doors, and Gates · U.S. government work, public domain
The U.S. Access Board is part of our national government. Its guides explain how to make buildings usable for people with disabilities. One guide explains door hardware. Hardware means the handles, pulls, latches and locks on a door.
The guide says this hardware must work with one hand. A person should not need to grip tightly, pinch, or twist the wrist. That is why a round door knob does not meet the rule. You have to twist it.
Some shapes work for more people. A lever handle or a U-shaped pull can be used with a loose grip or even a closed fist. The guide says this kind of hardware works for the widest range of users.
The guide also warns about small parts that must be pinched. It suggests avoiding hardware that needs careful finger movements or two actions at the same time.
These rules were not written for kindergarten cubbies. But the big idea can help us. Good design starts by asking who will use it.
Source: U.S. Access Board, Chapter 4: Entrances, Doors, and Gates (access-board.gov)