write a claim with evidence and reasoning that uses weather and climate patterns to set the requirements for our shelter.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at our Weather Log and our sample wind table. If you could build only one strong wall, where would it go?
In Schoolyard Town, which side most needs a strong wall?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Weather Team, it is time to put it all together. A design brief tells what problem we are solving and what the solution must do. Ours will use evidence from our investigations.
Claim, evidence, reasoning. A claim answers a question. Evidence is the data that supports it. Reasoning explains why the evidence supports the claim.
Worked example 1: a wind claim. Tessa wrote: “Claim: the shelter needs a strong west wall. Evidence: in the sample data, wind came from the west or northwest on 15 of 20 days. Reasoning: a wall on that side blocks the wind that comes most often.”
Worked example 2: a rain claim. Aiden wrote: “Claim: the roof should slope so water runs off. Evidence: spring has about 12 wet days in a month. Reasoning: rain is common then, so water must not collect on the roof or drip on the seats.”
| Design brief part | What to write |
|---|---|
| The need | Who needs the shelter, and why |
| Weather we expect | Patterns and a prediction, with data |
| Criteria | What the shelter must do |
| Constraints | Our limits |
| Claim, evidence, reasoning | One design idea backed by data |
| Safety plan | What we do when thunder roars |
Use real and sample data honestly. Our Weather Log is real data from a short time. Schoolyard Town is sample data. Say which one you are using.
Use your notes from the whole investigation.
Write your design brief using the table as your guide.
Write the need, the weather you predict, two criteria, two constraints and the safety plan.
Write one claim about your shelter. Support it with evidence and reasoning. Tell whether your data is from our Weather Log or sample data.
You have turned weather data into a plan. In our next phase, you will start building and testing shelter ideas.
Exit ticket: what is the most important thing our weather data taught you about designing the shelter?
Pacing: log update 2, warm-up 3, reading 7, mini lecture 7, practice 7, brief writing 11, exit ticket 3. Allow extra writing time at the start of part 2 if needed.
Materials: Weather Log, graphs from 2.04-2.08, climate cards, criteria and constraints from 2.13.
Misconceptions: restating a claim as evidence; treating a few days of our log as climate. Make the short time span explicit.
Supports: sentence frames for claim, evidence and reasoning. Stretch: write a second claim using a different kind of data.
Answer guide: look for a clear need, a data-based prediction, at least two criteria and two constraints, a matched claim-evidence-reasoning set, and the rule to go indoors when thunder is heard.
National Weather Service, Wind · U.S. government work, public domain
A gentle wind can feel good on a warm day. A strong wind is different. The National Weather Service warns that high winds can blow objects around and can put people in danger.
Where do high winds come from? They can come from strong thunderstorms. They can come from large weather systems. They can also come from air flowing down a mountain.
Wind that keeps blowing at about 40 to 50 miles per hour can cause some damage. Faster winds can cause much more. In strong thunderstorms, wind blowing in a straight line can go faster than 100 miles per hour.
Our model shelter will not be built for winds like those. No small outdoor shelter should be trusted in dangerous weather. People should go indoors.
But everyday wind still matters. A shelter must be fastened well, and loose things must be held down. Think about that as you write your design brief.
Source: National Weather Service, Wind (weather.gov)