sketch two shelter designs and explain how each one could solve the wind and rain problem.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. You need to keep rain off a friend, and you have one sheet of cardboard. Show two different ways to hold it. Which is better?
Why do engineers think of more than one idea?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Weather Team, today we imagine. You will draw two different shelters. They must really be different, not the same shelter in two colors.
Our design goals. In our design brief we wrote draft rules. Now we turn them into rules we can test on a model. Criteria are what the shelter must do. To show the seats stay dry, the learner paper under the roof stays dry. To show it stands up to wind, the shelter stays standing and moves 2 cm or less in fan wind. To show it keeps papers in place, the paper stays put. Six learner cards fit inside, with one open side so learners can see and reach the garden. Constraints are our limits. It fits on a 30 cm by 30 cm cardboard base. It is no taller than 30 cm. Our materials budget is 20 supply tokens or fewer. We build it in one class period.
Science helps us design. Water runs downhill, so a sloped roof can send rain away. Wind pushes hard on wide flat walls. Open sides can let some wind pass through. A low, wide shape with weight at the bottom is harder to tip.
Worked example 1: Nia’s Tent Shelter. Nia drew two sloped sides that meet at the top, like a tent. Rain slides off both sides. The low shape helps in wind. The weak spot: there is less room for learner cards.
Worked example 2: Mateo’s Table Shelter. Mateo drew four posts with a roof that tilts to one side. Open sides let wind pass, and there is plenty of room. The weak spot: rain blowing in from the side can reach the learners.
A trade-off. Each design gives up something to gain something. Nia gave up room to gain wind strength. Mateo gave up some rain cover to gain room.
| Check | Design A | Design B |
|---|---|---|
| Learner paper stays dry? | ||
| Stays up and in place? | ||
| Six cards fit, one open side? | ||
| Fits base and height limit? | ||
| Token cost (20 or fewer)? | ||
| Biggest trade-off |
Sketch Design A and Design B. Label how each part helps.
Explain your thinking.
Which design do you want to try first? Explain how it solves the problem. Use one criterion and one constraint.
What is the biggest trade-off in that design?
You have two ideas. Before choosing, we need facts about materials. Next time we test which materials keep water out.
Exit ticket: what does your design do about wind? What does it do about rain?
Pacing: warm-up 5, reading 7, mini lecture 8, sketching and checks 14, writing and exit 6 minutes.
Materials: sketch paper, rulers, the posted criteria and constraints, a token price list.
Misconceptions: “a closed box is always best” (it fails the open-side criterion and catches wind); criteria and constraints mixed up (use “must do” and “must stay within”).
Supports: offer shape cards to trace. Stretch: add a third design that borrows the best part of each.
Answer guide: look for two truly different structures, a link between each feature and a hazard, and a named trade-off.
NASA, The Engineering Design Process Worksheet · NASA educational material, U.S. government work
NASA engineers design things that fly to space. Their work starts with simple questions. A NASA worksheet lists the steps. They work for a spacecraft. They also work for a small shelter.
Step 1: Identify the problem. Ask what you are trying to do. What is the goal?
Step 2: Identify criteria and constraints. Criteria are what your design must do. Constraints are what limit it. Cost, supplies and time are common limits.
Step 3: Brainstorm possible solutions. To brainstorm means to think of many ideas. Describe them. Sketch them. Do not stop at one.
Step 4: Select a design. Pick one idea. Explain why you chose it. Then sketch the winning idea.
Notice what comes before building. Engineers think, list and draw first. Planning on paper is cheap. Fixing a finished project can cost much more.
Source: NASA, The Engineering Design Process Worksheet (nasa.gov)