use evidence from our investigations to explain how a magnet holds up the paper clip without touching it.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. The floating paper clip is back. Look at your first drawing from 1.01. What do you know now that you did not know then? Tell a partner one thing.
Your teacher slides a sheet of paper through the gap. What will the clip do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How scientists explain. A strong explanation has three parts. A claim says what you think is true. Evidence is what you observed. Reasoning tells how the evidence supports the claim.
What forces are on the clip? The magnet pulls the clip up. Gravity pulls it down. The thread pulls it down too, because it is tied to the table. The clip stays still, so these forces are balanced.
Why does the clip fall? When the magnet moves away, its pull gets weaker. Now the up pull is too small. The forces are unbalanced, and the clip falls.
Worked example 1: a claim and evidence. Layla writes: “The magnet pulls the clip without touching it. In our lab, a clip jumped to the magnet from 3 cm away.” Her claim is clear, and the evidence is something she saw.
Worked example 2: adding reasoning. Sam adds: “The clip stays up because the magnet’s pull up balances gravity and the thread pulling down. When the magnet moved away, the pull got weaker and the clip fell.” His reasoning connects the evidence to forces.
With your team, gather evidence from your notebooks. Test the demo setup with your teacher.
Write your explanation.
Explain why the paper clip floats. Write a claim, at least two pieces of evidence, and your reasoning. Add a drawing with force arrows.
Mystery solved, with evidence! Next we will see how people use magnets to solve real problems.
Exit ticket: what would happen to the clip if you used a much weaker magnet at the same height? Why?
Pacing (40 min): demo 5, reading 5, mini lecture 7, evidence work 10, writing and exit ticket 13.
Materials: floating clip demo, paper, cloth, notebooks. Optional: test thin foil or plastic in the gap; a thicker steel object would block the pull.
Misconceptions: “The thread holds the clip up.” Cut or untape the thread: the clip jumps to the magnet, showing the thread was holding it down. Keep hands clear while doing this.
Supports: provide Claim, Evidence and Reasoning boxes plus a word bank. Stretch: predict what a thicker sheet of cardboard would do.
Answer guide: claim: the magnet pulls the clip up across the gap. Evidence: jump distance, clip falling when the magnet moves, the pull through paper. Reasoning: balanced forces keep it still; a weaker magnet gives too small an up pull, so the clip falls.
NASA, What is Magnetism? An Introduction · NASA educational publication; NASA content is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
People have wondered about magnets for thousands of years. NASA says magnetism seems like a magic trick. Something invisible reaches out through space and moves things we can see, like paper clips and nails.
Long ago, people found a natural magnet in the ground. It is a mineral called lodestone, or magnetite. A writer in ancient China noted that lodestone attracts iron. That was more than 2,000 years ago.
Today we know much more. NASA explains that the simplest magnets have exactly two poles, north and south. Like poles push apart. Opposite poles pull together.
NASA also compares magnetism with gravity. Gravity only pulls. Magnetism can pull or push.
So magnetism is no more mysterious than gravity. Both are forces in nature. We cannot see either one. But we can see what they do, test them, and use evidence to explain them. That is your job today.
Source: NASA, What is Magnetism? An Introduction (assets.science.nasa.gov)