review the unit’s reading skills on a new passage and compare how two authors present the same event in different types of text.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Think of one day you could describe two ways: in a diary that night, and in a report for your school a year later. Write one thing that would be different about the two versions.
Who probably writes with more feeling about a hard day: someone writing that night, or someone writing a report a year later?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review: the reader’s toolkit. In this unit you have practiced finding a central idea and writing an objective summary, citing evidence for what a text says and what it suggests, tracing how a key event is introduced, illustrated and elaborated, studying how each part fits the structure and working out word meanings from context. Today you use all of them on a new passage, and you compare two authors again, as you did with Henson and Peary in Part 1.
Two authors, two types of text. A journal or diary is written day by day, often for the writer alone, before the ending is known. A report or published account is written afterward, for the public, by someone who knows how things turned out. When two authors present the same event in different types of text, ask: What facts do both include? What does only one include? How does each one’s purpose and situation shape the telling?
| Note card | What the source says (our words) |
|---|---|
| Amundsen, The South Pole, “The First Account” (a report written after the journey, read in 2.20) | The Norwegian team expected to reach the Pole on December 14, 1911. That afternoon the weather was brilliant and the sledges went well; Amundsen says the day passed with nothing worth mentioning. At three o’clock they halted, planted the flag together and named the plateau after King Haakon VII. On December 17 they left a small tent called Polheim, with the Norwegian flag and the Fram’s pennant above it, and started home. |
Worked example 1: Jordan finds a shared fact. Jordan notices that both texts mention a Norwegian flag and a tent near the Pole. Amundsen tells about planting the flag and raising the tent. Scott tells about finding a black flag and the tent. “Same objects,” Jordan writes, “but one author made them and the other discovered them.”
Worked example 2: Amara compares tone. Amara compares two descriptions of reaching the Pole. Amundsen says the day passed with nothing worth mentioning. Scott writes, “We have had a horrible day.” She explains: “Amundsen’s report is calm because he won and wrote later. Scott’s diary is full of feeling because he had just lost the race and did not know if he would get home.”
How Scott introduces the discovery. He does not say “we found the Norwegians’ camp” all at once. He builds it in steps: a possible cairn, a black speck, a black flag, a camp, tracks, dog prints. Then: “This told us the whole story.”
Use Scott’s journal under “The text” and the Amundsen note card. Work alone first, then compare with a partner.
Review and apply.
Write an objective summary of Scott’s three entries in three or four sentences. Leave out your opinions.
Choose two reading skills from today’s review that you want to practice before the unit check. For each, write one question you could ask yourself while reading a new passage.
Same Pole, same tent, two very different texts. Who writes, when and why always shapes what we read.
Exit ticket: if you were writing a label about the South Pole race, which text would you quote, and why?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture with the note card 7, guided practice 15, independent practice 5, closure 1.
Source notes: the passage is copied from Gutenberg #11579, Chapter XVIII, keeping Scott’s spellings (to-morrow, labouring, programme) and double hyphens. Cuts skip a few sentences of route detail, Scott’s note about supper, and the list of five names and objects in the tent. The five names (Amundsen, Bjaaland, Hanssen, Hassel, Wisting) and the date “16 Dec. 1911” are printed in the journal; the note card uses that date. The note card paraphrases Amundsen’s First Account, read in full in 2.20. Stretch readers may notice that Amundsen’s report says the tent was raised on December 17, while the record Scott found was dated December 16; both are true to their texts, and the gap is a good discussion of how records are made.
Discussion note: Scott and his four companions died on the return journey. Students who read 2.21 know this. Keep the focus on the texts, and avoid ranking the explorers as heroes or failures.
Likely misconceptions: that a diary is less reliable than a report (each is reliable about different things); that Scott and Amundsen disagree about facts (they mostly agree; they differ in feeling and purpose); that “Great God!” is slang (it is an exclamation of the time).
Supports: read the passage aloud while students follow. Provide a two-column compare chart (Scott / Amundsen: type of text, when written, for whom, tone, shared facts). Stretch: find the sentence where Scott admits the Norwegians did their job well.
Answer guide: sample short response: “Scott wrote a diary on the day, while Amundsen wrote a report after his success. Scott calls it ‘a horrible day’ because he has just learned he lost the race and still faces ‘a desperate struggle’ home. Amundsen says his day passed with nothing worth mentioning and describes the flag ceremony calmly. Scott’s situation makes his account emotional; Amundsen’s purpose, informing the public, makes his calm and factual.”
Project Gutenberg, Scott’s Last Expedition, Volume I, arranged by Leonard Huxley (New York, 1913), eBook #11579 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
You met Robert Falcon Scott in his Message to the Public. Now read three entries from his journal, the diary he kept every day of the journey. These were written in a tent on January 16, 17 and 18, 1912, by a man who did not yet know what would happen on the way home.
Scott’s party of five was pulling its sledges over the polar plateau, only a short march from the Pole. They hoped to be first. As you read, compare Scott’s entries with what Amundsen reported about the same place a month earlier. A note card in today’s lesson reminds you of Amundsen’s account.
Words to know: T. means temperature; sight here means a measurement of the sun to find position; a cairn is a pile of stones or snow built as a marker; a sastrugus is a ridge of hard snow carved by wind; forestalled means got there first and blocked someone’s plan; labouring means working hard; priority means being first; predecessors means those who came before.
Tuesday, January 16.–Camp 68. Height 9760. T. -23.5°. The worst has happened, or nearly the worst. We marched well in the morning and covered 7 1/2 miles. Noon sight showed us in Lat. 89° 42′ S., and we started off in high spirits in the afternoon, feeling that to-morrow would see us at our destination. About the second hour of the March Bowers’ sharp eyes detected what he thought was a cairn; he was uneasy about it, but argued that it must be a sastrugus. Half an hour later he detected a black speck ahead. Soon we knew that this could not be a natural snow feature. We marched on, found that it was a black flag tied to a sledge bearer; near by the remains of a camp; sledge tracks and ski tracks going and coming and the clear trace of dogs’ paws–many dogs. This told us the whole story. The Norwegians have forestalled us and are first at the Pole. It is a terrible disappointment, and I am very sorry for my loyal companions. […]
Wednesday, January 17.–Camp 69. T. -22° at start. Night -21°. The Pole. Yes, but under very different circumstances from those expected. We have had a horrible day–add to our disappointment a head wind 4 to 5, with a temperature -22°, and companions labouring on with cold feet and hands. […] Great God! this is an awful place and terrible enough for us to have laboured to it without the reward of priority. Well, it is something to have got here, and the wind may be our friend to-morrow. […] Now for the run home and a desperate struggle. I wonder if we can do it.
Thursday morning, January 18.–[…] We have just arrived at this tent, 2 miles from our camp, therefore about 1 1/2 miles from the Pole. In the tent we find a record of five Norwegians having been here, as follows: […] There is no doubt that our predecessors have made thoroughly sure of their mark and fully carried out their programme.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Scott’s Last Expedition, Volume I, arranged by Leonard Huxley (New York, 1913), eBook #11579 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)