cite evidence from NOAA’s page on why ocean exploration matters to support analysis of what it says explicitly and of inferences I draw from it.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. East Allegheny is hundreds of miles from any ocean. List two ways the deep ocean might still affect your life here. Star the one you are least sure about.
Does the ocean matter to people who live far from any coast?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two kinds of evidence work. Sometimes we cite a text to show what it says explicitly, right in its words. Other times we cite it to support an inference, an idea the text suggests but does not state. Both start with an exact quotation. An inference also needs a sentence of reasoning that connects the quotation to the idea.
How to quote. Copy the words exactly, put them in quotation marks and name the source: NOAA writes, “…” Quote only the words you need. Then explain them in your own words.
Worked example 1: explicit. Question: What useful things does the deep ocean hold? Lucia answers: NOAA says explicitly that “The deep ocean holds reserves of oil, gas, precious metals, and rare minerals.” The answer is right in the words, so her quotation is the proof.
Worked example 2: inference. Question: What does NOAA think happens if we do not explore? Ethan notices the question “how can we effectively manage it?” and the heading “we can’t manage what we don’t know.” He infers: NOAA suggests that without exploration we could use the ocean carelessly and leave too little for the future, because it says we must be careful “to ensure future generations can do the same.” He labels it an inference, because NOAA never says outright that resources will run out.
Generalizations. A generalization is a broad statement drawn from several details. From the food, jobs, medicine and weather details, you might generalize: The deep ocean affects daily life even far from the sea. Back it with at least two quotations.
For our labels. A reason label must quote what NOAA actually says. Watch hedging words like may: a label should not turn “may lie cures” into “holds cures.”
Use the page. Mark each answer E (explicit) or I (inference).
Write a two-part evidence response.
Part A (explicit): According to NOAA, name three things the deep ocean provides or holds. Quote each one.
Part B (inference): Why do you think NOAA asks so many questions on this page instead of only giving facts? State your inference, quote two of the questions and explain how they support your idea.
We quoted what NOAA says and what it implies. Next we read an explorer who failed, and how he explained why the journey still mattered.
Exit ticket: write one reason label for our exhibit (one sentence) that quotes NOAA exactly and does not overstate a hedged claim.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 10, response 9.
Text note: the passage is the page’s opening and its first two reason sections, copied in order; the bold lines are the page’s own headings. Remind students to quote only words shown in the passage, not words from other parts of the page.
Likely misconceptions: that an inference is a guess with no evidence; that a question in a text has no meaning as evidence; that “may” means “does.”
Supports: sentence frames: “NOAA states, ‘___.’ This shows ___.” and “From ‘___,’ I can infer ___ because ___.” Stretch: which reason would matter most to a STEM-night family, and why?
Answer guide: Part A: fisheries that provide “food, jobs, and livelihoods”; “reserves of oil, gas, precious metals, and rare minerals”; possible medicines (“may lie cures”); the ocean’s role in “the air we breathe.” Part B: the questions push readers to see that we cannot protect or use what we do not know (“can we truly say that we ‘know’ our own ocean?”; “how can we effectively manage it?”). Generalization: the deep ocean shapes food, weather and resources for everyone, even landlocked towns.
NOAA Ocean Exploration, Why Ocean Exploration Matters · U.S. government work, public domain
About the text. This page comes from NOAA Ocean Exploration, the government office whose job is exploring the unknown ocean. It is organized under bold headings, and each heading is one reason exploration matters. Today we read the opening and the first two reasons.
What to notice. NOAA asks several questions instead of only making statements. A question like “How will we know what is out there if we aren’t even looking for it?” makes a point without saying it directly. That is a clue for an inference. Also notice the word may: NOAA says cures may lie in the depths, not that they do.
Words to know. Landlocked means far from any ocean. Fisheries are places or businesses where fish are caught. Livelihoods are the ways people earn a living. Pharmaceuticals are medicines. To manage resources is to decide how they are used and protected. Conservative here means careful, not wasteful.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
Seventy percent of Earth is covered by the ocean. Ninety percent of the ocean is considered “deep,” with a depth of greater than 200 meters (656 feet). Yet only slightly more than a quarter of the ocean has been mapped at high resolution and just a fraction of that has been visually surveyed and explored. Given this, can we truly say that we “know” our own ocean? And if we don’t, how do we manage or protect it and the resources it holds?
[…]
The deep ocean impacts our very survival, yet remains poorly understood.
The ocean impacts all of us, whether you live in a coastal community or in a landlocked area. The ocean plays a role in everything from the air we breathe, the food we eat, and the transportation of the goods we buy to our daily weather and longer-term climate trends.
Most of our knowledge of the ocean lies in shallower waters. However, deeper waters continue to grow in their importance to our nation. Many fisheries are based in deep waters, providing food, jobs, and livelihoods. The deep ocean holds reserves of oil, gas, precious metals, and rare minerals. Within ocean depths may lie cures to crippling diseases and sources of other natural products with potential as pharmaceuticals, enzymes, cosmetics, and more.
How will we know what is out there if we aren’t even looking for it?
[…]
Good management of ocean resources is critical, but we can’t manage what we don’t know.
[…]
We need to be careful and conservative in how we use our ocean and its resources to ensure future generations can do the same. Careful practice requires good management that balances use, enjoyment, and protection. But if we don’t know what’s out there, how can we effectively manage it?
Source: NOAA Ocean Exploration, Why Ocean Exploration Matters (oceanexplorer.noaa.gov)