reflect on my growth as a writer with evidence from my drafts and answer our driving question in a class discussion.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at your first story map from 1.15 and your final story side by side. Write the biggest difference you see.
The man in “Love of Life” survives. How do you predict surviving changes him?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Look back to look ahead. Reflection means thinking about what you did, what you learned and what you will do next. Writers reflect after every project so the next one is stronger.
What London shows. The man survives because “in the very grip of Death he defied Death and refused to die.” But survival leaves a mark: he fills his bunk with hardtack, afraid of “another possible famine.” The scientists say he will recover, and he does. Surviving takes will, and recovering takes time.
Use your evidence. Your story map, drafts, peer conference notes, revision plan, revision log and final story are evidence of your growth. Reflect the way you write about literature: make a claim, then point to proof.
Worked example 1: Noah’s reflection. “My biggest growth was pacing. My first draft said, ‘The ice cracked and I fell in.’ My final draft takes six sentences for that second, including the sound like a rifle shot. My partner said she held her breath.”
Worked example 2: Amara answers the driving question. “Our question was what it takes to survive. Crane’s men needed each other. London’s man in ‘To Build a Fire’ needed a partner and good judgment. Dickinson says it takes hope. In my story, my character survives because she admits she is scared and asks for help. Writing it taught me that asking for help is a survival skill.”
A circle discussion. We finish in a whole-class circle. Come prepared with one piece of evidence from a text and one from your own story. Before you speak, connect to the person before you.
Use the passage, then your own writing folder.
Write your reflection for your portfolio.
Write a reflection paragraph: state your biggest growth as a writer, quote a sentence from an early draft and the same sentence revised, and explain why the change helps the reader.
Answer our driving question in a paragraph: what does it take to survive? State a theme, support it with one character from our unit's reading and your own story, and end with one goal for your next piece of writing.
You have read stories of people who kept going against the odds, and you have written one of your own. That is worth celebrating.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence: “Next time I write a story, I will…”
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 6, guided practice with circle discussion 15, written reflection 8, closure 1.
Content note: the summary mentions, but does not show, the starving man’s weeks alone and the sick wolf; the passage cuts the struggle with the wolf, which is graphic. Food anxiety after hardship is real; some students may connect it to their own lives, so keep the discussion respectful and do not ask students to share personal hardship. The summary’s plot context comes from the same story file.
Likely misconceptions: that reflection means retelling the story; that growth only counts if the final piece is perfect; that the driving question has one right answer.
Supports: provide reflection stems: “At first I…; now I…; this helps the reader because…” Seat the circle so every student can see the speaker, and use a talking object if needed. Record discussion skills for CC.1.5.6.A.
Answer guide: sample reflection: “My biggest growth was dialogue. In my first draft my uncle never spoke; I wrote ‘he was worried.’ After my conference I added, ‘Feet dry?’ he asked for the third time. My partner said that line showed how scared he was.” Sample driving-question paragraph: “Survival takes calm judgment and other people. In ‘The Open Boat,’ the men take turns rowing and bailing and stay calm together, and in my story the narrator survives because she tells her uncle the truth about her wet boot. My goal next time is to slow down more moments.”
Project Gutenberg, Love of Life and Other Stories by Jack London (Macmillan, copyright 1906), eBook #710, "Love of Life" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
You read the opening of “Love of Life” in 1.16 and the pool scene in the unit check. After Bill leaves, the unnamed man struggles on alone for weeks, starving, sick and followed by a sick wolf. He finally sees the ocean and a ship. Scientists on the whaling ship Bedford find him crawling along the beach and bring him aboard.
The first paragraph below comes just before the rescue, when he is near death. The rest shows his first weeks on the ship.
Words to know: undergone means lived through; babbled incoherently means talked in a confused way; gloated over means stared at with greedy delight; privily means secretly; hardtack is a hard, dry biscuit sailors ate; famine means a time of terrible hunger; ere means before.
As you read, ask what this ending says about what it takes to survive, and what survival leaves behind.
[…] And yet he wanted to live. It was unreasonable that he should die after all he had undergone. Fate asked too much of him. And, dying, he declined to die. It was stark madness, perhaps, but in the very grip of Death he defied Death and refused to die.
[…]
Three weeks afterward the man lay in a bunk on the whale-ship Bedford, and with tears streaming down his wasted cheeks told who he was and what he had undergone. He also babbled incoherently of his mother, of sunny Southern California, and a home among the orange groves and flowers.
The days were not many after that when he sat at table with the scientific men and ship’s officers. He gloated over the spectacle of so much food, watching it anxiously as it went into the mouths of others. With the disappearance of each mouthful an expression of deep regret came into his eyes. He was quite sane, yet he hated those men at mealtime. He was haunted by a fear that the food would not last. […]
[…]
The scientific men were discreet. They let him alone. But they privily examined his bunk. It was lined with hardtack; the mattress was stuffed with hardtack; every nook and cranny was filled with hardtack. Yet he was sane. He was taking precautions against another possible famine–that was all. He would recover from it, the scientific men said; and he did, ere the Bedford’s anchor rumbled down in San Francisco Bay.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Love of Life and Other Stories by Jack London (Macmillan, copyright 1906), eBook #710, "Love of Life" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)