review theme, summary, evidence, the speaker’s point of view and figurative language by comparing two Emily Dickinson poems.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Your anthology draft is with your revision plan. Today we sharpen reading skills for the unit check. Quick write: think of a long, hard night, real or in a story. What finally comes after it? One word, then one sentence.
How confident are you that you can I can find a theme and explain it with evidence.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review the moves. On the unit check you will read a new passage and show five skills: state a theme, write an objective summary, cite evidence, explain point of view and purpose, and interpret figurative language. Poems are a perfect workout because every word counts.
Theme. A theme is a full-sentence message about life, not one word. “Hardship” is a topic. “Everyone faces dark times, but they do not last forever” is a theme.
Figurative language. In the first poem, night and morning are metaphors for bad times and good times. “Some lose their way” among the stars and mists, but the poem ends “Afterwards — day!” In the second poem, the speaker uses a simile: she thought peace had come “as wrecked men deem they sight the land.” The “fictitious shores” are false hopes, and the “harbor” is the real end of her trouble.
Worked example 1: Gabriel compares themes. “The first poem says hard times are part of everyone’s life, but they end: ‘Afterwards — day!’ The second poem is darker. The speaker has believed many times that her troubles were over, only to find ‘many the fictitious shores / Before the harbor lie.’ Still, a harbor does lie ahead. Together, they suggest that survival means enduring, even when relief comes later than we hope.”
Worked example 2: Leah writes an objective summary. Leah’s first try: “This is a sad poem that I didn’t like.” That is an opinion. Revision: “The speaker says she has often thought peace had come when it had not, like shipwrecked sailors who think they see land in the middle of the sea. She has learned that many false shores come before the real harbor.”
Point of view. The first speaker says our, as if she speaks for everyone, and ends with an exclamation of hope. The second says I and admits she struggled “hopelessly.” Ask: how does the speaker’s point of view shape what the poem says about survival?
Work with a partner on the first four questions, then alone. Use the poems under “The text.”
Review on your own.
Write an objective summary of the first poem (“Our share of night to bear”) in two or three sentences. Then write one theme of the poem as a full sentence.
Author's purpose: why might Dickinson end the first poem with a dash and an exclamation point (“Afterwards — day!”)? Explain how the ending supports her purpose.
A theme is a sentence about life. Evidence is the poet’s exact words. You now have both.
Exit ticket: which skill do you feel strongest in, and which will you review tonight before the unit check?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 8, guided practice with group talk 15, independent review 7, closure 1.
Edition notes: the poems are copied from the 1890 and 1891 texts as Project Gutenberg #12242 prints them, with the editors’ Roman numerals (II in the “Life” section of the first series; XLVII in the second) and the file’s double hyphen in “Afterwards — day!” The labels in parentheses are ours. Modern editions restore Dickinson’s own dashes and capitals and number the poems differently. “Hope” is the thing with feathers is left out on purpose because ELA 5 I teaches it. The summary’s facts about Dickinson’s life are established background, not from this file.
Likely misconceptions: that the theme is one word; that the speaker is always the poet herself; that XLVII is about a real shipwreck; that “blank” means empty paper (here it means an empty space in our lives to be filled with joy or with scorn).
Supports: read each poem aloud twice; give a two-column organizer (line / what it means). Stretch: compare either poem with Shackleton’s rescue in 1.20. This lesson is the flex review lesson; use the exit tickets to group students for a ten-minute reteach.
Answer guide: sample summary: “The speaker says that everyone gets a share of night and of morning, of happiness and of scorn. Some people lose their way among the stars and mists, but day comes afterwards.” Theme: “Everyone faces dark times, but they pass.” Purpose answer: the dash makes readers pause, like waiting through the night, and the exclamation point makes the arrival of day joyful, so the ending leaves readers with hope.
Project Gutenberg, Poems by Emily Dickinson, Three Series, Complete (first and second series published 1890 and 1891), eBook #12242 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In Part 1 you read two Emily Dickinson poems, “Experience” and “Aspiration.” Dickinson (1830-1886) wrote almost 1,800 poems at her home in Amherst, Massachusetts, but very few were printed while she lived. After her death, friends edited and published them. The first poem here appeared in Poems in 1890 and the second in Poems, Second Series in 1891. Neither has a title; the editors gave them numbers.
Each poem has a speaker, the voice in the poem. The first speaker talks about everyone (“our share”). The second speaker (“I”) compares past hopes to shipwrecked sailors who think they see land. Read each poem twice, then compare what each says about getting through hard times.
Words to know: share means the part each person gets; bliss means great happiness; scorning means being looked down on; deem means believe; struggle slacker means stop fighting so hard; fictitious means not real.
II.
Our share of night to bear,
Our share of morning,
Our blank in bliss to fill,
Our blank in scorning.Here a star, and there a star,
Some lose their way.
Here a mist, and there a mist,
Afterwards — day!XLVII.
I many times thought peace had come,
When peace was far away;
As wrecked men deem they sight the land
At centre of the sea,And struggle slacker, but to prove,
As hopelessly as I,
How many the fictitious shores
Before the harbor lie.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Poems by Emily Dickinson, Three Series, Complete (first and second series published 1890 and 1891), eBook #12242 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)