write a conclusion that follows from my story’s events and shows what surviving meant, using Shackleton’s account of the rescue on Elephant Island as a model.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Here are three possible endings for “Fence Line.” (A) “Then I woke up and it was all a dream.” (B) “The end.” (C) The real last paragraph, about staying calm long enough to remember what you know. Which ending follows from the story? Why?
Why is ending A a weak choice?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A conclusion is earned. A strong ending follows from the events. It answers the story’s big question (Will they survive?) and shows what the experience meant: what changed, what was learned or what it cost. It should never come out of nowhere.
How Shackleton does it. The whole boat journey had one purpose: to save the men left behind. The conclusion answers that purpose in five words of dialogue: “Are you all well?” “We are all well, boss.” Then he does not stop at the rescue. He looks back on what it took: Wild “had held the party together and kept hope alive in their hearts,” and the “cheerfulness and resource” of the men lasted “four and a half months.” The ending tells us what survival required.
Tension until the last moment. Notice that Shackleton keeps danger alive almost to the end: thick fog, stranded bergs, a reef, ice that might close. The relief means more because the reader has waited for it.
Three kinds of conclusions. (1) Reflection: the narrator thinks about what it meant, like Maya, or like Shackleton blessing the men’s cheerfulness. (2) An image that carries the meaning, like the tiny black figures waving on the beach. (3) A changed action: the character does something new that shows growth.
Worked example 1: Hannah earns her ending. Hannah’s story about a cold-water canoe spill ended, “And we lived happily ever after.” She asks, What did my narrator learn? Revision: “Now, every time I zip my life jacket, I pull the strap one notch tighter and think about how fast the cold took my breath.” The ending grows from the events.
Worked example 2: Andre uses an image. Andre’s lost-hiker story ends with the narrator back home, holding the whistle that helped rescuers find her: “It is only plastic, but it is the loudest thing I own.” One object carries the meaning.
Use the passage. Some answers need you to infer.
Draft your conclusion.
Draft the conclusion of your narrative. Choose reflection, an image or a changed action. In the margin, label which kind you chose.
Follow-through check: list the three events in your story that your conclusion grows out of. If you cannot list three, revise the ending.
Your final sentence is the one readers will carry home from teen night.
Exit ticket: copy your last sentence. What do you want readers to feel when they read it?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, drafting 6, closure 1.
Context: the summary’s facts (twenty-two men under Wild, three failed attempts, the Yelcho lent by Chile) come from the same book; the hut of two upturned boats is described in South’s chapter on Elephant Island. Cuts […] remove a sentence about tobacco and other details. This is the end of the Elephant Island story, not the end of the book, which goes on to the expedition’s Ross Sea party. Students read the ending of “The Open Boat” in Part 1 (1.14); invite them to compare a loss with a rescue.
Likely misconceptions: that a happy ending must be simple (this one admits some men were “in a rather bad way”); that the conclusion should summarize the whole story; that Providence is a place.
Supports: give three ending frames (“Now, whenever I…”, “I still have…”, “I used to think…, but now…”). Stretch: compare Shackleton’s ending with “Fence Line.”
Answer guide: sample summary: “On August 30, 1916, Shackleton’s small steamer reaches Elephant Island through fog and finds all of the stranded men alive. Within an hour they are all aboard and heading north.” Sample image answer: “The tiny figures show how small and far away the men are, and their hurrying shows their joy and hope, so readers feel the relief before anyone speaks.”
Project Gutenberg, South: The Story of Shackleton's Last Expedition 1914-1917 by Sir Ernest Shackleton (1919), eBook #5199 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In 1.19 you read about the James Caird, the small boat Shackleton sailed from Elephant Island to get help. Twenty-two men stayed behind on the island under the command of Frank Wild, with two overturned boats for a hut and very little food. After Shackleton reached South Georgia, three attempts to rescue them failed because sea ice blocked the way.
This passage tells the fourth attempt, in August 1916, on the Yelcho, a small steamer lent by the government of Chile. Shackleton spells the country’s name the old British way, Chilian.
Words to know: Providence means fate or God’s care; the pack means the pack ice, floating sea ice; bergs are icebergs; prolonged means long; resource here means cleverness in solving problems; privation means lacking food, warmth and other needs.
As you read, notice how the ending connects back to the beginning of the journey.
[…] This time Providence favoured us. The little steamer made a quick run down in comparatively fine weather, and I found as we neared Elephant Island that the ice was open. […] We approached the island in a thick fog. I did not dare to wait for this to clear, and at 10 a.m. on August 30 we passed some stranded bergs. Then we saw the sea breaking on a reef, and I knew that we were just outside the island. It was an anxious moment, for we had still to locate the camp and the pack could not be trusted to allow time for a prolonged search in thick weather; but presently the fog lifted and revealed the cliffs and glaciers of Elephant Island. I proceeded to the east, and at 11.40 a.m. Worsley’s keen eyes detected the camp, almost invisible under its covering of snow. The men ashore saw us at the same time, and we saw tiny black figures hurry to the beach and wave signals to us. We were about a mile and a half away from the camp. I turned the Yelcho in, and within half an hour reached the beach with Crean and some of the Chilian sailors. I saw a little figure on a surf-beaten rock and recognized Wild. As I came nearer I called out, “Are you all well?” and he answered, “We are all well, boss,” and then I heard three cheers. […] Some of the hands were in a rather bad way, but Wild had held the party together and kept hope alive in their hearts. […] Everybody was aboard the Yelcho within an hour, and we steamed north at the little steamer’s best speed. […]
During the run up to Punta Arenas I heard Wild’s story, and blessed again the cheerfulness and resource that had served the party so well during four and a half months of privation. The twenty-two men on Elephant Island were just at the end of their resources when the Yelcho reached them. […]
Source: Project Gutenberg, South: The Story of Shackleton's Last Expedition 1914-1917 by Sir Ernest Shackleton (1919), eBook #5199 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)