analyze how each paragraph of a NASA history of Apollo 8’s arrival at the Moon fits into the overall structure and develops the idea of a risky, precise mission.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Imagine you are in Mission Control. The spacecraft goes behind the Moon and the radio goes silent. Write two feelings you might have and why.
When Apollo 8 lost radio contact behind the Moon, how did NASA feel?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Structure. Structure is how an author organizes a text: the order of paragraphs or sections and how they connect. Common structures include chronological order (time order), cause and effect, problem and solution and compare and contrast. Long texts often mix them.
How one paragraph fits. To analyze a paragraph, ask: What job does it do? What question from the paragraph before does it answer? What would be missing without it? That last question is the strongest test.
Worked example 1: a paragraph that sets up a problem. Mei reads the first paragraph. It explains that losing contact meant the spacecraft was on “a precise trajectory,” and it states the risk: everything depended on an engine burn behind the Moon. She writes: Paragraph 1 sets up a cause-and-effect problem: if the burn works, Mission Control hears from Apollo 8 after 32 minutes and 37 seconds. Without it, readers would not understand why the signal time mattered.
Worked example 2: a paragraph that answers. Carlos reads the third paragraph. Telemetry arrives and Lovell says, “Burn complete.” It answers the question the first paragraph raised: Did it work? It also adds the crew’s first description of the Moon. Carlos writes: Paragraph 3 resolves the suspense and adds new detail about what the crew saw.
Precision as an idea. NASA repeats words about exact timing: “Precisely on time,” “Exactly on schedule,” “precisely on schedule.” The repeated words develop an idea: success depended on perfect timing.
For our timeline. A museum timeline is pure chronological order. Each date on it needs one short event, like the times NASA gives here.
Use the article. Number its paragraphs and write each one’s job in three words in the margin.
Map the structure, then write.
Structure map: draw a flow chart with one box per paragraph. In each box write its job (for example, sets up a risk) and one time or number from it.
Write a paragraph (5-6 sentences): How does the order of the paragraphs build suspense and then release it? Use the words structure and cause and effect, and quote two phrases about timing.
NASA built suspense around a silent radio. Next we jump to 2026 and read words, numbers and pictures together on NASA’s Artemis II page.
Exit ticket: write three timeline entries (time plus event, under ten words each) from today's article.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 11, map and paragraph 8.
Text notes: the cuts skip NASA’s explanation of what different signal times would have meant (in the first paragraph) and the paragraphs on the Earthrise photos and the Christmas Eve broadcast. The page spells both “grey” (in Lovell’s quotation) and “grayish”; both spellings are correct. The article was published for the 50th anniversary; use the date on the page if students ask.
Likely misconceptions: that losing signal was an emergency; that structure means only paragraph length; that the crew landed.
Supports: a four-box frame: Risk, Work, Result, Leaving. Act out the timeline with a ball (Moon) and a toy (spacecraft). Stretch: why might a writer end with “Apollo 8 was heading home to Earth” instead of a fact about fuel?
Answer guide: suspense: paragraph 1 states the risk and the exact signal times (cause and effect); paragraph 2 shows the burn out of contact; paragraph 3 releases suspense with “Burn complete”; the last paragraph repeats the pattern for the trip home (“precisely on schedule”). Timeline: Dec. 24, 1968, contact lost behind the Moon; burn of just over four minutes; signal regained, “Burn complete”; at 89 hours 19 minutes, Trans Earth Injection burn.
NASA History, 50 Years Ago: Apollo 8 in Lunar Orbit · U.S. government work, public domain
About the text. NASA’s history office wrote this article for the 50th anniversary of Apollo 8. It picks up the mission on December 24, 1968, as the spacecraft swings behind the Moon, where no radio signal could reach Earth. To stay at the Moon, the crew had to fire their engine while out of contact.
What to notice. Each paragraph has a job: setting up a risk, showing the crew at work, reporting the result, then ending the visit. Watch the times and how each paragraph answers a question the one before it raised.
Words to know. A trajectory is the path of a moving object. Velocity is speed in a direction. A burn is a firing of a rocket engine. Telemetry is data sent by radio from a spacecraft. The farside is the side of the Moon always turned away from Earth. Elliptical means shaped like a stretched circle. Plaster of Paris is a white powder that hardens into a chalky solid.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
Precisely on time on Dec. 24, 1968, Mission Control lost contact with Apollo 8 and its crew of Frank Borman, James A. Lovell, and William A. Anders. And everyone at NASA and onboard Apollo 8 was happy about that. It meant that the spacecraft and crew were on a precise trajectory to swing behind the Moon, and if all went well, to fire the Service Module’s Service Propulsion System (SPS) engine to slow their velocity just enough to allow the Moon’s gravitational field to capture them. With a successful Lunar Orbit Insertion (LOI) burn, they would become the first crewed spacecraft in lunar orbit, and Mission Control would regain the signal after 32 minutes and 37 seconds.
[…]
While NASA and the world awaited to hear from Apollo 8, Borman, Lovell, and Anders busied themselves with preparing for the engine burn. Just a few minutes before ignition, the crew got its first glimpse of the Moon. During the 66-hour coast to the Moon, the spacecraft was oriented with the SPS engine facing in the direction of travel, so the windows were pointed toward the Earth. Now, about 70 miles above its surface, the Moon finally entered into their field of view and the Apollo 8 crewmembers became the first humans to directly see the farside. Exactly on schedule, the SPS engine lit up and burned for just over four minutes, placing Apollo 8 into an elliptical 70-by-195-mile orbit around the Moon.
Just as expected, Mission Control began receiving telemetry from Apollo 8 as it came out from behind the Moon, followed by Lovell’s simple call, “Houston, Apollo 8. Burn complete.” From Mission Control, Capcom Carr replied, “Apollo 8, this is Houston. Good to hear your voice.” As they passed over the Sea of Fertility, Lovell provided this commentary: “The Moon is essentially grey, no color; looks like plaster of Paris or sort of a grayish beach sand. We can see quite a bit of detail. … The craters are all rounded off. There’s quite a few of them, some of them are newer.”
[…]
At the end of their 10th revolution, at 89 hours and 19 minutes into the flight and once again out of communication with Earth, the Apollo 8 astronauts fired the spacecraft’s SPS engine for the Trans Earth Injection burn. While Mission Control waited for confirmation of the burn, the crew had its last look at the Moon’s farside. Then, precisely on schedule, contact was re-established indicating a successful 3-minute and 23-second burn. Apollo 8 was heading home to Earth.
Source: NASA History, 50 Years Ago: Apollo 8 in Lunar Orbit (nasa.gov)