sketch at least two magnetic latch ideas and explain how each one could solve the cubby problem.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look at a door handle in our room. Could you open it with a closed fist? Try the motion in the air. Why might that matter?
Why do engineers sketch more than one idea?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today you are an idea maker. Your team will sketch at least two different latches. Each one must use a magnet. Each one must fit our Design Card.
Parts of a magnetic latch. One part goes on the cubby frame. One part goes on the door. When the door closes, the two parts come close, and the magnetic pull holds the door. A pull tab gives small fingers something to pull.
Use your science. Magnets pull on steel. Opposite poles pull together, and matching poles push apart. The pull gets weaker as the gap gets bigger. You can use all of these ideas in a design.
Worked example 1: Priya’s Washer Catch. Priya covers one magnet and tapes it to the frame. She tapes a steel washer to the door. The magnet pulls on the washer and holds the door. She adds a wide paper loop. “Small fingers can hook this,” she says.
Worked example 2: Lucas’s Two-Magnet Catch. Lucas puts one covered magnet on the frame and one on the door. He turns them so opposite poles face each other. The pull is strong. He predicts he may need a cardboard spacer to make the door easier to open.
Check each idea. Ask: How does it hold the door? How does a small hand open it? Which criterion might it miss?
| Our Design Card | What it means |
|---|---|
| Criterion: Pull Score | The door opens with 6 to 20 washers pulling. This is our sweet spot. |
| Criterion: Bump | The door stays shut through 5 bumps. |
| Criterion: Two Fingers | It opens with one hand and two fingers. No pinching. No twisting. |
| Criterion: Click Back | It clicks shut after a light push at least 8 times out of 10. |
| Constraint: Materials | We use only our class kit and no more than 2 large magnets. |
| Constraint: Safe Magnets | Every magnet is covered and cannot come loose. |
| Constraint: Time | We finish in the class time we have. |
Use the reading and the Design Card as you plan.
Explain your thinking.
Explain how Idea A keeps the door shut and how a small hand opens it.
Explain how Idea B is different. Which criterion or constraint might be hardest for each idea?
You have two ideas. Soon, data will help you decide what works.
Exit ticket: Which idea do you think will work better? Give one reason.
How confident are you that you can I can explain how each idea could solve the problem.
Pacing: Do Now 5, instruction 10, sketching and guided practice 15, independent 5, closure 5.
Materials: sketch paper, Design Card, a sample washer, a covered magnet for demonstration only.
Misconceptions: two ideas means the same idea in two colors; the magnet must touch the washer to hold it; poles do not matter when using steel (they do matter when two magnets face each other).
Supports: give a labeled cubby outline. Stretch: add a third idea that uses a sliding part.
Answer guide: each explanation should name the magnetic pull that holds the door and the pull by a hand that opens it. The two ideas must truly differ in parts or layout. The Access Board rules are for buildings, so use them as inspiration, not as our class limits.
U.S. Access Board, Guide to the ADA Accessibility Standards, Chapter 3: Operable Parts · U.S. government work, public domain
Buildings have many parts that people must work with their hands. Think of handles, latches, buttons and switches. The U.S. Access Board explains rules that help people with disabilities use these parts. These parts are called operable parts. Operable means you can work it.
The rules say an operable part must work with one hand. It must not need tight grasping, pinching or twisting of the wrist. It must not take more than 5 pounds of force.
Some designs pass these rules. U-shaped pulls and lever handles are fine. Other designs do not pass. Round knobs need a twist of the wrist. Small latch parts that you must pinch are not allowed either.
The guide also shares a useful check. Can you work the part with a closed fist? This is not a rule, but it is a good test.
These rules were not written for cubbies. Still, they teach a big idea. When a design is easy for more hands, more people can use it.
Source: U.S. Access Board, Guide to the ADA Accessibility Standards, Chapter 3: Operable Parts (access-board.gov)