determine the meaning of figurative and technical words in Shackleton’s account of the loss of the Endurance, using context, word parts and reference tools.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Write two sentences about a ship trapped in ice. In the first, use only plain facts. In the second, describe the ship as if it were alive. Which sentence makes a reader feel more?
What sound do you predict penguins made as the ship was being crushed?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three kinds of word meaning. A word’s literal meaning is its dictionary meaning. A figurative meaning stretches it to make a comparison. A technical meaning belongs to a field, such as sailing. Good readers notice which kind they are reading, because each needs a different strategy.
Strategies. For a figurative phrase, ask what is compared and what they share. For a technical word, use context clues nearby, word parts and, when needed, a dictionary or glossary. Then reread the sentence with the meaning in place.
Worked example 1: a simile. Sofia reads “the ship was bending like a bow under titanic pressure.” A bow, the kind that shoots arrows, curves when pulled tight. So the ship’s long body was curving under the ice. Titanic means huge, from the giant Titans of Greek myth. The simile helps a reader picture how strong the ice was.
Worked example 2: technical words from context. Andre meets “The butts of planking were opened four and five inches on the starboard side.” He knows planking from the earlier phrase “starting of a trenail or plank.” Butts must be the ends where planks meet. If those joints opened four or five inches, cold sea water could get in. He checks the end of the passage: the ship is “crushed beyond all hope of ever being righted.”
Personification that builds. Shackleton gives the ship a voice (“whispers of our ship’s distress”), a will (“she resisted”) and a body (“her wounds gaping”). By the end the ship is “giving up her sentient life.” The comparisons grow stronger as the ship gets closer to its end.
Why it matters. Word choices show an author’s feelings. A plain report might say the ship broke. Shackleton’s words show that, to a sailor, “his ship is more than a floating home.”
Use the passage. Highlight technical words in one color and figurative phrases in another.
Build a word study, then write.
Word study: choose two technical words (for example timbers, planking, starboard, trenail) and two figurative phrases. For each technical word, write the clue you used and the meaning. For each figurative phrase, write what is compared and the feeling it creates.
Write a paragraph (5-6 sentences): How does Shackleton's language make the loss of the Endurance feel like the death of a living thing? Quote at least three phrases.
Shackleton’s crew lost their ship but stayed alive. Next we leave Earth and read how NASA told the story of Apollo 8 behind the Moon.
Exit ticket: write one technical word you learned today and use it correctly in a sentence about a ship.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 5, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, word study and paragraph 8.
Text notes: the cuts skip a paragraph on the sky and the order to move boats and stores to the ice, and the end of the penguin paragraph. All 28 men of the ship’s party survived the expedition in the end; the passage says only that they were “alive and well” on October 27, so keep the full rescue story for students who ask.
Likely misconceptions: that “titanic” refers to the Titanic ship; that personification means the author is confused; that every unusual word is figurative.
Supports: a labeled ship diagram (bow, stern, starboard, port, planking). Stretch: how does the connotation of “dared” differ from “tried”?
Answer guide: “little” shrinks the ship against “Millions of tons of ice,” making the fight unfair; “dared” makes the ship (and its crew) brave for facing the Antarctic. Paragraph: voice (“whispers of our ship’s distress”), will (“she resisted”), wounds (“her wounds gaping”), death (“giving up her sentient life”), and a mourning song (“a dirge for the ship”).
Sir Ernest Shackleton, South (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #5199 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #5199
About the text. In 1915 Shackleton’s ship, the Endurance, was trapped in the frozen Weddell Sea near Antarctica. For months the ice drifted with the ship locked inside it. In this passage, from late October 1915, the ice begins to crush the ship. The last paragraph is Shackleton quoting his own diary for October 27.
What to notice. Shackleton mixes ship words (timbers, planking, starboard) with comparisons that make the ship seem alive. Look for both kinds. Notice that his crew survives the loss: “we are alive and well.” British spellings such as centred are copied as printed.
Words to know. Pressure here is the push of moving ice. Timbers and planking are the wooden beams and boards of a ship. A trenail is a wooden peg that holds planks together. Starboard is the right side of a ship, facing forward. Inexorably means in a way that cannot be stopped. Sentient means able to feel.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
The roar of pressure could be heard all around us. New ridges were rising, and I could see as the day wore on that the lines of major disturbance were drawing nearer to the ship. The Endurance suffered some strains at intervals. Listening below, I could hear the creaking and groaning of her timbers, the pistol-like cracks that told of the starting of a trenail or plank, and the faint, indefinable whispers of our ship’s distress.
[…]
At 7 p.m. very heavy pressure developed, with twisting strains that racked the ship fore and aft. The butts of planking were opened four and five inches on the starboard side, and at the same time we could see from the bridge that the ship was bending like a bow under titanic pressure. Almost like a living creature, she resisted the forces that would crush her; but it was a one-sided battle. Millions of tons of ice pressed inexorably upon the little ship that had dared the challenge of the Antarctic.
[…]
A strange occurrence was the sudden appearance of eight emperor penguins from a crack 100 yds. away at the moment when the pressure upon the ship was at its climax. They walked a little way towards us, halted, and after a few ordinary calls proceeded to utter weird cries that sounded like a dirge for the ship.
[…]
Then came a fateful day—Wednesday, October 27. […]
“After long months of ceaseless anxiety and strain, after times when hope beat high and times when the outlook was black indeed, the end of the Endurance has come. But though we have been compelled to abandon the ship, which is crushed beyond all hope of ever being righted, we are alive and well, and we have stores and equipment for the task that lies before us. The task is to reach land with all the members of the Expedition. It is hard to write what I feel. To a sailor his ship is more than a floating home, and in the Endurance I had centred ambitions, hopes, and desires. Now, straining and groaning, her timbers cracking and her wounds gaping, she is slowly giving up her sentient life at the very outset of her career.
Source: Sir Ernest Shackleton, South (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #5199 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)