analyze how Ernest Shackleton introduces, illustrates and elaborates the idea that crossing Antarctica was worth attempting, and cite evidence for an inference about his purpose.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Someone else has already reached the South Pole. Would you still want to go to Antarctica? List one reason to go and one reason not to.
After others reached the South Pole, what goal did Shackleton choose?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How a key idea grows. Strong informational writers do not state an important idea once and move on. They introduce it (first mention), illustrate it (give an example, story or fact that shows it) and elaborate on it (add more detail, reasons or meaning). Tracking those three moves shows how an author builds understanding.
Worked example 1: introduce and illustrate. Amara tracks the idea of crossing Antarctica. Shackleton introduces it in the first sentence as the one goal left after Amundsen’s “conquest of the South Pole.” He illustrates his own path to it with a short story: he once turned back “within ninety-seven miles of our goal.”
Worked example 2: elaborate. Jonah notices the plan paragraphs add new reasons. The crossing is not only a race; it “will be a journey of great scientific importance.” Shackleton elaborates with three kinds of science: maps of mountains, magnetism and weather. Jonah writes: Shackleton develops the idea from a national goal into a scientific one.
Admitting failure. Shackleton says plainly, “We failed in this object.” Then he lists what the book still offers: “unflinching determination, supreme loyalty, and generous self-sacrifice.” An author’s choice to admit failure early can make readers trust him more.
Inference about purpose. Why print the plan in the book? We can infer that Shackleton wants readers to judge the expedition by its goals and science, not only by its result. Evidence: he calls the crossing important “apart from its historic value.”
Explorers as people. Explorers in 1914 also wanted fame for their nations: Shackleton wanted the crossing “achieved by a British Expedition.” Reasons can be mixed. A museum label can name more than one.
Use the passage. Mark I (introduce), IL (illustrate) and E (elaborate) in the margin.
Make an idea-development chart, then write.
Chart: three rows labeled Introduced, Illustrated, Elaborated. In each row, quote the words where Shackleton does that move with the idea of crossing Antarctica, and explain in a few words what it adds.
Write a paragraph (5-6 sentences): How does Shackleton develop the idea that the crossing was worth attempting? Use at least two quotations and the words introduce, illustrate or elaborate.
Shackleton explained his goal. Next we read what happened when the ice closed around his ship.
Exit ticket: name two different reasons Shackleton gives for exploring Antarctica, one about his nation and one about science.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, chart and paragraph 9.
Text notes: the preface’s long third sentence is cut after “my men”; the rest refers to World War I, which explains why readers in 1919 knew sacrifice well. The plan paragraphs are Shackleton’s own quotation of his public programme, so each opens with a quotation mark. Amundsen reached the Pole in December 1911; Scott’s party reached it in January 1912 and died on the return. Share that only if students ask; it is not in the passage.
Likely misconceptions: that the expedition reached its goal; that “elaborate” means fancy; that one quotation can show all three moves.
Supports: color-code the three moves; give a map of Antarctica showing the Weddell Sea and Ross Sea. Stretch: ask what “conquest” suggests about how explorers saw the Pole.
Answer guide: introduced: “the crossing of the South Polar continent from sea to sea”; illustrated: turning back “within ninety-seven miles of our goal,” and planning a “last great journey”; elaborated: “a journey of great scientific importance,” mountains, magnetism and weather. Inference: admitting failure early earns trust and lets him show that courage and loyalty are the real story (“records of unflinching determination”).
Sir Ernest Shackleton, South (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #5199 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #5199
About the text. Sir Ernest Shackleton was a British polar explorer. South, first published in 1919, tells the story of his 1914-1917 expedition. In the preface, the opening section of a book where the author explains it, he says why he went. The last three paragraphs come from the plan he printed to win public interest before the trip.
What to notice. Shackleton names Roald Amundsen of Norway and Robert Falcon Scott of Britain, who both reached the South Pole in 1911-1912. He also admits “We failed in this object.” Notice how one idea, crossing the continent, appears first as a goal, then as a failure and then as science. Shackleton keeps British spellings such as centred elsewhere in the book; here, notice the long sentences.
Words to know. An expedition is a long journey for a purpose. To be morally certain is to feel sure without proof. Unflinching means not backing away from pain or danger. Magnetic observations measure Earth’s magnetism with a compass needle. Meteorological means about weather.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
After the conquest of the South Pole by Amundsen, who, by a narrow margin of days only, was in advance of the British Expedition under Scott, there remained but one great main object of Antarctic journeyings—the crossing of the South Polar continent from sea to sea.
When I returned from the Nimrod Expedition on which we had to turn back from our attempt to plant the British flag on the South Pole, being beaten by stress of circumstances within ninety-seven miles of our goal, my mind turned to the crossing of the continent, for I was morally certain that either Amundsen or Scott would reach the Pole on our own route or a parallel one. After hearing of the Norwegian success I began to make preparations to start a last great journey—so that the first crossing of the last continent should be achieved by a British Expedition.
We failed in this object, but the story of our attempt is the subject for the following pages, and I think that though failure in the actual accomplishment must be recorded, there are chapters in this book of high adventure, strenuous days, lonely nights, unique experiences, and, above all, records of unflinching determination, supreme loyalty, and generous self-sacrifice on the part of my men
[…]
“The first crossing of the Antarctic continent, from sea to sea via the Pole, apart from its historic value, will be a journey of great scientific importance.
“The distance will be roughly 1800 miles, and the first half of this, from the Weddell Sea to the Pole, will be over unknown ground. Every step will be an advance in geographical science. It will be learned whether the great Victoria chain of mountains, which has been traced from the Ross Sea to the Pole, extends across the continent and thus links up (except for the ocean break) with the Andes of South America, and whether the great plateau around the Pole dips gradually towards the Weddell Sea.
“Continuous magnetic observations will be taken on the journey. The route will lead towards the Magnetic Pole, and the determination of the dip of the magnetic needle will be of importance in practical magnetism. The meteorological conditions will be carefully noted, and this should help to solve many of our weather problems.
Source: Sir Ernest Shackleton, South (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #5199 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)