share test results and use kind, specific feedback to find what to improve.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read two comments. “Your shelter is bad.” “I wonder how the back post could stay up on high wind.” Which comment helps a team more?
What makes feedback helpful?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Weather Team, today we help each other. Other people can spot what you cannot see. Sharing results also gives everyone new ideas.
How the critique works. Team A shows its shelter and its data for 2 minutes. Team B looks closely. Team B uses three starters: I like, I wonder and What if. Team A listens, writes notes and says thank you. Then the teams switch.
Talk about evidence. Point to a number or a part. Say which criterion or constraint it connects to. Be kind to people. Be honest about designs.
Worked example 1: Zoe’s critique. “I like your wide base, because it moved only 1 cm. I wonder if side rain reaches the cards, since you had 5 wet spots. What if the roof hung over the edge by 3 cm?”
Worked example 2: Andre’s notes. Andre’s team wrote: “Roof edge does not meet the dry paper goal. Evidence: 5 wet spots in side rain. Idea: add an overhang.” The evidence pointed right at the part to fix.
| Feedback | Which part? | Which goal? | Evidence | Our idea |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I like… | ||||
| I wonder… | ||||
| What if… |
Run the critique with your partner team.
Sort what you heard.
Name one part of your shelter that does not yet meet a goal. What evidence shows that?
How will that evidence help you decide what to change first?
Thank your partner team. Next time you will make one smart change and test again.
Exit ticket: what idea did you get from another team?
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 6, modeling 6, two critique rounds of 8 minutes, writing and exit 8 minutes.
Misconceptions: feedback is a judgment of people; more changes are always better. Model the protocol once with a sample shelter.
Supports: provide starter cards with sentence frames and allow pointing at the model. Stretch: ask teams to rank their weak spots by importance.
Answer guide: a full response names a part, the goal it misses and a data point, then explains that the evidence shows where to start.
NASA, The Engineering Design Process Worksheet · NASA educational material, U.S. government work
You already know the first four steps on NASA’s design worksheet. You found the problem. You listed criteria and constraints. You brainstormed. You chose a design. The last steps are where you are now.
Steps 5 to 7 go together. Build a prototype. Test it and evaluate it. To evaluate means to judge how well something works. Then refine the design. To refine means to make it better with small changes.
The worksheet asks two good questions here. What did you learn from your evaluation that led to your final design? How did the final product do?
Step 8 is to share the design. The worksheet tells builders to be proud of what they did. It also asks them to find a creative way to share what they learned.
Sharing helps more than one team. When people explain what worked and what did not, others get new ideas too.
Source: NASA, The Engineering Design Process Worksheet (nasa.gov)