give and use specific feedback in a peer conference and make a revision plan, after studying how Jack London rewrote “To Build a Fire.”
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of a time someone gave you advice about something you made. What made the advice easy or hard to hear? Write two sentences.
Jack London wrote “To Build a Fire” twice. In the first version (1902), what do you predict happens to the man?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision means re-seeing. Revising is not just fixing commas. It means looking at your story again and asking, Is this the best way to tell it? Sometimes the answer is a new approach. The standard calls this “revising, editing, rewriting, or trying a new approach.”
Today’s workshop. First a case study of a writer who rewrote a whole story. Then you will meet with a partner using a three-step protocol: retell, glow and grow.
Step 1: Retell. The reader summarizes the writer’s story in two sentences, objectively, with no opinions. If the summary misses something important, the writer learns what is unclear. Step 2: Glow. Name one specific strength and point to the exact words. Step 3: Grow. Ask one question or suggest one change tied to the checklist, such as “Could you slow down the moment the ice cracks?”
Worked example 1: Jordan gives a useful grow. Jordan reads Priya’s flood story. Unhelpful: “Make it better.” Helpful: “In the middle you jump from the basement to the roof. Could you add a transition that shows how you got there? That’s checklist item 6.”
Worked example 2: Priya builds a revision plan. Priya does not make every change. She lists three: add a transition (from Jordan), add one sound detail during the flood (her own idea), and cut a paragraph about lunch. Next to each she writes why. That list is her revision plan, and her log will record what she actually changed.
Discussion norms. Look at the speaker. Build on ideas (“Adding to what you said…”). Ask questions that move the talk forward. The writer listens first and decides later.
Compare the versions, then practice the protocol with “Fence Line.”
Make your revision plan.
Write your revision plan: three changes you will make, where in the draft, which checklist item each one serves and why. At least one must come from your partner and one from you.
Try a new approach: rewrite your opening or your ending in a completely different way, as London did. Paste both versions and explain which you will keep.
In 1902 Jack London published “To Build a Fire” in The Youth’s Companion. His hero, Tom Vincent, travels alone, loses his fire to falling snow, rebuilds it and limps into camp the next day. The story begins by stating its lesson, “Never travel alone,” and ends by repeating it.
Six years later London wrote the story again for The Century Magazine (August 1908). This time the man has no name. The cold is colder, a dog is added and becomes an important character, the old-timer’s warning returns again and again, and the second fire fails. The man dies, and the dog trots on toward camp. London no longer announces the lesson; readers discover it. The 1908 version is the one most readers know today. Both versions, along with the 1910 book copy, are listed together on Wikisource.
Think about it: London kept the setting, the falling snow and the lesson about traveling alone, but changed the ending and the way the lesson is delivered. Which version do you think is stronger for teen readers, and what does this case teach you about revising your own story?
London rewrote a published story. Your draft can change too.
Exit ticket: which piece of feedback today will most improve your story, and what will you do with it?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 6, case study 7, mini lecture 6, protocol practice and conference 14, revision plan 3, closure 1.
About the 1902 text: the passage was transcribed from the Internet Archive scan’s text layer (The Youth’s Companion, May 29, 1902, page 274). OCR column breaks, hyphens, the decorative drop capital and a few letter misreads were repaired; the page image was not checked word by word, so preview the scan if exact wording matters. The case study’s facts about the 1908 version come from the Lost Face text used in 1.18, and the publication list from Wikisource’s “To Build a Fire” versions page (https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/To_Build_a_Fire).
Likely misconceptions: that revision means editing; that good writers get it right the first time; that a grow comment is an insult.
Supports: post the protocol and sentence stems; pair thoughtfully; let students read their drafts aloud to partners who struggle with handwriting. Observe and record discussion skills for CC.1.5.6.A.
Answer guide: case study responses vary; strong answers say the 1908 version is more powerful because readers feel the lesson instead of being told it, or defend 1902 for younger readers, and connect to trying a new approach in their own draft. Sample revision plan item: “Add the sound of the ice cracking in paragraph 4 (checklist 4), because my partner could not picture the danger.”
Internet Archive, The Youth's Companion, May 29, 1902 (vol. 76, no. 22), Jack London, "To Build a Fire" (first version) · Public domain in the United States (published 1902); scan from the Internet Archive
Before the version you know, Jack London published a shorter “To Build a Fire” in The Youth’s Companion, a magazine for young readers, on May 29, 1902. In it, a young man named Tom Vincent travels alone at sixty below zero to rejoin his partners. As in the later story, he gets his feet wet, builds a fire, and snow from a tree puts it out.
But this version ends differently, and it begins by telling the reader the lesson. The passage below gives you its opening, the moment the snow falls and its ending. Compare each part with the 1908 version.
Words to know: precept means a rule for how to act; strapping means big and strong; smote means struck; presence of mind means staying calm and thinking clearly; counteracted means undone or worked against; destined means sure to happen.
For land travel or seafaring, the world over, a companion is usually considered desirable. In the Klondike, as Tom Vincent found out, such a companion is absolutely essential. But he found it out, not by precept, but through bitter experience.
“Never travel alone,” is a precept of the north. He had heard it many times and laughed; for he was a strapping young fellow, big-boned and big-muscled, with faith in himself and in the strength of his head and hands.
[…]
The snow from the topmost bough was the first to fall, striking and dislodging the snow on the boughs beneath. And all this snow, accumulating as it fell, smote Tom Vincent’s head and shoulders and blotted out his fire.
He still kept his presence of mind, for he knew how great his danger was. He started at once to rebuild the fire, but his fingers were now so cold that he could not bend them, and he was forced to pick up each twig and splinter between the tips of the fingers of either hand.
[…]
For three hours he worked, till the worst effects of the freezing had been counteracted. All that night he stayed by the fire, and it was late the next day when he limped pitifully into the camp on the Cherry Creek Divide.
In a month’s time he was able to be about on his feet, although the toes were destined always after that to be very sensitive to frost. But the scars on his hands he knows he will carry to the grave. And—“Never travel alone!” he now lays down the precept of the north.
Source: Internet Archive, The Youth's Companion, May 29, 1902 (vol. 76, no. 22), Jack London, "To Build a Fire" (first version) (archive.org)