use transitions to link my ideas, write a timeline card and draft a concluding statement, using Amundsen’s first account of reaching the South Pole.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read these sentences with no transitions: “The weather cleared. We checked our position. We passed the old record. We camped.” Add one transition word or phrase to the start of three sentences. How does the passage change?
Which transition shows that something happened as a result?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Transitions are the glue. A transition is a word or phrase that shows how one idea connects to the next. Without transitions, a label reads like a list. With them, visitors can follow your thinking.
| Relationship | Transitions |
|---|---|
| Time | first, then, on December 14, by noon, up to this moment, decades later |
| Cause and effect | because, so, as a result, therefore, so that |
| Contrast | but, however, unlike, yet, instead |
| Addition and example | also, in addition, for example, such as |
How Amundsen moves through time. Nearly every sentence starts with a time marker: “On December 1,” “On December 2,” “In the afternoon.” Then he speeds up with a list of dates and latitudes, December 10 through 13. The phrase “Up to this moment” turns the reader toward the big event. Notice also how he introduces the arrival (“We reckoned that we should be at the Pole on December 14”), illustrates it (the weather, the halt at three o’clock) and elaborates on it (the flag, the plateau’s name, the tent).
Conclusions. Amundsen’s last sentence sums up the whole journey in two numbers: about 870 miles at about 15 1/2 miles a day. A concluding statement can sum up, answer “So what?”, leave the visitor with an image or connect the topic to the visitor’s own life.
Timeline cards. Our exhibit has a class timeline. Each card has a date and one complete sentence that names who did what. Exact dates come from your source.
Worked example 1: Noah writes a timeline card. Noah’s first try: “Amundsen got to the Pole.” He adds the date and specifics from the passage: “December 14, 1911. Roald Amundsen’s Norwegian team halts at the South Pole and plants its flag.”
Worked example 2: Ava writes a conclusion. Ava’s label ends: “That’s it.” She revises to answer “So what?”: “Amundsen’s team crossed about 870 miles of ice to stand where no one had stood before. Their careful measurements, checked day after day, are how we know they really got there.” Both sentences come from facts in the passage.
Use Amundsen’s account under “The text.” Box every date and circle every transition.
Link and close your label.
Add at least three transitions to your draft, using at least two kinds from today’s table (time, cause and effect, contrast, addition). Copy each sentence you changed.
Write two possible concluding statements for your label: one that sums up and one that answers “So what?” for a visitor. Choose one and explain why. Then write your timeline card.
Amundsen ended a journey of about 870 miles with one sentence. Your ending can be just as strong.
Exit ticket: copy your concluding statement. Underline the words that answer “So what?”
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 8, guided practice 12, drafting 6, closure 1.
Source notes: the passage is copied from Gutenberg #4229 (“The First Account”), including its double hyphens for dashes. The first cut skips the “Devil’s Ballroom” description; the second skips one sentence on the plateau sloping down; the third skips the observations of December 15-16. The account just before this passage describes the team killing many of its sled dogs for food, a common practice of that era; it is not included. This first account says the clear weather and the 88° 16′ observation came on December 8; Chapter XII of the same book places them on December 7. Stretch readers can discuss why an early report and a later chapter might differ. The team was five men: Amundsen, Bjaaland, Hanssen, Hassel and Wisting (named in Chapter XII and in Scott’s journal).
Likely misconceptions: that more transitions are always better (choose the one that shows the true relationship); that a conclusion must begin “In conclusion”; that the Pole is at the top of a mountain (it is on a high plateau).
Supports: give a date strip for students to place six events on. Provide conclusion frames: “Next time you …, remember …” Stretch: rewrite Amundsen’s December 10-13 list as full sentences and decide which version a visitor would prefer.
Answer guide: sample timeline card: “December 17, 1911. Amundsen’s team leaves a small tent called Polheim at the South Pole and starts home.” Sample conclusion: “The ice did not stop them, and their careful measurements proved where they had been.”
Project Gutenberg, The South Pole by Roald Amundsen, translated by A. G. Chater (1912; New York: Lee Keedick, 1913), eBook #4229 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
Roald Amundsen of Norway led the first team to reach the South Pole, in December 1911. His book The South Pole was translated into English by A. G. Chater and published in London in 1912 and in New York in 1913. It opens with “The First Account,” a short report of the journey, before the long chapters tell it in detail.
In this passage the team has just climbed a huge, cracked glacier onto the high plateau of Antarctica. Follow the dates. Notice how Amundsen leads up to the arrival, what he describes when they get there and how he sums up the trip in his final sentence.
Words to know: crevasses and crevices are cracks in ice; elevation means height above the sea; hypsometer and aneroid barometer are instruments for finding height; reckoning means working out position from distance and direction traveled; lat. means latitude; depot means a stored pile of supplies; plateau means high, flat land; pennant means a long, narrow flag.
On December 1 we left the glacier in high spirits. It was cut up by innumerable crevasses and holes. We were now at a height of 9,370 feet. […] This part of our march was the most unpleasant of the whole trip. On December 2 we reached our greatest elevation. According to the hypsometer and our aneroid barometer we were at a height of 11,075 feet — this was in lat. 87° 51′. On December 8 the bad weather came to an end, the sun shone on us once more, and we were able to take our observations again. It proved that the observations and our reckoning of the distance covered gave exactly the same result — namely, 88° 16′ S. lat. Before us lay an absolutely flat plateau, only broken by small crevices. In the afternoon we passed 88° 23′, Shackleton’s farthest south. We pitched our camp in 88° 25′, and established our last depot — No. 10. […] We reached 88° 29′ on December 9. On December 10, 88° 56′; December 11, 89° 15′; December 12, 89° 30′; December 13, 89° 45′.
Up to this moment the observations and our reckoning had shown a surprising agreement. We reckoned that we should be at the Pole on December 14. On the afternoon of that day we had brilliant weather — a light wind from the south-east with a temperature of -10° F. The sledges were going very well. The day passed without any occurrence worth mentioning, and at three o’clock in the afternoon we halted, as according to our reckoning we had reached our goal.
We all assembled about the Norwegian flag — a handsome silken flag — which we took and planted all together, and gave the immense plateau on which the Pole is situated the name of “King Haakon VII.’s Plateau.”
[…]
On December 17 we were ready to go. We raised on the spot a little circular tent, and planted above it the Norwegian flag and the Fram’s pennant. The Norwegian camp at the South Pole was given the name of “Polheim.” The distance from our winter quarters to the Pole was about 870 English miles, so that we had covered on an average 15 1/2 miles a day.
Source: Project Gutenberg, The South Pole by Roald Amundsen, translated by A. G. Chater (1912; New York: Lee Keedick, 1913), eBook #4229 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)