determine the central idea of a passage from Henson’s memoir, cite evidence for inferences about why he explored, and show what I have learned across the unit’s texts in a reading check.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at our Wonder Board. Move every question we can now answer to the “Answered” side, and write the source that answered it.
After the hard journey, did Henson want to go back to the Arctic?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Putting it together. Across this part we have found central ideas, quoted to infer, tracked how ideas and people develop, decoded figurative and technical words, studied structure, combined numbers and pictures with words and compared two authors. Today we use all of it on one passage and then across the unit.
Worked example 1: figurative language. Destiny reads “Imagine gorgeous bleakness, beautiful blankness.” Each pair joins words that seem to clash: gorgeous with bleak, beautiful with blank. These contrasts are called oxymorons. She explains: Henson shows that the Arctic is empty and harsh, and still beautiful to him.
Worked example 2: central idea and inference. Kenji notices that Henson calls the region’s pull “an irresistible fascination” and ends with “the lure of the Arctic is tugging at my heart.” He states the central idea: Henson loved the Arctic’s strange beauty and its trail so much that he wanted to return. He infers: For Henson, exploring was not only a job; it was a calling.
Answering the driving question. Why do people explore places where they cannot live? Our texts gave many answers: science (Shackleton, NOAA), resources and protection (NOAA), new ways of seeing home (Apollo 8), national pride (Shackleton, Peary) and the pull of beauty and adventure (Verne’s Nemo, Henson). A strong answer names more than one reason and cites sources.
Discussion norms. Come prepared with evidence, build on a classmate’s idea before adding your own, and ask a question that moves the talk forward.
Reading life check. Bring your nonfiction log. Be ready to share one fact from your book that could appear in our exhibit.
Reading check, part 1: today’s passage.
Reading check, part 2: across the unit.
In the NOAA fact page from 2.03, which was smallest?
In 2.08, what did the photo caption on the Artemis II page reveal?
Short response: Why do people explore places where they cannot live? Write 6-8 sentences using evidence from at least three texts in this part. Name each source, quote accurately and explain how the evidence fits together. Include at least two different reasons.
Reading life: finish your nonfiction log. Write three sentences about your book: its central idea, one fact you could use in our exhibit and how you would rate it for a classmate.
We read like researchers. In Part 2 we write like museum curators.
Exit ticket: write the heading of the label you most want to write for our exhibit, and the source you will use first.
Pacing (40 min): Wonder Board 4, reading 7, mini lesson 6, reading check part 1 and discussion circle 12, reading check part 2 11.
Text notes: the first cut skips Henson’s description of the twilight and the sun’s distorted shape; the second skips the rest of Chapter VIII and all of Chapters IX-XXI, jumping to the book’s last paragraph. “Mr. Stokes” is not identified in the passage; do not guess. Crocker Land was later shown not to exist; share only if asked. Henson’s “Well done, my boy” quotes Peary; discuss how the word “boy” for a grown Black man reflects the unequal relationship of the time, and connect to 2.11. Stretch: compare the book’s last lines with the monument inscription in 2.11 and note how the inscription changed the punctuation and capitals.
Point scheme for the reading check (20 points): part 1 quizzes, true/false and fill-in 1 point each (6); part 2 quizzes 1 point each (2); discussion contribution scored 0-2 (prepared with evidence, builds on others); short response scored 0-10 on the rubric below. This is a formative check; the unit check in Part 2 scores the final label set.
Short-response rubric (4 levels): 4 clear claim with two or more reasons; accurate evidence from three or more named sources; reasoning connects them; no unsupported claims. 3 clear claim; evidence from three sources with small quoting slips; some reasoning. 2 claim; evidence from one or two sources; little explanation. 1 no clear claim or no text evidence. Convert 4/3/2/1 to 10/8/5/2 points.
Answer guide: discussion and response: accept reasoned answers that cite sources. Sample short response: People explore places where they cannot live for knowledge, for their nations and for the pull of the unknown. NOAA’s page (2.04) argues that we cannot manage or protect an ocean we do not know, and its fact page (2.03) says explorers have seen less than 0.001% of the deep seafloor. Shackleton’s preface (2.05) calls his crossing scientifically important, but he also wanted the honor for a British expedition. Henson simply loved the Arctic: “the lure of the Arctic is tugging at my heart.” Apollo 8’s crew went to study the Moon and, as the reading reports (2.01), found a new way of seeing Earth. Together these sources show that exploring teaches us about the world and about ourselves. Students’ own responses should quote earlier texts exactly from their notes or the earlier lessons.
Matthew A. Henson, A Negro Explorer at the North Pole (Frederick A. Stokes, 1912), Project Gutenberg eBook #20923 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #20923
About the text. The first part of this passage comes from Chapter VIII of Henson’s 1912 memoir, while the party waited at Cape Columbia, at the northern edge of land, before sledging out over the frozen ocean. The last two paragraphs are the very end of his story, written after the expedition was home.
What to notice. Henson says he has “no poetry” in his soul, and then writes some of the most poetic lines in his book. Notice the pairs of opposite words, and how his feelings change from describing the land to longing for it. Grant Land is the name the explorers used for the northern part of Ellesmere Island, in today’s Canada. Crocker Land was a land some explorers believed lay farther north.
Words to know. Desolation means emptiness with no life or comfort. Irresistible means too strong to resist. Inhospitable means hard to live in. Unexampled means never seen before. Lithe means slim and moving easily. The lure of a place is its strong pull.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
While we waited here, we had time to appreciate the magnificent desolation about us.
[…]
There is an irresistible fascination about the regions of northern-most Grant Land that is impossible for me to describe. Having no poetry in my soul, and being somewhat hardened by years of experience in that inhospitable country, words proper to give you an idea of its unique beauty do not come to mind. Imagine gorgeous bleakness, beautiful blankness.
[…]
The south sides of the lofty peaks have for days reflected the glory of the coming sun, and it does not require an artist to enjoy the unexampled splendor of the view. The snows covering the peaks show all of the colors, variations, and tones of the artist’s palette, and more. Artists have gone with us into the Arctic and I have heard them rave over the wonderful beauties of the scene, and I have seen them at work trying to reproduce some of it, with good results but with nothing like the effect of the original. As Mr. Stokes said, “it is color run riot.”
[…]
I long to see them all again! the brave, cheery companions of the trail of the North. I long to see again the lithe figure of my Commander! and to hear again his clear, ringing voice urging and encouraging me onward, with his “Well done, my boy.” I want to be with the party when they reach the untrod shores of Crocker Land; I yearn to be with those who reach the South Pole, the lure of the Arctic is tugging at my heart, to me the trail is calling!
“The Old Trail! The Trail that is always New!”
Source: Matthew A. Henson, A Negro Explorer at the North Pole (Frederick A. Stokes, 1912), Project Gutenberg eBook #20923 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)