Museum label set
Why do people explore places where they cannot live?
The mystery: A NASA image of Earth from the Moon (Apollo 8, 1968) beside a NOAA deep-sea image.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
meet the unit question and our STEM-night museum audience, then determine the central idea of a short NASA history article about Apollo 8 and explain how key details convey it.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now: two pictures. Your teacher shows two images side by side: Earth rising above the gray edge of the Moon, photographed from Apollo 8 in 1968, and a robot vehicle shining its lights on the dark deep-sea floor. No person could live in either place. Write one thing you notice and one question you have about each picture.
The astronauts trained for months to study the Moon. What do you predict they said they discovered most?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome to Explorers of Earth and Space. Our unit asks: Why do people explore places where they cannot live? Space and the deep sea have no air to breathe, and the polar ice has almost nothing to eat. Yet people keep going. In Part 2 you will write a museum label set for our school STEM-night exhibit, “Explorers of Earth and Space”: object labels, a timeline and a data graphic. Families will read your labels standing up, in a few seconds each, so every word must be clear, true and backed by a source.
Central idea. The central idea is the most important point a text makes about its topic. The topic of today’s article is Apollo 8. The central idea is what NASA wants us to understand about it. Authors convey (get across) a central idea through particular details: facts, dates, quotations and examples.
Worked example 1: testing a central idea. Priya writes: “Apollo 8 was a bold first trip around the Moon that changed how people saw Earth.” She tests it against the details. The reading says the crew “became the first humans to orbit another world.” It calls the decision “a bold, improvisational call.” It says the Earthrise photo gave people “a new perspective on their home planet.” Three different details point to her sentence, so it works.
Worked example 2: a detail is not the central idea. Marcus writes: “The article is about Lovell joking about Santa Claus.” That quotation is fun, but it is one detail near the end. Marcus asks, “What do most of the paragraphs point to?” Most tell about a bold first trip and a new way of seeing Earth, so he revises.
A model label. Here is a sample label I wrote, to show where we are headed: Earthrise, 1968. On Christmas Eve, Apollo 8 astronaut Bill Anders photographed Earth rising above the Moon. The crew had trained to explore the Moon, but Anders said they “ended up discovering Earth.” Source: NASA. Notice the title, the date, one key fact, one quotation and the source.
Our nonfiction reading lives. All unit you will also read a nonfiction book of your choice about an explorer, space, the ocean or the poles. You will log what you read and bring facts from it to our discussions.
Use the article under “The text.” Put your finger on the sentence that proves each answer.
Write your first evidence response of the unit.
What is the central idea of NASA's article? Write 3-4 sentences. Checklist: (1) the central idea in your own words, (2) two details from the text that convey it, (3) at least one exact quotation in quotation marks.
Wonder Board: write two questions about places people explore but cannot live: one about space and one about the deep sea or the poles. Add them on sticky notes.
We met our question and our audience. Next time we read a famous novel’s view of the deep sea and choose our nonfiction books.
Exit ticket: STEM-night visitors read fast. Write one sentence a visitor should learn about Earthrise in five seconds.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now with images 6, unit launch and audience 5, reading 9, mini lesson 7, guided practice 8, response and Wonder Board 5.
Phenomenon images: project NASA’s Earthrise image article (https://www.nasa.gov/image-article/apollo-8-earthrise/), which credits the photo to Bill Anders aboard Apollo 8, beside the NOAA Ocean Exploration photo on the page used in 2.03 (https://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/facts/explored.html) or the remotely operated vehicle photo on the page used in 2.12. Both agencies’ images are U.S. government works; check each image credit line before printing, because some NOAA images credit partners.
Audience: confirm the STEM-night date, the display space and whether families, younger students or both will visit before promising students a display.
Text note: the cuts skip NASA’s paragraph on the Christmas Eve broadcast, which included a Bible reading, and a paragraph about a 2013 visualization. Keep discussion on exploration.
Likely misconceptions: that Apollo 8 landed on the Moon; that the topic (Apollo 8) is the central idea; that a memorable quotation (Santa Claus) is the central idea.
Supports: frame: “The central idea is ___. One detail that conveys it is ___. Another is ___.” Read the article aloud once. Stretch: why might NASA open with “one of the most turbulent, tragic years in American history”?
Sample response: The central idea is that Apollo 8 was a bold first trip around the Moon that changed how people saw Earth. NASA sent the crew “without a lunar module” on the Saturn V’s first crewed flight. The crew became “the first humans to orbit another world,” and the Earthrise photo gave people “a new perspective on their home planet.” Guided open question: they went to study the Moon, but seeing Earth from far away, small and alone, was the biggest surprise.
NASA, Apollo 8: Christmas at the Moon · U.S. government work, public domain
About the text. This is a history article from NASA, the United States space agency. It looks back at Apollo 8, the December 1968 mission that carried three astronauts around the Moon and back. NASA wrote it for the public, so it mixes facts and dates with the astronauts’ own words.
What to notice. The article moves through the trip in time order, from the risky choice to send the crew, to circling the Moon, to splashdown. Watch for the one idea that many details point to. Notice that NASA uses quotation marks when it repeats what an astronaut said.
Words to know. To orbit is to travel in a path around a planet or moon. Turbulent means full of trouble and sudden change. Iconic means so famous it stands for a whole idea. An improvisational call is a decision made quickly, without the usual long planning. The lunar module was the small craft built to land on the Moon. The Saturn V was the giant rocket that launched Apollo crews.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
Christmas Eve, 1968. As one of the most turbulent, tragic years in American history drew to a close, millions around the world were watching and listening as the Apollo 8 astronauts—Frank Borman, Jim Lovell and Bill Anders – became the first humans to orbit another world.
[…]
The mission was also famous for the iconic “Earthrise” image, snapped by Anders, which would give humankind a new perspective on their home planet. Anders has said that despite all the training and preparation for an exploration of the moon, the astronauts ended up discovering Earth.
[…]
The Apollo 8 astronauts got where they were that Christmas Eve because of a bold, improvisational call by NASA. With the clock ticking on President Kennedy’s challenge to land on the moon by decade’s end, delays with the lunar module were threatening to slow the Apollo program. So NASA decided to change mission plans and send the Apollo 8 crew all the way to the moon without a lunar module on the first manned flight of the massive Saturn V rocket.
[…]
The crew rocketed into orbit on December 21, and after circling the moon 10 times on Christmas Eve, it was time to come home. On Christmas morning, mission control waited anxiously for word that Apollo 8’s engine burn to leave lunar orbit had worked. They soon got confirmation when Lovell radioed, “Roger, please be informed there is a Santa Claus.”
The crew splashed down in the Pacific on December 27. A lunar landing was still months away, but for the first time ever, humans from Earth had visited the moon and returned home safely.
Source: NASA, Apollo 8: Christmas at the Moon (nasa.gov)