use facts about real latches to explain the problem our magnetic latch must solve.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of a door at home that stays shut. It might be a cabinet, a refrigerator or a closet. What keeps it shut? How do you open it?
What does a latch do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers, welcome to Build. You have spent this unit finding out how pushes, pulls and magnets work. Now you will use those ideas. A kindergarten class has a problem. Their cubby doors swing open, and things fall out.
Our driving question. How can we design a magnetic latch that keeps a kindergarten cubby closed but is easy for small hands to open?
Why a magnet? A magnet can pull on steel without touching it. It can also hold a door shut with no hook to pinch. A gentle pull on the door can beat the magnet’s pull, and then the door opens.
Research comes first. Engineers study how others solved a problem before they build. They read, look closely and ask people questions.
Worked example 1: Amara studies a cabinet. Amara finds a small magnet catch inside a kitchen cabinet. She writes: “Problem: the door swings open. Cause: nothing holds it. Solution: a magnet pulls on a steel plate.”
Worked example 2: Diego studies a lunch box. Diego’s lunch box has a hard snap. His little sister cannot open it. He writes: “It stays shut, but it is too hard for small hands.” He has found both jobs of a good latch.
| Our Design Card | What it means |
|---|---|
| Criterion: Pull Score | The door opens with 6 to 20 washers pulling. This is our sweet spot. |
| Criterion: Bump | The door stays shut through 5 bumps. |
| Criterion: Two Fingers | It opens with one hand and two fingers. No pinching. No twisting. |
| Criterion: Click Back | It clicks shut after a light push at least 8 times out of 10. |
| Constraint: Materials | We use only our class kit and no more than 2 large magnets. |
| Constraint: Safe Magnets | Every magnet is covered and cannot come loose. |
| Constraint: Time | We finish in the class time we have. |
Use the reading, the case study and the Design Card to answer.
Write like an engineer. Use full sentences.
Explain the kindergarten cubby problem. Tell what causes it and what happens because of it.
Why could a magnet be a good way to solve this problem? Use one fact about magnets.
Old refrigerators often had a latch on the outside. A child who climbed in could not push the door open. In 1956 a law said home refrigerators must open easily from the inside.
Today, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says the part that does this job is usually a magnetic latch. The magnet holds the door shut. A push from inside can beat the magnet’s pull. One simple idea does both jobs.
Think about it: How is a refrigerator’s magnetic latch like the latch we want for our cubby? How is it different?
A good latch has two jobs. Next, we will learn about the people who will use ours.
Exit ticket: What is one question you want to ask a kindergarten teacher about cubby doors?
How confident are you that you can I can name the two jobs of a good latch.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 5, instruction 10, reading and case study 10, guided practice 10, closure 5.
Materials: Design Card poster, a cabinet magnet catch if available, notebooks. If your class set different numbers in Part 1, keep your class’s numbers and update the card.
Sensitive topic: the reading mentions children trapped in refrigerators. Keep the focus on how people fixed the problem. Remind students never to play inside appliances. The magnetic latch fact comes from the CPSC statutes page: https://www.cpsc.gov/Regulations-Laws–Standards/Statutes.
Misconceptions: stronger is always better (a latch that is too strong fails small hands); magnets stick to all metals (they pull strongly on iron and steel, but not on aluminum).
Supports: offer the frame “The problem is ___. It happens because ___.” Stretch: compare two latches and tell which suits small hands.
Answer guide: strong answers name the cause (nothing holds the door), the effect (things fall out) and a magnet fact (it pulls steel, even across a small gap).
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Federal Register notice on the Refrigerator Safety Act (August 2, 2019) · U.S. government work, public domain
Long ago, many home refrigerators had a latch on the outside. The latch held the door shut when no one was using it. That sounds helpful. But it caused a serious problem. A young child could get trapped inside, and the door could not be opened from within.
People wanted to protect children. So on August 2, 1956, the United States passed a law called the Refrigerator Safety Act. A law is a rule for a whole country.
The law says a home refrigerator must have a part that lets the door open easily from the inside. The part must work by itself. It must also work when the power is off.
Notice what happened here. People found a problem with a design. Then they wrote down what a better design must do. Engineers call those needs criteria. A good latch does not just hold a door shut. It must also open for the right person at the right time. Our cubby latch has the same two jobs.
Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Federal Register notice on the Refrigerator Safety Act (August 2, 2019) (govinfo.gov)