compare the purposes of a National Weather Service cold-safety page and “To Build a Fire,” and explain how each author conveys that purpose.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Which would make you more careful on a freezing day: a list of safety tips or a story about someone who got hurt? Explain in two sentences.
A government safety page and London's story both describe what cold does to hands and feet. Do you predict they agree?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same danger, different purposes. The NWS page and London’s story both deal with deadly cold. The page’s purpose is to inform and protect. London’s purpose is to tell a gripping story and make readers think about human limits. Purpose shapes every choice an author makes.
How purpose is conveyed. Look at structure (steps and headings, or scenes and suspense), voice (you-commands, or a narrator) and evidence (facts and advice, or a character’s experience).
Worked example 1: commands. Chloe notices the page talks to the reader directly: “dress in layers,” “Keep your skin dry.” She writes, “The commands show the page’s purpose is to tell readers exactly what to do.”
Worked example 2: showing, not telling. Marcus finds the same fact in the story. The page says frostbite “can happen in minutes, especially on the extremities such as fingers.” In 1.05, London shows it happening: the man “tugged with his numbed fingers” at moccasin strings “like rods of steel.” Marcus writes, “The page states the fact. The story makes us live through it.” Before quoting, he checks each line against the passage it came from.
A model comparison. Both texts warn about cold, but in different ways. The NWS page informs readers with direct advice: “Mittens are better than gloves. Keep your skin dry.” London instead shows a character whose wet feet become “like sheaths of iron.” The page tells us what to do; the story makes us feel why it matters.
Evaluate the effect. Which text would help you more on a real trail? Which would you remember longer? Both answers can be true.
Make a two-column chart: NWS page / London’s story. Fill it as you answer.
Write a comparison paragraph.
Prompt: How do the NWS page and “To Build a Fire” convey different purposes about the same danger? Write 6-8 sentences. Checklist: (1) a claim naming both purposes; (2) one exact quotation from the page and one from a London passage we read (1.03-1.05, 1.10), checked against the text; (3) an explanation of how each quotation shows purpose; (4) a transition such as while, however or in contrast.
Anthology idea: survival stories feel real when the facts are right. Write one true fact about a danger you might put in your own story and where you would check it.
We compared a safety page and a story. Next we return to Rikki-tikki for the final battle and see how he has changed.
Exit ticket: name one thing a story can do that a safety page cannot, and one thing a safety page can do better.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 3, reading 8, mini lesson 8, guided practice 9, comparison paragraph 12.
Source note: the page is a U.S. government work (NOAA National Weather Service), opened 2026-11-20. Our passage skips the page’s notes on caffeine, alcohol and cigarettes and its frostbite first-aid list; preview before projecting the whole page. Emphasize that in real danger, students should get indoors and to an adult; the class is not first-aid training.
Quotation check: students quote London from earlier passages. Have them find each line in the 1.03-1.05 or 1.10 passage before using it; a remembered line may come from a part we skipped.
Likely misconceptions: that fiction has no purpose beyond entertainment; that informational text cannot have a point of view (the page clearly wants to change behavior).
Supports: the two-column chart; sentence starters “While the page ___, the story ___.” Stretch: the page says to “Hold onto another person or animal” for warmth (first-aid list, not in our passage). How does that connect to the man and the dog?
Sample response: The NWS page and London’s story both warn about deep cold, but they have different purposes. The page informs readers with commands such as “Keep your skin dry.” Its short steps make it easy to follow in an emergency. In contrast, London shows the danger through a character: after the man breaks through the ice, “the thick German socks were like sheaths of iron.” The story makes readers feel the danger, while the page tells them how to avoid it.
NOAA National Weather Service, Cold Weather Safety: During Extremely Cold Weather · U.S. government work, public domain
About the page. The National Weather Service is the U.S. government agency that forecasts the weather and warns people about dangerous conditions. This page tells people what to do if they must go outside in extreme cold.
What it says. Dress in layers, cover bare skin, get out of the wind and change into dry clothes if you get wet. Frostbite can happen in minutes, mostly on fingers, toes, noses and ears. To protect the organs inside the body, the body cuts blood flow to the hands and feet, and they can freeze. The page says mittens are better than gloves and skin should stay dry. If body temperature drops below 95 degrees, a person has hypothermia, which is dangerous.
Words to know. Frostbite is skin and the tissue under it freezing. Hypothermia is a dangerously low body temperature. Extremities are the hands, feet, nose and ears. Circulation is the flow of blood through the body. Windchill is how cold the air feels on skin when wind is blowing.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
If you or someone you care about must venture outdoors during extreme cold this winter, dress in layers. Cover exposed skin to reduce your risk of frostbite or hypothermia. Try to seek shelter from the wind as much as possible while outside. Once inside again, change into dry clothing immediately if you are wet. Watch for frostbite and hypothermia, and take immediate action upon the first detection of either.
[…]
Frostbite can happen in minutes, especially on the extremities such as fingers, toes, nose and ears, but can affect any area of exposed skin.
[…]
Frostbite happens when the body’s survival mechanisms kick in during extremely cold weather. To protect the vital inner organs, the body cuts circulation to your extremities: feet, hands, nose, etc., which eventually freeze. To avoid frostbite, stay inside during severe cold, especially when the windchill is -50°F or below. If you must go out, try to cover every part of your body: ears, nose, toes and fingers, etc. Mittens are better than gloves. Keep your skin dry. Stay out of the wind when possible.
[…]
When your body temperature sinks below 95°F, you have hypothermia, a serious health hazard that occurs when body temperature is lowered too much.
Source: NOAA National Weather Service, Cold Weather Safety: During Extremely Cold Weather (weather.gov)