edit my label set for grade 6 conventions: pronoun case and clear pronouns, commas and dashes around extra information, and spelling.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Find the problem: “Shackleton told Worsley that he would steer the boat.” Who will steer? Rewrite the sentence so there is only one possible answer.
Why is “he” a problem in the Do Now sentence?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revise first, then edit. Revising changes ideas, order and words. Editing fixes conventions so nothing distracts a visitor. A single error on a printed label can make readers doubt every fact on it, so we edit carefully.
1. Pronoun case. Use subject pronouns (I, he, she, we, they) as subjects, object pronouns (me, him, her, us, them) after verbs and prepositions, and possessive pronouns (his, her, their) for ownership: “Hurley and he watched,” “The Boss called to them.” An intensive pronoun (himself, ourselves) adds emphasis: “Shackleton himself gave the order.”
2. Clear, consistent pronouns. Every pronoun needs one clear antecedent, the word it stands for. In the diary, she always means the ship, so it is clear. Also avoid shifting person: the diary moves from “one knows … one’s ship” to “as we did.” That was a common style in 1919, but on our labels, pick one point of view and keep it.
3. Setting off extra information. Commas, dashes and parentheses set off nonrestrictive information, words that add detail but could be removed: “Sir Ernest, standing on the top of the look-out, said…” and “It must, however, be said.” Commas are quiet, dashes are dramatic and parentheses whisper.
4. Spelling and confused words. Use modern spelling on labels: everyone (not every one when you mean all people) and forever. Check their/there/they’re and its/it’s. Put ship names in italics: Endurance. Keep exact quotations exactly as printed, older spellings and all.
Worked example 1: Hana fixes pronouns. Hana’s sentence: “Amundsen and Scott both reached the Pole, but he got there first.” She revises: “Amundsen and Scott both reached the Pole, but Amundsen got there first.”
Worked example 2: Omar punctuates extra information. Omar writes: “The AUV a robot with no cable maps the seafloor.” He sets off the extra phrase: “The AUV, a robot with no cable, maps the seafloor.” Then he tries dashes for drama in another sentence: “The ship sank — bows first — into the ice.”
Use the diary under “The text” for the first two questions, then edit the label sentences.
Revision and editing studio: finish revising, then edit.
Finish any revisions from your peer review and revision log. Then edit with this order: (1) every pronoun has one clear antecedent and the right case; (2) no shifts in person; (3) commas, dashes or parentheses around extra information; (4) spelling, capitals and italics for ship names; (5) every quotation matches its source exactly. List three edits you made.
Read your label set aloud to a partner, slowly, one sentence at a time. Mark any place you stumble and fix it. Then time yourself reading the main label for your 60-second docent talk.
A clean label lets visitors trust every word. Your work goes to print next.
Exit ticket: which convention did you fix most often today? Write one before-and-after example.
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, revision and editing 11, closure 1. This flex lesson can stretch over two periods for students who need more revision time.
Source notes: the passage is copied from Gutenberg #5199, Chapter V (“Ocean Camp”), keeping its curly quotation marks, em dash and older spellings. The book does not name the diarist at this point; the summary says only that it is one of his men, as the text shows (“the Boss,” “Sir Ernest”). The cut skips three sentences about the camp’s mood. The diary’s first sentence has no comma after “tents”; do not “correct” quoted text, but students may say where a modern writer would add one.
Likely misconceptions: that “myself” is more polite than “me” or “I” (it is only for emphasis or reflexive use); that old spellings in a quotation should be fixed (never inside quotation marks); that dashes and hyphens are the same mark.
Supports: provide an editing checklist strip in the order above. Model one edit aloud using a student volunteer’s sentence. Pair editors so each checks a different convention. Stretch: write one sentence for your label that uses a dash pair and one that uses parentheses, and decide which fits a formal label better.
Answer guide: edited sentence: “When the ice crushed the Endurance in 1915, Shackleton and his crew had to leave their ship, and they felt deep sadness.” Fixes: comma after the opening clause; “him” to a clear subject; “there” to “their”; the shift to “you” removed; “they was” to a correct verb; ship name in italics.
Project Gutenberg, South: The Story of Shackleton’s Last Expedition 1914–1917 by Sir Ernest Shackleton (1919; New York: Macmillan, 1920), eBook #5199 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
After the Endurance was abandoned, the crew camped on the ice nearby at a place they called Ocean Camp. The broken ship stayed stuck in the ice for almost a month. On November 21, 1915, it finally sank.
Shackleton tells the moment by quoting a diary entry by one of his men, who calls Shackleton “the Boss” and “Sir Ernest.” Sailors call a ship “she,” so watch the pronouns she and her. Notice the commas and dashes that set off extra information, and the older spellings, such as for ever and every one.
Words to know: vantage means a good place to see from; bows means the front of a ship; mastless means without masts; destitution means having nothing; pathos means deep sadness; passage-at-arms means a friendly argument; inadequacy means not being enough.
It was with a feeling almost of relief that the end came.
“November 21, 1915.—This evening, as we were lying in our tents we heard the Boss call out, ‘She’s going, boys!’ We were out in a second and up on the look-out station and other points of vantage, and, sure enough, there was our poor ship a mile and a half away struggling in her death-agony. She went down bows first, her stern raised in the air. She then gave one quick dive and the ice closed over her for ever. It gave one a sickening sensation to see it, for, mastless and useless as she was, she seemed to be a link with the outer world. Without her our destitution seems more emphasized, our desolation more complete. […] When one knows every little nook and corner of one’s ship as we did, and has helped her time and again in the fight that she made so well, the actual parting was not without its pathos, quite apart from one’s own desolation, and I doubt if there was one amongst us who did not feel some personal emotion when Sir Ernest, standing on the top of the look-out, said somewhat sadly and quietly, ‘She’s gone, boys.’
“It must, however, be said that we did not give way to depression for long, for soon every one was as cheery as usual. Laughter rang out from the tents, and even the Boss had a passage-at-arms with the storekeeper over the inadequacy of the sausage ration, insisting that there should be two each ‘because they were such little ones,’ instead of the one and a half that the latter proposed.”
Source: Project Gutenberg, South: The Story of Shackleton’s Last Expedition 1914–1917 by Sir Ernest Shackleton (1919; New York: Macmillan, 1920), eBook #5199 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)