examine how Robert E. Peary presents the arrival near the North Pole compared with Matthew Henson’s memoir, and write a short response citing evidence.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. You and a teammate win a game together. You each write one sentence about it for the school paper. List two ways your sentences might differ even if both are true.
Peary wrote in his diary when he believed he had reached the Pole. Which word do you predict he used?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two authors, one event. When two authors present the same event, they may include different facts, emphasize different people and use different words. Comparing them shows each author’s point of view and helps us build a fuller picture. Ask: What does each include? What does each leave out? What words show how each feels?
What we know from Henson (2.09). In his memoir, Henson described the endless daylight, his fall into the lead, Ootah pulling him out and Peary unfolding his silk flag at the April 6 camp. He put the team and the danger at the center.
Worked example 1: what Peary includes. Zara lists Peary’s details: the march ended “at ten o’clock on the forenoon of April 6,” his “reckoning,” his exhaustion and his diary. She notices that Peary mentions Henson and the Inuit men once, “having unloaded the sledges.” She writes: Peary focuses on his own goal and feelings; the others appear as helpers in one clause.
Worked example 2: word choice. Eli compares pronouns. Peary’s diary says “My dream and goal” and “Mine at last!” Eli recalls that Henson’s chapter spoke of the whole party traveling together. Eli writes: Peary presents the Pole as his personal prize, while Henson presents it as a shared struggle. He supports the Peary half with quotations and the Henson half with his 2.09 notes.
Claim versus proof. Peary writes that his reckoning “showed that we were in the immediate neighborhood of the goal.” Notice that this is Peary’s report of his own measurements. Historians have long debated whether his party reached the exact Pole. Careful labels say Peary reported or claimed when the evidence is one person’s account.
Response frame. A comparison response states how the two authors differ, gives evidence from each and explains why the difference matters.
Use Peary’s passage and your 2.09 notes on Henson.
Write a comparison response.
Short response (6-8 sentences): How does Peary's presentation of the arrival near the Pole differ from Henson's? Checklist: (1) a clear claim about the difference, (2) at least two quotations from Peary, (3) at least one specific detail from your Henson notes, (4) an explanation of why the difference matters for a museum visitor.
Reading life: in your nonfiction book, find one place where the author tells you whose account a fact comes from. Copy the sentence and note the page.
Two explorers told the same days differently. Next we read a government biography of Henson and compare a memoir with a biography.
Exit ticket: rewrite this label to be more accurate and fair: “Peary reached the North Pole alone in 1909.”
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 8, guided practice and discussion 12, response 8.
Content care: other parts of Peary’s book, including the chapter before this one, make racist statements about Henson and about the Inuit (for example, Peary claims Henson’s race made him unfit to lead a return party). The passage leaves those out. If a strong reader finds them in the full text, discuss them directly: they show Peary’s prejudice and help explain why Henson received less credit. Do not assign the full chapter.
Accuracy: whether Peary’s party reached the exact Pole has been debated since 1909, because his navigation records were never independently checked at the time. Teach students to write “Peary reported” and to cite sources. The cuts skip Peary’s description of further observation trips and the flags and records left at the camp.
Likely misconceptions: that one account is true and the other false; that a leader’s account is automatically the most complete; that “Eskimo” is the people’s own name.
Supports: a two-column chart (Peary / Henson): who is named, what happens, key words. Stretch: why might Peary call reaching the Pole “simple and commonplace” right after calling it a prize?
Answer guide: Sample response: Peary presents the arrival as his own achievement, while Henson presents it as a team’s dangerous struggle. Peary describes his reckoning, his exhaustion and his diary: “My dream and goal for twenty years. Mine at last!” He mentions Henson and the Inuit men only as having “unloaded the sledges.” Henson, in contrast, tells how Ootah pulled him from the icy water and how the party pushed on together. A visitor who read only Peary would not know that others risked their lives too, so the exhibit should quote both. Exit ticket: Robert Peary, Matthew Henson and four Inuit men, Ootah, Egingwah, Seegloo and Ooqueah, reported reaching the area of the North Pole in April 1909.