show what I have learned in Unit 2 by reading a new passage and a data table closely, writing a short informative label on demand and turning in my final label set.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have read like an investigator and written like an expert for weeks. Read the passage twice: once for the events, once with your pencil. Underline anything you might use as evidence, and look at the table before you answer.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to read closely and use evidence from the passage and the table.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How this check works. Part A is a reading check on the passage, the table below and the Scott note card. Part B is a short informative label written today. Part C is your final label set with your checklist and revision log. Take your time and use evidence.
Table for Part A (made for this check from Amundsen’s book).
| Date, 1911 | Latitude reached (South) | Where it is printed |
|---|---|---|
| December 10 | 88° 56′ | The First Account |
| December 11 | 89° 15′ | The First Account |
| December 12 | 89° 30′ | The First Account |
| December 13 | 89° 45′ | The First Account |
| December 14, noon | 89° 53′ (dead reckoning) | Chapter XII (today’s passage) |
| December 14, 3 p.m. | The Pole, 90°, by reckoning | Chapter XII (today’s passage) |
Latitude is measured in degrees (°) and minutes (‘); 60 minutes make one degree. The South Pole is at 90° South.
| Note card | What the source says (our words) |
|---|---|
| Scott, journal for January 16-18, 1912 (a diary written each day, read in 2.23) | The day before reaching the Pole, Scott’s party found a black flag, an old camp and many dog tracks, and knew the Norwegians had been first. Scott called it a terrible disappointment. They reached the Pole on January 17 in a head wind at -22°, and the next day found the Norwegian tent with a record of five names dated December 16, 1911. |
Reminders for Part A. Quote exactly, inside quotation marks. A central idea is a full sentence about the whole passage. A summary leaves out your opinions.
Worked example 1: Ravi integrates the table. A practice question asks how far the team traveled on December 11. Ravi reads the table: 88° 56′ on December 10 and 89° 15′ on December 11, a gain of 19 minutes of latitude. He writes, “The table shows the team moved 19 minutes of latitude closer to the Pole that day.” He uses the numbers, not a guess.
Worked example 2: Maddie explains figurative language. Maddie reads that “Hanssen’s neck grew twice as long as before” She writes, “A neck cannot really double in length. This hyperbole shows how hard Hanssen was stretching and staring to spot anything ahead.”
Reminders for Parts B and C. Use our ten-item checklist.
| # | Label checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My title names my object and makes a visitor curious. | B |
| 2 | My opening introduces my topic in a way that fits STEM-night families and younger students. | B |
| 3 | My label examines one focused topic and explains it clearly; every fact comes from a source I can name. | A |
| 4 | I develop the topic with relevant facts, concrete details and at least one definition. | C |
| 5 | I include one short, exact quotation in quotation marks and name who said or wrote it. | C |
| 6 | My data graphic and my caption help readers understand, and each has a title or credit line. | C |
| 7 | I organize with a clear strategy (definition, classification, comparison or cause and effect) and two headings. | D |
| 8 | Transitions show how my ideas connect, and my concluding statement answers “So what?” | D |
| 9 | I use precise words and topic vocabulary, vary my sentences and keep a consistent, formal voice. | E |
| 10 | Grammar, pronouns, punctuation (commas, dashes, parentheses), capitals and spelling are correct. | F |
Constraints: main label 150 to 220 words in two short sections with headings; caption 15 to 40 words; one data graphic with a title and a source line; one timeline card (a date and one sentence). Every fact must come from a source you can name. Your title and your first name will appear on the label.
Part A: Reading check. Work alone. Use the passage, the table and the Scott note card.
Parts B and C.
Part B (on-demand writing, about 15 minutes): Write a museum label of 100 to 150 words for a photograph of Amundsen’s team at the South Pole, using only today’s passage, the table and the note card. Include a title, an opening that introduces the topic for STEM-night families, at least two precise facts, one short exact quotation with its source, at least two transitions and a concluding statement. Keep a formal voice.
Part C: Submit your final label set (title, main label with two headings, caption with credit, data graphic with source line, timeline card, words to know), your marked checklist and your revision log.
Amundsen’s team planted their flag together. Next lesson, our class sets up its exhibit together.
Exit ticket: which question on the check felt strongest for you, and which skill do you want to keep practicing?
Pacing: warm-up and two readings 10 minutes, reminders 3, Part A 15, Part B 12 (finish next lesson if needed). Collect Part C at the end.
Source notes: the passage is copied from Gutenberg #4229, Chapter XII. Cuts skip breakfast details, the noon weather, the sentence about the dogs losing interest, the circle of observations the team planned, the handshakes and the description of the flag unfurling. The passage stops before the team kills the dog Helge for food; do not assign the rest of the chapter without preview. The table’s latitudes are copied from “The First Account” and this chapter; 90° as the Pole’s latitude is general knowledge.
Coverage: Part A covers CC.1.2.6.A (questions 1 and the summary), B (2; inference in 3 and 6), C (5), E (6), F (4, 9), G (7), I (8) and L (reading a new passage independently). Parts B and C are scored with the rubric below for CC.1.4.6.A-F.
Supports: read the passage aloud for students with reading accommodations (Part A then measures comprehension, not decoding). Allow typed responses. Descry and topsy-turvy are deliberately left out of the words to know, so questions 3 and 4 test context.
Scoring Part A: questions 1-9 are 1 point each. The short response is scored 0-4: 1 for an objective summary, 1 for a clear central idea, and 1 for each of two details accurately explained (one from the passage, one from the table). Total 13 points; 10 or more meets the standard.
Label set rubric (Part C; use rows 1, 2, 3 and 5 for Part B). Score each row 4 (exceeds), 3 (meets), 2 (approaching) or 1 (beginning).
| Row | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Topic and introduction (A, B) | A focused big idea; title and opening hook STEM-night families and name the topic | Clear topic and an opening that fits the audience | Topic is broad or the opening is flat | Topic unclear |
| 2. Development (C) | Relevant, sourced facts, a definition and an exact, credited quotation | Several sourced facts and a definition or quotation | Few facts, or some not sourced | Facts missing or inaccurate |
| 3. Organization (D) | A clear strategy with two headings, varied transitions and a so-what conclusion | Clear sections, some transitions, a fitting conclusion | Order sometimes confusing; ending stops | Hard to follow; no conclusion |
| 4. Graphic and caption (C) | Accurate graphic with title, labels and source; caption tells what to notice | Accurate graphic and caption with credit | Graphic or caption missing a title or credit | Missing or inaccurate |
| 5. Style (E) | Precise words and topic vocabulary, varied sentences, consistent formal voice | Mostly precise and formal | Vague words or slang in places | Vague or informal throughout |
| 6. Conventions (F) | Few or no errors; pronouns clear; extra information punctuated | Minor errors that do not distract | Frequent errors | Errors make it hard to read |
A total of 18-24 meets the standard for the exhibit. Below 18, confer and allow one more revision before printing. The revision log is required for Part C.
Answer key: 1 = C (index 2), 2 = A (0), 3 = D (3), 4 = B (1), 5 = C (2), 6 = A (0), 7 = D (3), 8 = B (1), 9 = C (2). Sample summary: “On December 14, 1911, Amundsen’s team skied across the flat plateau, watching for anything ahead. At three o’clock the sledge-meters showed they had reached the Pole by reckoning. Amundsen admits he had always dreamed of the North Pole, and he has all five men plant the flag together.” Sample details: “It was not for one man to do this” shows the shared honor; the table shows steady daily progress, which explains how careful reckoning got them there. Sample Part B: “Five Fists, One Flag. On December 14, 1911, five Norwegian explorers reached the South Pole. With no landmarks on the endless plain, they used sledge-meters to measure their distance. At three in the afternoon, the drivers shouted ‘Halt!’ Then, instead of one leader planting the flag, all five grasped the pole together. Their leader, Roald Amundsen, wrote that the honor was ‘for all who had staked their lives in the struggle.’ A month later, Robert Falcon Scott’s British team arrived to find the Norwegian tent. Exploring the Pole took teamwork as much as courage.”
Project Gutenberg, The South Pole by Roald Amundsen, translated by A. G. Chater (1912; New York: Lee Keedick, 1913), eBook #4229 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In 2.20 you read Amundsen’s short first report of reaching the South Pole. This passage comes from Chapter XII of the same book, “At the Pole,” where he tells the day in much more detail. His team of five is skiing beside three dog sledges across the flat polar plateau. They have no landmarks, so they measure distance with sledge-meters, wheels that count the distance a sledge travels.
Pay attention to how Amundsen describes his own feelings. They may surprise you.
Words to know: forerunner means the skier who goes ahead to lead the way; dead reckoning means working out position from distance and direction traveled; stage means one part of a journey; endeavour means effort (British spelling); romancing means making a story more exciting than the truth; diametrically opposite means exactly opposite; ascertain means to find out for certain; solemn means serious and important.
On the morning of December 14 the weather was of the finest, just as if it had been made for arriving at the Pole. […] We went in the usual order — the forerunner, Hanssen, Wisting, Bjaaland, and the reserve forerunner. By noon we had reached 89° 53′ by dead reckoning, and made ready to take the rest in one stage. […] We advanced that day in the same mechanical way as before; not much was said, but eyes were used all the more. Hanssen’s neck grew twice as long as before in his endeavour to see a few inches farther. I had asked him before we started to spy out ahead for all he was worth, and he did so with a vengeance. But, however keenly he stared, he could not descry anything but the endless flat plain ahead of us. […]
At three in the afternoon a simultaneous “Halt!” rang out from the drivers. They had carefully examined their sledge-meters, and they all showed the full distance — our Pole by reckoning. The goal was reached, the journey ended. I cannot say — though I know it would sound much more effective — that the object of my life was attained. That would be romancing rather too bare-facedly. I had better be honest and admit straight out that I have never known any man to be placed in such a diametrically opposite position to the goal of his desires as I was at that moment. The regions around the North Pole — well, yes, the North Pole itself — had attracted me from childhood, and here I was at the South Pole. Can anything more topsy-turvy be imagined?
We reckoned now that we were at the Pole. Of course, every one of us knew that we were not standing on the absolute spot; it would be an impossibility with the time and the instruments at our disposal to ascertain that exact spot. But we were so near it that the few miles which possibly separated us from it could not be of the slightest importance. […] After this we proceeded to the greatest and most solemn act of the whole journey — the planting of our flag. […] I had determined that the act of planting it — the historic event — should be equally divided among us all. It was not for one man to do this; it was for all who had staked their lives in the struggle, and held together through thick and thin. […] Five weather-beaten, frost-bitten fists they were that grasped the pole, raised the waving flag in the air, and planted it as the first at the geographical South Pole.
Source: Project Gutenberg, The South Pole by Roald Amundsen, translated by A. G. Chater (1912; New York: Lee Keedick, 1913), eBook #4229 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)