give and use specific feedback on informative labels, check every fact against its source and revise with a log.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Which feedback would help you more? (A) “It’s good.” (B) “Your opening made me picture the ice, but I lost track in section two, where the dates jump around (checklist #8).” Write why.
What should a reviewer do first when reading a partner’s label?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every exhibit is revised. Professional label writers never publish a first draft. Editors, scientists and test readers read it first. Today you are each other’s test readers.
Our review protocol. (1) Retell: the reviewer says the label’s big idea in one sentence. If the retelling is off, the writer knows the label is not clear yet. (2) Glow: one specific strength, with a checklist number. (3) Grow: one specific change, with a checklist number and a place in the draft. (4) Fact check: the reviewer points to one fact and asks, “Where did this come from?” The writer shows the source. (5) So what?: the reviewer says why a visitor should care.
Practice on NOAA. Retell: the ocean averages about 3,682 meters deep, and its deepest spot, the Challenger Deep, is about 10,935 meters. Glow: exact numbers in two units, so readers who use meters or feet both understand (#9). Grow for our audience: a seven-year-old may not picture 10,935 meters; a comparison would help (#4). Notice the page also has no quotation, which our checklist asks for (#5).
Worked example 1: Maya gives a useful grow. Maya reads her partner’s Earthrise label. Instead of “add more,” she says: “In section two you say the photo was taken ‘by accident.’ The NASA page says the roll brought Earth into view, but not that it was an accident. Can you show me where that came from (#3)?” Her partner cannot, so he revises.
Worked example 2: Leo keeps a revision log. Leo lists each change: 1. Added a definition of glacier (#4) because my partner asked what it meant. 2. Moved the 1912 fact into section one (#7) so the dates go in order. 3. Cut ‘super cold’ and wrote -47° (#9). Each change has a reason.
First practice on NOAA’s page, then review a partner’s label.
Workshop in pairs, then revise.
Reviewer: after reading your partner’s label set, write (1) the big idea in one sentence, (2) one glow with a checklist number, (3) one grow with a checklist number and a place in the draft, (4) the fact you checked and its source, and (5) your answer to “So what?”
Writer: start your revision log. List at least three changes you will make from your partner’s feedback and the checklist. For each, write the checklist number and why. Make the changes and give your new word count.
For decades, the Earthrise photograph from Apollo 8 was one of the most famous pictures in the world. But some details of how it was taken were not widely known. In 2013, for the photo’s 45th anniversary, a team at NASA’s Scientific Visualization Studio decided to check the story against the evidence.
According to our reading’s page, the team used photos and elevation data from the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter, the cloud pattern on Earth from the ESSA-7 satellite, dozens of Apollo 8 photographs and the astronauts’ onboard audio. A camera on Apollo 8 had photographed the lunar surface every 20 seconds. By lining up each of those photos with a model of the Moon’s terrain, the team worked out exactly which way the spacecraft was facing. The work showed that the spacecraft was rolling when the photos were taken and identified, for the first time, which window each photo was taken from. Ernie Wright created the visualization, and the author Andrew Chaikin narrated the video.
Like our class, NASA’s team did not simply repeat what everyone remembered. They went back to the sources, checked each detail and told the public what the evidence showed.
NASA rechecked a famous photo after 45 years. Checking our facts before STEM night is the least we can do.
Exit ticket: what is the most useful feedback you received today, and what will you change because of it?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading and NOAA practice review 8, mini lecture with the case study 8, guided practice 7, two peer rounds of 6 minutes each, revision log 1, closure 1. Continue revision in 2.24 if needed.
Source notes: the passage is copied from the NOAA National Ocean Service page (last updated 09/23/26 on the page), including its bold headline sentence; the photo and its caption are not reproduced. The case study uses only the NASA SVS page “Earthrise: The 45th Anniversary” read in 2.15.
Likely misconceptions: that feedback means the reviewer fixes the draft (the writer decides); that a fact check is an insult (it is how experts work); that “about 11,000” and “approximately 10,935” mean the same on a label (use the source’s number, or say you rounded).
Supports: give reviewers sentence starters: “Your big idea is …” “One thing that taught me something was … (#).” “I was confused when … (#).” Pair students thoughtfully and allow a teacher conference for writers who need one. Stretch: review a second label with a different strategy and compare.
Answer guide: sample NOAA review: Retell: the ocean is about 3,682 meters deep on average, and the Challenger Deep is far deeper at about 10,935 meters. Glow (#9): exact numbers in two units. Grow (#4): add a comparison a child can picture. So what: most of that depth is still unexplored, so there is a lot left to discover. Collect revision logs; they are part of the label score in 2.25.
NOAA National Ocean Service, Ocean Facts: How deep is the ocean? · U.S. government work (NOAA), public domain; photo credits on the page belong to their owners and the photos are not reproduced
NOAA’s National Ocean Service publishes short “Ocean Facts” pages that each answer one question for the public. This one answers a question a seven-year-old might ask at our exhibit: how deep is the ocean?
The page is only a few sentences long, much like our main labels. Today we use it as a practice piece. Read it once for the facts. Then review it the way you will review a partner’s label: retell its big idea, find what it does well and decide what you might add for STEM-night families.
Words to know: average means the typical amount found by combining many measurements; trench means a long, deep valley in the seafloor; territorial island means an island that belongs to a country without being a state; sounded here means measured how deep the water is.
The average ocean depth is 3,682 meters (12,080 feet).
[…]
The average depth of the ocean is about 3,682 meters (12,080 feet). The deepest part of the ocean is called the Challenger Deep and is located beneath the western Pacific Ocean in the southern end of the Mariana Trench, which runs several hundred kilometers southwest of the U.S. territorial island of Guam. Challenger Deep is approximately 10,935 meters (35,876 feet) deep. It is named after the HMS Challenger, whose crew first sounded the depths of the trench in 1875.
Source: NOAA National Ocean Service, Ocean Facts: How deep is the ocean? (oceanservice.noaa.gov)