present our latch, our evidence and our next ideas to a kindergarten audience of adults.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Pretend a kindergarten teacher asks, “Why should I trust your latch?” What would you show first?
What makes a design talk convincing?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers share their work. Today our audience is a kindergarten teacher or another school adult. They want to know if your idea can help.
Use the Four-Part Talk. Tell the problem. Show the design. Share your evidence. Name your next step.
Show how it works. Point to the magnet’s cover and the door part. Explain that magnetic force holds the door. Then open it with two fingers.
Be honest about limits. This is a model. A real cubby latch would need stronger materials and an adult’s safety review.
Worked example 1: Arjun’s opening. “Cubby doors swing open and coats fall out. Our latch uses a covered magnet and a steel washer to hold the door shut.” Arjun names the problem and the solution in two sentences.
Worked example 2: Bella’s evidence (sample data). “Our door opened with 12, 13 and 12 washers, which is in our sweet spot. It clicked shut 9 of 10 times. Next, we want a stronger pull tab, because ours began to bend.”
Plan and practice your talk with another team.
After your talk, reflect.
What question did your audience ask? How did you answer it?
Explain how your latch solves the problem people had with the cubby doors.
You solved a real problem and shared what you learned. Well done, engineers.
Exit ticket: What idea from another team would you add to your latch?
How confident are you that you can I can share my ideas to help make designs better.
Pacing: Do Now 3, instruction 7, rehearsal 8, presentations 15, reflection 5, closure 2.
Materials: prototypes, Final Results pages, talk cards. Invite a kindergarten teacher, aide or other school adult. If no one can attend, record audience questions from another class.
Safety: kindergartners do not handle the prototypes. Models stay with our class.
Source note: the NASA document is written for older students; the reading retells only its main ideas for grade 3.
Supports: use sentence starters and let students present in pairs. Stretch: answer, “What would you change for a real classroom?”
Answer guide: talks include the problem, how the design works, test data and a next step. Reflections tie the latch back to the needs of kindergarten users.
NASA Next Gen STEM, Engineering Design Process educator notes and student worksheet · U.S. government work, public domain
What does an engineer look like? A NASA lesson begins by asking students to draw one. Then it helps them see an important idea: anyone can become an engineer.
The lesson teaches the engineering design process. That is a way to solve problems. Its word list includes ask, imagine, plan, create, test, improve and share. You have used every one of these words in this project.
The lesson asks good questions about any technology. Why was it invented? Does it meet a need or a want? How could it be tested? What improvements have been made? Who would benefit from it?
It also makes a point about everyday things. A pencil sharpener and a window were engineered too. Things like these are designed many times, and they keep changing.
So your latch does not have to be the last word. When you share your results, others can use your ideas and make them better.
Source: NASA Next Gen STEM, Engineering Design Process educator notes and student worksheet (nasa.gov)