interpret the extended metaphors in two Emily Dickinson poems, explain how the speaker’s point of view is developed and state a theme each poem conveys.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Think of a time you tried something new and scary, like a first day, a tryout or a high dive. Write three words for how you moved or felt.
A poem's speaker says, “I stepped from plank to plank… About my feet the sea.” Is the speaker probably really walking on boards over an ocean?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
An extended metaphor is a comparison that runs through a whole poem. In “Experience,” the whole poem compares living through a dangerous time to walking across planks with the sea below.
The speaker’s point of view. The speaker is the voice of a poem; it may or may not be the poet. Dickinson develops the speaker’s point of view through what the speaker notices and admits. This speaker looks back and confesses not knowing whether each step would be the last.
Worked example 1: decode the metaphor. Ben makes a chart. Planks = small steps through a hard time. The sea = the danger of failing. Stars about my head = hope or something big above. Then he reads the last line: the careful, wobbly walk is what “Some call experience.”
Worked example 2: hyperbole with a purpose. Ana reads “Our statures touch the skies.” No one is that tall. The exaggeration means that when we rise to a challenge, we become far greater than we knew. The second stanza adds that heroism “Would be a daily thing” if fear did not make us shrink ourselves.
From images to theme. A theme is a message about life in a full sentence. “Experience” might say: We gain experience by moving forward carefully even when we cannot see what is next. “Aspiration” might say: People are capable of more courage than they realize, but fear holds them back.
Reading a poem aloud. Read to the punctuation, not to the end of each line. Dickinson’s dashes ask for a pause.
Read each poem aloud twice with a partner. Then answer.
Write about one poem.
Choose one poem. Write a paragraph of 5-6 sentences that (1) explains the main metaphor or hyperbole, (2) quotes two lines exactly, with slash marks between lines, (3) describes the speaker's point of view and (4) states a theme in a full sentence.
Write your own 4-line poem about a survival moment using one extended metaphor. It can become a first page or epigraph for your anthology story.
We have now read a story, a fable-like animal tale, a shipwreck story and two poems. Next we start making sense of them: how does “To Build a Fire” end, and why?
Exit ticket: in your own words, what does Dickinson say it takes to survive?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading and read-alouds 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, writing 9.
Text notes: “Experience” is LIII and “Aspiration” XIV in the 1896 Poems, Third Series (Todd), copied from Gutenberg #12242; the editors’ titles and the printed dash (“inch, –”) are kept as printed. ELA 5 I teaches “’Hope’ is the thing with feathers,” so this course uses these two instead.
Hard lines: “Did not ourselves the cubits warp / For fear to be a king” means “if we did not shrink our own height (bend our measure) because we are afraid to be great.” Walk through it as a paraphrase together.
Likely misconceptions: that the speaker must be Dickinson; that the poem is literally about a ship; that a theme can be one word.
Supports: a metaphor decoder chart (image / stands for / clue). Stretch: why might the editors’ titles help or limit a reader?
Sample response: In “Experience,” walking from “plank to plank” with “About my feet the sea” stands for living through a risky time one careful step at a time. The speaker looks back honestly and admits not knowing if the next step would be the “final inch.” Theme: experience comes from moving forward carefully when you cannot see what is next. Comparison: the speaker moves “cautiously,” while the man thinks “the temperature did not matter.”
Emily Dickinson, Poems, Third Series (1896), in Poems: Three Series, Complete, Project Gutenberg eBook #12242 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #12242
About the poet. Emily Dickinson (1830-1886) wrote almost 1,800 poems in Amherst, Massachusetts, but very few were published while she lived. After her death, her friends Mabel Loomis Todd and T. W. Higginson edited her poems into books. These two appeared in the third book, in 1896. The titles “Experience” and “Aspiration” were added by the editors; Dickinson did not title her poems.
What to notice. Each poem is one big comparison. In the first, the speaker, the “I” of the poem, walks over the sea. In the second, “we” rise toward the sky. Ask: what is the walk, and what is the rising?
Words to know. Precarious means unsteady and risky. A gait is a way of walking. Stature is a person’s height, or their importance. To recite is to tell aloud. A cubit is an old unit of length, about the length of a forearm. To warp is to bend out of shape.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
EXPERIENCE.
I stepped from plank to plank
So slow and cautiously;
The stars about my head I felt,
About my feet the sea.I knew not but the next
Would be my final inch, —
This gave me that precarious gait
Some call experience.ASPIRATION.
We never know how high we are
Till we are called to rise;
And then, if we are true to plan,
Our statures touch the skies.The heroism we recite
Would be a daily thing,
Did not ourselves the cubits warp
For fear to be a king.
Source: Emily Dickinson, Poems, Third Series (1896), in Poems: Three Series, Complete, Project Gutenberg eBook #12242 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)